Round 23 Trades

[joeyavalanche]

not enough cash to do much else
need to make 2 trades from:

ebert > montagna
stanton > scott selwood
westhoff > stokes

other 2 tradable mids are masten & kornes

 

[tryonthis]

Not sure whether to go Henderson > Scotland, or Henderson > Mackie. Thoughts?

 

[pawnshopghost]

Cool thanks

Yeah maybe I might drop Gibbs instead and keep Ibbo

the 2nd one. i would actually keep ibbo if you have another issues in your team. i think he will get a 85-100

 

[Fitzey]

Not sure whether to go Henderson > Scotland, or Henderson > Mackie. Thoughts?

Mackie

 

[tryonthis]

Mackie

Despite already having Enright?

 

[kierez4ever]

Not sure whether to go Henderson > Scotland, or Henderson > Mackie. Thoughts?

i think we won't tag scotland and expect him to get 80+ as good as mackie is he can get the odd bad score

 

[kierez4ever]

not enough cash to do much else
need to make 2 trades from:

ebert > montagna
stanton > scott selwood
westhoff > stokes

other 2 tradable mids are masten & kornes

i would do westhoff (no butcher in the team means he's playing as a KPF not a swingman where he gets most of his DT scores)
then i would ebert because he is a bit sore this week and i dont think stanton will be tightly marked this weekend

 

[Fitzey]

Mackie or Hibberd or Enright

 

[kierez4ever]

Mackie or Hibberd or Enright

Enright because its at skilled. not hibbo because im worried that he will play the lock down defender again and mackie as good as he is can provide the odd crappy score

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

What option is better

a) Libba + Hanley, w/ Deledio bench cover
b) Deledio + scotland/mackie w/ ROK bench cover

 

[TheGhostOfJohnBelushi]

Am I crazy for trading Barlow out? Means keeping Cotchin and Jack. Just not trusting Fretank's game tactics.

Also deciding to keep McKenzie against GWS and ditching Gibbs for Mackie.

 

[kierez4ever]

What option is better

a) Libba + Hanley, w/ Deledio bench cover
b) Deledio + scotland/mackie w/ ROK bench cover

Libba (110+) and Hanley (80+) =190
Deledio (95+) and Scotland/Mackie (80/75ish+) so option A
note these are my predictions, obviously the mids can go real big this week
hanley did get a lot of the ball last week but because cross was on him he got no marks

 

[joeyavalanche]

i would do westhoff (no butcher in the team means he's playing as a KPF not a swingman where he gets most of his DT scores)
then i would ebert because he is a bit sore this week and i dont think stanton will be tightly marked this weekend

cheers for the insight mate!
so ebert's a bit injured you reckon?

 

[kierez4ever]

cheers for the insight mate!
so ebert's a bit injured you reckon?

i wouldnt say injured but he's sore. wont get subbed though but i dont think he can get a 105+

 

[Fitzey]

Hanley or Terlich out for my team?

 

[Fitzey]

Despite already having Enright?

Yeah, His recent scores at Skilled have been good.

 

[kierez4ever]

Hanley or Terlich out for my team?

going on form, hanley has gotta go out

 

[tortoise_24]

Hi Guys,
After a little help. In the GF in my first year in DT
The guy I am up against has had the best team all year in my league however I have out scored him last 2 weeks. I think our teams are reasonably even but he has better forward line, plus no major outs.
I only have around $20k in the bank.

His team before trades
Def: Goddard, Hibberd, Hanley, Gibbs, Ellis, Duffield, (Vlastuin)
Mids: Swan, Pendles, Ablett, JSelwood, Barlow, Griffen, ROK, Cotchin, (Armfield)
Rucks: Cox and Minson (Grundy)
For: NRoo, Rocky, Martin, Cloke, JRoughie, StevieJ, Christensen

Mine before trades
Def: Goddard, Enright, D Pearce, Gibbs, Harry O, Duffield, (McKenzie)
Mids: Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Barlow, Stanton, Priddis, Sselwood, FYFE, (TMitchell)
Rucks: Cox and Berger (Grundy or Blicavs)
For: NRoo, Rocky, Martin, JJK, Monfries, StevieJ, (Macaffer or Johnston)

I was thinking of going Fyfe->Watson (or maybe Masten) and then either JJK or Monfries to someone.
If I trade in Watson probably the best forward I can afford for JJK is Roughie (or Motlop??), whereas I can get Pav, Wellingham, Bartel, Ryder or even Motlop for Monfries.

Any suggestions welcome.

I don't know if I can provide any particularly enlightened help, but its been fairly wet over here in Perth, which probably won't help JJK, so he may be a better trade out than Monfries ... if so you'd probably need to do the Masten trade to give yourself some more wiggle room. A slightly left field pick might be Lachlan Hansen who's been scoring well lately. Pav might be the best option, but it depends on whether Freo's slightly less than full strength team can give him enough supply.

Good luck!

 

[DANMAN]

please help.
trading stanton out. can afford anyone Beams,Libba, S.Selwood.
already have swan , ablett, watson,J.Selwood,Griffen,Pendles,barlow
& who to play Terlich or Scotland ?
thoughts please
cheers

 

[kierez4ever]

I don't know if I can provide any particularly enlightened help, but its been fairly wet over here in Perth, which probably won't help JJK, so he may be a better trade out than Monfries ... if so you'd probably need to do the Masten trade to give yourself some more wiggle room. A slightly left field pick might be Lachlan Hansen who's been scoring well lately. Pav might be the best option, but it depends on whether Freo's slightly less than full strength team can give him enough supply.

Good luck!

get jobe and get lachie hansen!!

 

[kierez4ever]

please help.
trading stanton out. can afford anyone Beams,Libba, S.Selwood.
already have swan , ablett, watson,J.Selwood,Griffen,Pendles,barlow
& who to play Terlich or Scotland ?
thoughts please
cheers

what about jobe/libba?
i would play scotland, he's been in good form as of late

 

[tortoise_24]

May as well contribute my final trades ....

Fyfe -> Liberatore (for point of difference)
Jack -> N. Riewoldt (to cover a current point of difference)

Playing a top 100 ranked team in my main league GF, so will need some luck. Good luck me.

Thanks to all the regular (and irregular) posters to the trade threads over the year for your interesting/amusing/occasionally perplexing input ... they've supplemented the admirable footy Tragic site as my main weekly DT read.

 

[Nyaaamate]

dilemma was either priddis/stanton > libba/griffen. decided to get rid of priddis, but for LIBBAR OR GRIFF? cant decide. somebody convince me to pick one of them

 

[kierez4ever]

dilemma was either priddis/stanton > libba/griffen. decided to get rid of priddis, but for LIBBAR OR GRIFF? cant decide. somebody convince me to pick one of them

libba libba libba. griffen will probably get the mckenzie tag

 

[DANMAN]

what about jobe/libba?
i would play scotland, he's been in good form as of late

cheers
worried about Scotland, look injured towards end of last game, leaning towards Terlich @ Etihad.
have Jobe, thinking Libba or Beams , leaning towards Libba.
thanks for the feedback.