Round 14 Trades

[evo]

Whats the general consensus now for the better player for D6 out of Ox and Saad to take to the finish?

I've been leaning to Oxley up until he got another vest again on the weekend.

Now thinking Saad might be the better, and he has DPP.

 

[Super Hans]

Ox has to go. Hoping I can get Docherty, if not I'll probably go Lonie > Steele and Ox > Picken.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Have 7 trades left and need to deal with Sloane.
Choices are:
Sloane > Rocky (if playing)
Sloane > Gawn (via Gray/Martin/Swan)
Sloane > any defender ~$500k (via Hodge)
Thoughts?

Macae looks good.

 

[stevebbb]

Macae looks good.

PISS OFF HE'S MINE!!!!

 

[KardiniaPark]

Whats the general consensus now for the better player for D6 out of Ox and Saad to take to the finish?

I've been leaning to Oxley up until he got another vest again on the weekend.

Now thinking Saad might be the better, and he has DPP.

I'd take Saad just for the consistency. (Watch him throw up a 13 today ha)

 

[DT_35]

Don't even f****** know anymore. Picked up Sloane this week, nek minut, GONE. Cripps is my M9 so won't hurt THAT much. Just means I waste 2 trades. Probably look at Hodge after next week.

Trade out Newnes for Houli last week, nek minut, Newnes starts smashing out 130's while Houli can't even conjure a 65>

So it's a given that whoever I bring in for Sloane (Hodge) will go down for the year

 

[Figster]

Was looking at doing Hogan > Gawn as my F6 and back up ruck but with Sloane gone not sure what to do now? Have 7 trades and with LTI's popping up every week dont want to burn 2 trades this week.

 

[Woodie99]

I was 1 of the more than 13k people how traded in Sloane this week (also got Hodge)

What is everyone going to do with Sloane? He will be around the 480k.

I think he has to be traded, I can't keep that amount of $ on the bench for the 4-6 weeks. So for me trading is the only option even though I only have 8 left with 100k in the bank, my first thought is to get Rocky if back next week, his BE is 64 & will be a straight swap price wise leaving the 100k to use elsewhere.

Would like to hear from Sloane owners what they are going to do.

 

[GOAUS!]

Let me know what you're doing with Sloane Jiska

 

[rocker_oz33]

Ive had Sloane since rd 2 held him over hes first injury.
Hes gone for JPK who also cheap also held rocky.
So doing GnR patience has not worked more like estranged.

 

[Lums23]

I was 1 of the more than 13k people how traded in Sloane this week (also got Hodge)

What is everyone going to do with Sloane? He will be around the 480k.

I think he has to be traded, I can't keep that amount of $ on the bench for the 4-6 weeks. So for me trading is the only option even though I only have 8 left with 100k in the bank, my first thought is to get Rocky if back next week, his BE is 64 & will be a straight swap price wise leaving the 100k to use elsewhere.

Would like to hear from Sloane owners what they are going to do.

Just about have to trade him I think. Personally, I have 60k ish in the bank so I think I'll find another 70+ and trade him to someone like Priddis or Ward who will be consistently good and has minimal injury history

 

[David Szabo]

As a Melbourne supporter do you see Gawn as fools gold as one poster put it this week?

No, Gawn has been given his opportunity to play by Paul Roos in a team that Roos is rebuilding and reassuring confidence in from the Neald Days

Gawn was used sparingly by other managers. Yes, He has had his injuries, BUT he always excelled at VFL level, just wasnt ever able to cement a place in the clubs best 22 due Jamar and big Stef Martin. Gawn has been in the system a few years now, he is taking his chances, and yeah, he isnt going to score 140's every week, but Barring injury is a safe bet for a bit of cash and 80 or more every week from what he has shown

 

[Woodie99]

Just about have to trade him I think. Personally, I have 60k ish in the bank so I think I'll find another 70+ and trade him to someone like Priddis or Ward who will be consistently good and has minimal injury history

Like Ward, but I think I would be a couple of K short for him & I don't want to burn 2 trades. Will just have to weight up the options during the week.

 

[Jiska]

Let me know what you're doing with Sloane Jiska

Oh ****. Who cares. Might get Dusty.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Was looking at doing Hogan > Gawn as my F6 and back up ruck but with Sloane gone not sure what to do now? Have 7 trades and with LTI's popping up every week dont want to burn 2 trades this week.

What about McKernan instead of Gawn? 160k to spend elsewhere. It shouldn't cost you many points if any. Gawn surely can't keep up this pace...

 

[KardiniaPark]

Oh ****. Who cares. Might get Dusty.

Don't you ****ing dare

 

[pincrusher]

I would like to forward a motion that the remainder of this supercoach year be cancelled and we can all just start planning for next year.

 

[Jiska]

I would like to forward a motion that the remainder of this supercoach year be cancelled and we can all just start planning for next year.

Seconded

 

[Hairy Lager]

No, Gawn has been given his opportunity to play by Paul Roos in a team that Roos is rebuilding and reassuring confidence in from the Neald Days

Gawn was used sparingly by other managers. Yes, He has had his injuries, BUT he always excelled at VFL level, just wasnt ever able to cement a place in the clubs best 22 due Jamar and big Stef Martin. Gawn has been in the system a few years now, he is taking his chances, and yeah, he isnt going to score 140's every week, but Barring injury is a safe bet for a bit of cash and 80 or more every week from what he has shown

I can't like that post enough, thanks mate will have a good look at him this week.

 

[GOAUS!]

Should just be able to squeeze in Sloane -> Neale

 

[xisor]

Should just be able to squeeze in Sloane -> Neale

Doing the same

 

[Jiska]

Should just be able to squeeze in Sloane -> Neale

Doing the same

Me too.

Who are we all trading Neale to next week??

 

[stevebbb]

Lonie to McLean
Sloane to _______

 

[GOAUS!]

Me too.

Who are we all trading Neale to next week??

Don't do this to me man. JM cursed Bontempelli earlier, I don't need another curse.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Lonie to McLean
Sloane to _______

Toby Mclean looks good hes played hes 3rd game had a b/e of -16 before this weeks game.