Review Round 2 vs Western Bulldogs @ Mars Stadium - 24th March 2024 - 12:00pm AEST
- Thread starter Big Red Machine
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I had Mac as being our number 1 most improved player this year. I feel like he just needs to be selected once and hopefully can put it all together. Would love him to just be given a license to play pretty free across Half back and Wing.
Being so tall and skinny he doesn't fit into Hardwicks high pressure game plan. Hardwick needs to adjust because we have 2 great tall players in Mac and Ethan and he needs to tweak that game plan to make the most out of the talent we have.
A Mac playing well is going to do more for our team than an Ellis / Long playing well etc.
Being so tall and skinny he doesn't fit into Hardwicks high pressure game plan. Hardwick needs to adjust because we have 2 great tall players in Mac and Ethan and he needs to tweak that game plan to make the most out of the talent we have.
A Mac playing well is going to do more for our team than an Ellis / Long playing well etc.
Confirming that having just turned 20 he has does have a lot of growing up to do
Unless he's like a Pakistani batsman and official DOB is bogus
I wasn't able to watch the match live but I planned to watch it on AFL's replay. My plan was to type my thoughts as I watched then post them when I finished the match. But I got pretty distracted after the first quarter and never got back around to it. Anyway, this is what I wrote:
Very annoying: Should have been ball on Bailey Dale at 8:12 left in Q1 (20:15 to 20:45 on the match replay). Great tackle by Jed Walter dead in front, Bailey Dale juggles it before he carries it to ground, waits half a second, then gets off the handpass. It would have been a great first goal for Jed Walter that highlights his excellent defensive pressure… would have been so good for his confidence, alas. And in the very next throw-in Ned Moyle got taken high for no free kick. I suppose since GC got such an easy ride by the umps in the Adelaide game (Rowell had about 6 throws) our luck was bound to come around.
Poor Bodhi Uwland got absolutely mullered by Weightman. I like the kid but he needs to be dropped after that, Lemmens can keep his spot warm while he gets his confidence back.
Not sure what Long was even doing in the team, surely Darcy MacPherson would have been a better option as a replacement forward for Rosas? 2 tackles and just 1 ground ball get. At least Rosas can slot right back into the team.
Very annoying: Should have been ball on Bailey Dale at 8:12 left in Q1 (20:15 to 20:45 on the match replay). Great tackle by Jed Walter dead in front, Bailey Dale juggles it before he carries it to ground, waits half a second, then gets off the handpass. It would have been a great first goal for Jed Walter that highlights his excellent defensive pressure… would have been so good for his confidence, alas. And in the very next throw-in Ned Moyle got taken high for no free kick. I suppose since GC got such an easy ride by the umps in the Adelaide game (Rowell had about 6 throws) our luck was bound to come around.
Poor Bodhi Uwland got absolutely mullered by Weightman. I like the kid but he needs to be dropped after that, Lemmens can keep his spot warm while he gets his confidence back.
Not sure what Long was even doing in the team, surely Darcy MacPherson would have been a better option as a replacement forward for Rosas? 2 tackles and just 1 ground ball get. At least Rosas can slot right back into the team.
If we’re bringing lemmens in then we are in trouble
Lemmens and McPherson are where they belong - leave them there.
I agree that Lemmens isn't great, but Uwland is really struggling and it will be better long-term for Uwland's development to regain his confidence for one or two VFL games. I know Dimma likes his tenacity but I wouldn't want him to join the 'never dropped regardless of form' club.
- Mar 14, 2014
- 40,678
- 75,159
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Las Vegas Bears
Bodhi did struggle but he didn't have any help from the midfield. Dogs where able to deliver the ball into the forward line under stuff all pressure. Hard to defend against that no matter who it is.
Southern Sun
Club Legend
- Mar 6, 2020
- 1,923
- 2,633
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
Sort of agree with most that lemmens isn't a long term prospect but right now I think he's our best lockdown. Coming up against Toby Greene is it a good opportunity for experience playing uwland on him or could it set him back if he gets hold of him? Maybe lemmens is a safer bet for now.
He’s only played 6 games I’m pretty sure where he is playing is better for his development
Southern Sun
Club Legend
- Mar 6, 2020
- 1,923
- 2,633
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
Yeah I do like uwland in the team, just not sure giving him the big job every week is ideal. Maybe play him on Daniels this week instead of Greene ( still a tough task)
- Mar 14, 2014
- 40,678
- 75,159
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Las Vegas Bears
Best way for him to learn. Lemmens is who he is, Bodhi has to learn somehow
- Dec 3, 2013
- 3,285
- 3,607
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
We're at best 3 years away, might as well play the kids and get experience into them, same for andrew, rogers and read
Haha, Daniel is as good as Greene recently. Tough choice. Then you got Brown, Bedford, the list goes on.
To be honest I worry more about Budarick's defence and whether midfield can stand up against GWS machine. All GWS players look fast with great skills, great rebound. I am concerned, haha.
Just hoping we are competitive and not lose by 50+.
Last edited:
Worked well with Sharp, Hollands and Burgess didn't it. Uwland is the future - Lemmens is the past. Play the kids - we're still way off the pace unless a massive change in confidence and aggression - will to win etc.
- Dec 3, 2013
- 3,285
- 3,607
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
Everything is okShhhhhhh
The walls have ears!!!
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Similar threads
