Round 14 Discussion

[Jonzi]

Hope scooter plays...opponent has the E on greenwood with no other loophole options

 

[vast]

Bombers Vs Eagles GF

Not that it will happen but that would be a dream match up for us. Or anyone really...

 

[fuic08]

Found it

http://www.aflcommunityclub.com.au/...oach_AFL/2017_Laws_of_Australian_Football.pdf


Interestingly, Rule 12.2 is missing

Not specifying about the padding is weird

 

[Broar]

Adelaide lose to Hawthorn.
GWS lose to Carlton.
Bulldogs get smashed by Melbourne.
Geelong lose to West Coast.
Tigers can't win close games.
Port get smashed by Bombers.

Who the f*ck is going to win the Premiership?

So your telling me we are a chance?

 

[Hava Alle]

It's gonna take that one week where the shoulder is back to normal. It's not like it's a longstanding injury, it's an unfortunate dislocation. As soon as he gets confidence back with it he'll go boom.

Having said that I wish I had brought in Zorks over Rocky because I don't know when that will be. Could be this week, could be three weeks. Until it does you can bank on 80-90 scores.

Once you dislocate a shoulder it needs surgery, 100% will have a reco in the off season if he makes it that far.

 

[reload141]

If u have him dont u hope that everyweek???

Afraid to tackle now. Really big scores will be few and far between

He'll be right, he's capable of 150-180 and at the right time can win you a game in finals

 

[Hairy Lager]

Adelaide lose to Hawthorn.
GWS lose to Carlton.
Bulldogs get smashed by Melbourne.
Geelong lose to West Coast.
Tigers can't win close games.
Port get smashed by Bombers.

Who the f*ck is going to win the Premiership?

Freo

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

3/300

Greenwood
TitchMitch
Spud Laird, should have loopholed him since soud Buckly dropped Shazberg.

All downhill from here.

 

[Biggie]

Adelaide lose to Hawthorn.
GWS lose to Carlton.
Bulldogs get smashed by Melbourne.
Geelong lose to West Coast.
Tigers can't win close games.
Port get smashed by Bombers.

Who the f*ck is going to win the Premiership?

Shudders...

Sydney from 7th

 

[Jiska]

Not specifying about the padding is weird

Why? They say the goal line. There's no padding on the line.

12.1.2 (a) talks about if the ball hits the padding.

 

[vast]

He'll be right, he's capable of 150-180 and at the right time can win you a game in finals

He is more likely to be on ice.for the rest of the year come finals tha scoring 150 +

 

[srobbo]

Greeny 127 pre scaling....who'd have thought?? F6 lock for me now given the inconsistency fwd premo scoring.

Cheers Sandi you soft campaigner

 

[Mullarkey]

Burton robbed of a ton

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Titch +6 DT
+1 SC
WTF is this shit?

He just laid a tackle then got a mark and an effective kick and got 2 points! I've watched every score and he's been robbed. It's beyond a joke! Sloane got 2 points for a handball in a tackle that went to ground, Titch never got a point for two of those. Bont got 4 points for a tunnel ball tap to a teammate, Titch got 2 points for a handball through legs to a teammate with someone sitting on his back also he tunnel balled tapped to a teammate once and got nothing!

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Karl Lagerfeld. I didn't realise that Obese Arachnid was quite the fashionista

I got style, not just your average spider.

 

[Huttabito]

Freo

This guy gets it.

 

[Mullarkey]

Subject to Law 12.2, a Goal is scored when the football is Kicked completely over the Goal Line by a Player of the attacking Team without being touched

How much clearer can it be???? The ball hitting the padding to cause a behind is a seperate unrelated clause.

So what happened in the review for it to be called a point? It cleared the line and hit the back of the padding off hands

 

[pincrusher]

Brought in Laird this week as an anti POD, watch Bont go 130

I'll see myself out.....

 

[Jiska]

Adelaide lose to Hawthorn.
GWS lose to Carlton.
Bulldogs get smashed by Melbourne.
Geelong lose to West Coast.
Tigers can't win close games.
Port get smashed by Bombers.

Who the f*ck is going to win the Premiership?

Melb beat Adel by 40 in Adel

Melb lose to Hawks, Freo & Norf

 

[Hairy Lager]

Bitchall needs some footballing sessions from our man Ollie.
big bootaaaaah

 

[Mullarkey]

Why? They say the goal line. There's no padding on the line.

12.1.2 (a) talks about if the ball hits the padding.

Padding is fatter than the line

 

[Jiska]

So what happened in the review for it to be called a point? It cleared the line and hit the back of the padding off hands

Wrong call, which was my initial point

 

[KardiniaPark]

Agreed. May as well let the umpire get it wrong and not have the 5 minute delay to get a wrong decision.

I would so much prefer to get things wrong. Cricket is ruined as well. How the hell can it be a good thing to have 70,000 people cheer for a wicket, then have it overturned 90 seconds later after 10 replays? It just sucks the life out of the crowd. They are both games of passion, and the argument of 'oh what's if it costs them a World Cup or a grand final is just so ridiculous.

It's reflective of the real world, where we are all over officiated. Where rules are made to save everyone from themselves. It can't be done, you can't keep everyone happy. There's going to be mistakes, in life and sport, just let it be.

 

[gutsroy]

Good stuff to those who have Greenwood on field / are able to loop, getting that from a rookie is the duck's guts, absolute manna from heaven..

 

[Jiska]

Padding is fatter than the line

So? Show me in the rules where the ball has to clear the padding.