Trades Round 14 Trades

[Suncraze]

A: Libba
B: Cogs

Will get Bont next week

 

[Judd_Magic]

Need some advice kenties.

Am bringing in Stewart and Teakle but stuck with my 3rd trade.

Shoiuld I bring in Himmelberg or dare I say it Roughy Preuss or Heeney back in?

Just worried that Himmelberg is going to be playing at CHF due to being named there this week.

$484k to play with.

 

[Judd_Magic]

What about if I have Cameron who can DPP into R2 via Teakle if Preuss does something dumb or gets injured? An average of 110 is incredible for 450k odd

In all seriousness it's not the worst idea I guess.

You have Cameron and Teakle so that's plenty of cover for any short term Preuss out.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Need some advice kenties.

Am bringing in Stewart and Teakle but stuck with my 3rd trade.

Shoiuld I bring in Himmelberg or dare I say it Roughy Preuss or Heeney back in?

Just worried that Himmelberg is going to be playing at CHF due to being named there this week.

$484k to play with.

View attachment 1425813

I know Haynes is in this week but HH was also named at CHF last week

 

[DT_35]

Gawn > Teakle
Mccartin > Stewart
Clark > Himmleberg

Or

Gawn > Teakle
Clark > Stewart
Next week McCartin > Rookie + Hayes > English

Or

Hayes > Teakle
McCartin > Dawson

Thoughts?

 

[Gribnoor]

Hey SC family!

I'm freaking out and need help - I'm ranked in the 300s, and never been so high before at this stage... with 13 trades in hand...

I've got 20 playing on field, so don't have to make any move this week - but can't help be feel I should be trying to capitalise? Photos attached.

Himmelberg I'm iffy on - but have the trades to chance him, and worse case he makes fast coin?
Would love to bring Bont into forward line - but at who's expense?
Laird feels essential - and I've got sideways to do it before he goes nuts against GCS...
Maybe go early to Hayes to Teckle give he's playing and to open up money there...

Help guys - I'm freaking out, but in a good way? I have no idea...

 

[Gribnoor]

anyone brave enough to get Preuss back?

Gawn -> Preuss makes 150k! Preuss is averaging 110 and has tonned every game he has played.

Brave indeed! But do you trust he's back?
Very much now feels like McVeigh has him more fringe then previous coach - so do you trust him?

 

[puda]

With Haynes back for GWS, and Phil around the corner... doubt lingers of HH for me.

 

[AFDogs]

I just brought in Guthrie. At 520k and a 3 round average of 117 I couldn't look past him. Geelong playing great and they have West Coast this week. Hoping for a good score.

Hopefully he's a decent POD for the rest of the year.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I just brought in Guthrie. At 520k and a 3 round average of 117 I couldn't look past him. Geelong playing great and they have West Coast this week. Hoping for a good score.

Hopefully he's a decent POD for the rest of the year.

Guth not as good as last year .
But could go 110 from here tho.

Good luck kenty.

 

[stevebbb]

I just brought in Guthrie. At 520k and a 3 round average of 117 I couldn't look past him. Geelong playing great and they have West Coast this week. Hoping for a good score.

Hopefully he's a decent POD for the rest of the year.

Same. I reckon he could push a 120 average in his last 10 matches with a few 130s and 140s

110 at a minimum with 5/10 matches in Geelong and an easy fixture.

 

[buttox]

Hey SC family!

I'm freaking out and need help - I'm ranked in the 300s, and never been so high before at this stage... with 13 trades in hand...

I've got 20 playing on field, so don't have to make any move this week - but can't help be feel I should be trying to capitalise? Photos attached.

Himmelberg I'm iffy on - but have the trades to chance him, and worse case he makes fast coin?
Would love to bring Bont into forward line - but at who's expense?
Laird feels essential - and I've got sideways to do it before he goes nuts against GCS...
Maybe go early to Hayes to Teckle give he's playing and to open up money there...

Help guys - I'm freaking out, but in a good way? I have no idea...

Hayes to Teakle looks good.
Personally I would go McCartin to Stewart. (i think you can afford this.)

 

[Suncraze]

A: Libba
B: Cogs

Will get Bont next week

Any thoughts gentleman? Tearing my hair out trying to decide

 

[Kadog]

Where are you ranked this year mate? Hopefully a lot better than that injury cursed year we’ve had! That was something worthwhile to whinge about

This week, I’m gonna be reckless and will likely trade in Jezza for Brodie

Hovering around 10.5k atm. Same position as I was Rd1. Treading water despite burning trades. Still waiting for that absolute cracking round where it all clicks.

Team is decent I think with a few PODs. Bench depth and trades are an issue.

OUT: Gawn Petracca Clark
IN: Laird Mills Teakle

Starting 22:

Stewart Sinclair Doc Short Hall Wehr
Oliver Neale Laird Mills Macrae Miller Cripps Zerrett
English Darcy
Bont Dunkley Brodie Goldy Cogs Butterz

 

[buttox]

Any thoughts gentleman? Tearing my hair out trying to decide

Libba for mine.
Cogs seems a great pick because he just played North.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Any thoughts gentleman? Tearing my hair out trying to decide

Libba with no Bailey Sniff stealing points.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Hovering around 10.5k atm. Same position as I was Rd1. Treading water despite burning trades. Still waiting for that absolute cracking round where it all clicks.

Team is decent I think with a few PODs. Bench depth and trades are an issue.

OUT: Gawn Petracca Clark
IN: Laird Mills Teakle

Starting 22:

Stewart Sinclair Doc Short Hall Wehr
Oliver Neale Laird Mills Macrae Miller Cripps Zerrett
English Darcy
Bont Dunkley Brodie Goldy Cogs Butterz

That's a cracking team, you should be able to climb from 10.5K - with a bit of luck

So GL

 

[buttox]

Hovering around 10.5k atm. Same position as I was Rd1. Treading water despite burning trades. Still waiting for that absolute cracking round where it all clicks.

Team is decent I think with a few PODs. Bench depth and trades are an issue.

OUT: Gawn Petracca Clark
IN: Laird Mills Teakle

Starting 22:

Stewart Sinclair Doc Short Hall Wehr
Oliver Neale Laird Mills Macrae Miller Cripps Zerrett
English Darcy
Bont Dunkley Brodie Goldy Cogs Butterz

I reckon hold petracca mate.
get a d6.

 

[Quazza]

Rough day yesterday. Genuinely can't remember who I ended up trading in late last night. Gawn for someone ....

Just gonna not look

 

[Cats_29]

This is what I’m thinking..

Owens to Bont
Gawn to Strnadica
Clark/Hamilton to Teakle
McDonald to Stewart

Have English as a ruck

Not sure who to keep out of Greg Clark and Cooper Hamilton.

Any other options?
Have full premium except McCartin as a fwd
Will leave me with 7 trades

Please help!!

 

[stevebbb]

This is what I’m thinking..

Owens to Bont
Gawn to Strnadica
Clark/Hamilton to Teakle
McDonald to Stewart

Have English as a ruck

Not sure who to keep out of Greg Clark and Cooper Hamilton.

Any other options?
Have full premium except McCartin as a fwd
Will leave me with 7 trades

Please help!!

Post your team mate, hard to gauge

Why would you take Strnadica? He's a ruck only and not playing.

Bont and Stewart big ticks.
Teakle yep.
Strnadica makes zero sense.

 

[What is a cakewalk]

Thoughts on sdk to bont to finish my team this week? On the one hand think i should wait to ensure bont is the last forward i want, can potentially trade someone other than sdk next week, it doesn't give me another green tick. On the other hand, why wait might as well get the money on the field. Suggestions?

 

[Kadog]

I reckon hold petracca mate.
get a d6.

I’ve looked at it. The other trade scenario had me holding Petracca (No Laird or Mills) and going with Himmelberg F6 and Whitfield D6 and a completed side.

As much as I’m tempted by HH, I’m very wary of Haynes and Davis returning down back. Coach pencil neck comments on HH didn’t give much confidence either. He might play a little more in that defense role but I feel he’ll get pushed back forward to suit the side and we know his scores are shit there. Whitfield isn’t a bad option but again I’m wary in comments he made on his ankle. It’s still bothering him and will have to have surgery at some point. Soon as GWS are out of contention they may shelve him asap for surgery/recovery and ready for next PS. If you’ve got trades up your sleeve HH is absolutely a worthy punt because he’ll make cash and you could flip him if he bombs. I don’t have that luxury so whoever I bring in now, I’m stuck with for the remainder of the year. Gotta make sure they’re A graders at this point. Too many ?? marks on both GWS boys.

At the end of the day it comes down to onfield:

Laird Mills Wehr(D6) v
Petracca HH Whitfield

Getting two gun mids (both PODs) adds a bit of extra viewing excitement for me (which I need) so I’m gonna ride with 21 solid players and a rookie for a while I think. Let’s hope they click!

 

[Cats_29]

Post your team mate, hard to gauge

Why would you take Strnadica? He's a ruck only and not playing.

Bont and Stewart big ticks.
Teakle yep.
Strnadica makes zero sense.

I already have English and Preuss as rucks and need to trade Gawn to someone.
I was going to put English forward but thought I might leave him as a ruck now Gawn has gone down.

This is my team..



Thinking

Owens to Bont
Gawn to Strndica
Clark/Hamilton to Teakle
McDonald to Stewart

 

[JuddgementDay]

I’ve looked at it. The other trade scenario had me holding Petracca (No Laird or Mills) and going with Himmelberg F6 and Whitfield D6 and a completed side.

As much as I’m tempted by HH, I’m very wary of Haynes and Davis returning down back. Coach pencil neck comments on HH didn’t give much confidence either. He might play a little more in that defense role but I feel he’ll get pushed back forward to suit the side and we know his scores are s**t there. Whitfield isn’t a bad option but again I’m wary in comments he made on his ankle. It’s still bothering him and will have to have surgery at some point. Soon as GWS are out of contention they may rest him asap for surgery/recovery and ready for next PS. If you’ve got trades up your sleeve HH is absolutely a worthy punt because he’ll make dash and you could flip him if he bombshell. I don’t have that luxury so whoever I bring in now, I’m stuck with for the remainder of the year. Gotta make sure they’re A graders at this point. Too many ?? marks on both GWS boys.

At the end of the day it comes down to onfield:

Laird Mills Wehr(D6) v
Petracca HH Whitfield

Getting two gun mids (both PODs) adds a bit of extra viewing excitement for me (which I need) so I’m gonna ride with 21 solid players and a rookie for a while I think. Let’s hope they click!

I certainly agree - get these actual premos in and throw away the keys

Also, we tend to agree too much - but, viewing excitement is also important to me!
Hence, I've locked in Jezza for Brodie (too early I know, but it's now or never)