Lost the players?
We have lost 6 games in two seasons with an average losing margin of 5 points per game.
Clearly any good judge can see that the coach has lost the players.
Review Round 10 v Geelong - Friday 1 November @ GHMBA Stadium
- Thread starter brucetiki
- Start date
- Tagged users None
We have lost 6 games in two seasons with an average losing margin of 5 points per game.
Clearly any good judge can see that the coach has lost the players.
Sanfl obvious cheating
Boy, ain’t this the truth… barely looked like she could play the code
Good win but far-out we are hard to watch this year. Especially that first half. Our goal kicking this season is horrible. The umpiring is abysmal. This is the first year where I haven't bothered to watch most games live or go back and watch them later. Hard to imagine watching a team that doesn't regularly win when this is the standard.
TubbsFarquhar
TheBrownDog
We'll win a semi against Freo/Essendon. That's it though.
- Dec 29, 2000
- 25,812
- 24,151
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Was Nicks coaching the first half?
Boy, ain’t this the truth… barely looked like she could play the code
She was awful today. Simply not ready to be playing. Honestly, missing her chance for her first AFLW goal by hitting the post was probably actually her best moment of the day. The idea that she was on the ground and Ballard was in the stands befuddles me. Hell, I would have taken Varnhagen over her today.
Geez, we've been served up some frustrating football the last month! Thank goodness for Gould, even though she's a crap kick (which the commentators seem shocked about every week, lol) at least she generates shots on goal from close range, and plays within her limitations. Nobody else seems to be able to do it. Even Hatchard's goal was a clanger, had Ponter free in the goal square, could have either kicked or handballed it to her, instead just burned her and rolled it along the ground, thank goodness it went through.
The umpiring was classic Kardinia Park bullshit, just an all-time rat**** performance from the mob in green. They should hang their heads in shame.
Prowse and Biddell, phenomenal effort. How good are they? Prowse made Moloney look second-rate, and Biddell just marks everything and uses it beautifully. And Sarah Allan looked good when she went down back, even when she didn't have a player. It's not that difficult guys, we won our last flag based on having a quality loose down back (Randall in that case), why not do it again? We can't seem to kick a winning score, so how about preventing them from scoring? Footy's just not that complicated.
Marinoff with another excellent game. I would go as far as to say she's just completed the finest H&A season of any player in the history of AFLW. Randall is desperate to win another flag, you can tell. Newman excellent as well. Hatchard had a decent game, although her disposal is simply baffling at times. Put Kelly in that category as well. Jess Allan with another quality ruck performance.
Shame about Ponter, hopefully it's a short-term thing. We've carried her for most of the season because she is such an important big-game player, it would be a shame for her to miss the big games.
Anonymous games from Kustermann, Martin, and Levy. (And Allen, but I've already potted her performance.) Levy seems to thrive in close contested games, but in more open games like this one she just can't get involved with her lack of pace. It was painful watching the ball go to space with her nearby, and a Geelong player just ran past her like she wasn't even moving. Kustermann I like as a player, but I couldn't even tell you where she's playing at the moment. And Martin tried hard, but her most effective pressure acts today were spoiling Marinoff and blocking one of our I50 entries. Sadly, the cupboard is a bit bare for replacing them, especially if Ponter is injured.
Great to have (almost certainly) locked away the double chance. Who knows, maybe things will finally come together when it really counts? But I doubt it. Another qualifying loss, semi win, and prelim exit for my money.
Last edited:
I'm not saying this will happen but we could lose the first final win the second and face hawthorn who we beat quite easily early in the season.
We could quite easily arse our way into the GF.
Am I missing something?
Sent from my SM-T220 using Tapatalk
Hawthorn will likely lose to Brisbane in the QF and end up facing North in the prelim.
Oh, and it has to be said - geez Georgie Prespakis is a bloody good player. I know that's nothing new, but every time I watch her I'm impressed.
Certainly. And it's not outside of the realm of possibility that we somehow get up over North and end up in the box seat ourselves.
But you'd have to think the odds are pretty high that it ends up being North vs Hawthorn, Brisbane vs Adelaide for the two prelims.
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 62,226
- 166,274
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #65
I don't think we can play all of Mueller, Tonon and Allen in the side in addition to the talls of Prowse, Biddell and Allan. Obviously the latter three play.
Najwa Allen is not a forward. We tried to hide her there and it didn't work. Can't play Sarah Allan forward either but at least she's good back
Tonon is an outside player and shouldn't be playing defense. Really struggles to actually defend especially in the air.
Mueller well below her best this season.
We need to replace some of those medium defenders with attack off half back
Najwa Allen is not a forward. We tried to hide her there and it didn't work. Can't play Sarah Allan forward either but at least she's good back
Tonon is an outside player and shouldn't be playing defense. Really struggles to actually defend especially in the air.
Mueller well below her best this season.
We need to replace some of those medium defenders with attack off half back
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 62,226
- 166,274
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #66
I'm sure this is the case for most teams given the state of the competition but I reckon we only have 13 players actually up to the standard required on the entire list
Marinoff, Hatchard, Randall, Biddell, Gould, Prowse, S. Allan, J. Allan, Newman, Ponter, Charlton, Kelly and Goodwin.
Maybe Thompson sneaks into that group (she was there based on past form) and I have hope for Kustermann and Boileau. Jones obviously injured.
So every week we are going to have a fair few anonymous performances and we really heavily rely on individual brilliance from those in the group I mentioned, rather than structural wins or tactics
SLT has been pretty good this year, albeit she was down today. I'd put Mueller in the list as well.
Najwa Allen has looked good in the past, but was clearly enormously underdone tonight. Munyard has been a bit better this season, jury is still out on her for me. Her improved pace has been a welcome surprise this season.
But I agree, our team is, by and large, carried by a small number of very good players. Marinoff/Hatchard/Allan in the midfield, Biddell/Prowse/Allan down back, Kelly/Newman on the wings, and Gould up forward (+ Ponter when she's playing well, which is not this year). And Randall wherever she plays in any given week.
Even the likes of Charlton, Goodwin, etc are good but they're just playing bit part roles, and they've had some poor performances along the way.
I reckon that the best teams (North, Brisbane etc) have a much better "bottom six" than we do. But our core spine is as good as any going around.
Or…….the other teams are improving and we have not had access to any potentially elite young players in recent years.
Our best half dozen are very good but we drop off alarmingly. Marinoff, Hatchard, Randall and Biddell do most of the heavy lifting. Ponter is great when she is on, Sarah Allan has struggled following her injury last year and we really miss the spark of Eloise Jones. We rely on Gould to kick most of our goals and Jess Allan wins the ruck but doesn’t have enough influence around the ground.
We do have some good young women who have improved this year but we need more quality in attack. Clarke has tried Randall, Biddell, Allan, Hatchard and Jones in attack but they are all better on ball or in defence.
What coaching moves would you suggest?
Aren't we playing a VFL favourite in a Melbourne prelim in that scenario?
Unless we win in week 1, we're pretty much guaranteed to get rogered by the umpires in the prelim.
Just got home and watched the replay and geezus those umps are ****ing atrocious
our goalkicking and forward entries are just not clicking at all
Wish we could have Biddell at each end of the ground to get marks
Gould has become probably most important player behind Marinoff
our goalkicking and forward entries are just not clicking at all
Wish we could have Biddell at each end of the ground to get marks
Gould has become probably most important player behind Marinoff
There was also that moment in the 3rd where Martin just randomly kept on running after the ball after Ponter had grabbed it just inside 50 and Martin just ran straight into her and dispossessed her, has absolute tunnel vision. Also she isn’t alone in doing this but she also always does that really annoying thing where if a teammate is under pressure from an opponent or getting tackled instead of stopping and standing a few metres away from them so she can be used to get a handball out she instead just runs into the contest instead & ends up being totally useless.
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Well it is. He clearly isn’t doing skills training. If you see a deficiency, that’s what you need to train for to fix said deficiency.
I understand Marino has had a huge year and is getting better than just accumulating possessions and tackles although a lot are 2 nd tackles .
But how could she be our best player ahead of Gould and Biddell who won the game for us and even thought Hatchard had a better 4 qtr game than Marinoff, though still struggle to understand why Hatchard doesn't have more impact with her size and ability apart from some strong marking especially with her disposal.
Often on here I have read how bad umpiring was against us and thought poster was over reacting but that umpiring last night was disgusting biased matched by biased commentators .
But how could she be our best player ahead of Gould and Biddell who won the game for us and even thought Hatchard had a better 4 qtr game than Marinoff, though still struggle to understand why Hatchard doesn't have more impact with her size and ability apart from some strong marking especially with her disposal.
Often on here I have read how bad umpiring was against us and thought poster was over reacting but that umpiring last night was disgusting biased matched by biased commentators .
Mileratkinsshow
Team Captain
- Feb 14, 2016
- 404
- 473
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
One of the players I have hopes for is Tonon. This year she seems to have put on a bit more size and seems to be able to hold her own both in her marking and in the penetration and accuracy of her kicks. By no means the finished product at this stage but I think she may be valuable as another forward or flanker, and I hope next year would add to that “up to the standard group”. She’s still pretty young.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Similar threads
