Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[Hodge1]

Lol. Was last nights game the only one you have watched so far this season. Sounds very reactionary.

- Martin has 'attempted' 0 tackles in 2019.
- Doesn't get down to the oppositions D50, that's a third of the ground he doesn't collect stats.
- Hasn't chased, pressured or been on the bottom of a single pack to get his own ball.
No sure if injured or just a lazy and arrogant one way runner, he may improve but likewise it wont be in my team.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

- Martin has 'attempted' 0 tackles in 2019.
- Doesn't get down to the oppositions D50, that's a third of the ground he doesn't collect stats.
- Hasn't chased, pressured or been on the bottom of a single pack to get his own ball.
No sure if injured or just a lazy and arrogant one way runner, he may improve but likewise it wont be in my team.

Don't disagree with Dusty... but Pendles?

 

[Hodge1]

Don't disagree with Dusty... but Pendles?

Oh lol my bad mate, had to get the Dusty rage out somewhere.
Yeah agree with you on Pendles, two or three pie mids alone in front of him.
He's a champion, no doubt.
But with Treloar, Beams, Sidebottom and Adams to come back in, I feel there are safer options elsewhere.

 

[Blackhawk42]

Don't disagree with Dusty... but Pendles?

Pendles looks hurt (emotionally) from last year's grand final and is playing like a guy seeking atonement. I can see the logic.

 

[buttox]

mills to newman
gibbons to sheed

 

[JuddgementDay]

I havent finalised my RD2 trades as yet, I cant even think about RD3
A lot can happen by the end of RD2

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I might trade Grundy...





















View attachment 643894 View attachment 643896

Im gonna trade Grundy



















Trade him the **** in

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I havent finalised my RD2 trades as yet, I cant even think about RD3
A lot can happen by the end of RD2

Shut up and trade kenty

 

[Jcpdragonx]

If Oliver spuds up again -

Oliver > Newman (providing he scores over 100 again) via Duursma

Burgess > Worpel


Or

Oliver > Butters and Hore > Lloyd


Or

Oliver > Sheed\Rocky and either Hore > Newman or Burgess > Worpel


That's what I am thinking of atm, just don't know which combo best suits my team.

What does everyone think is the best trade combo?

Current team as of last nights game -

View attachment 643863

Burgess>Hore via dpp, Moore Fwd, Oliver for Lloyd via Duursma? Just one trade here. Only if Oliver plays like dog again.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Shut up and trade kenty

Looking at getting Sheed in RD2. Can Sheed hold up his scoring with Gaff back?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Looking at getting Sheed in RD2. Can Sheed hold up his scoring with Gaff back?

Yep. I started with him expecting hes a year long keeper. 110+ avg

 

[AssassinAndy]

What does everyone think is the best trade combo?



View attachment 643863

No trades is the clear winner. Keep Oliver.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Depends on whats cracking after this round.

Early thoughts.

Collins to moore and dirty hore bag to sticky wilkie.

 

[Judd_Magic]

No trades is the clear winner. Keep Oliver.

Will see how he goes this week.

Feel like I've gone in a premo\breakout forward\back short though.

Damnit not taking Sheed, Rocky and Worpel.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Burgess>Hore via dpp, Moore Fwd, Oliver for Lloyd via Duursma? Just one trade here. Only if Oliver plays like dog again.

Would love to get Lloyd in.

He would go a long way into fixing up my backline.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Will see how he goes this week.

Feel like I've gone in a premo\breakout forward\back short though.

Damnit not taking Sheed, Rocky and Worpel.

Worpel looks good but I think (hope) well be right without him, his TOG is real low, had to kick 2 goals and based on R1 and last year, has a lot of clangers. For his game he should have gone more than 110. Not having Rocky and Sheed are a problem and idk what do other than pray.

 

[freddy mercury]

Looking like a straight swap Martin - Pendlebury

 

[Hai_Newman]

Depends on whats cracking after this round.

Early thoughts.

Collins to moore and dirty hore bag to sticky wilkie.

Stay away from Kiera, she's mine.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Stay away from Kiera, she's mine.

Cant we share ..she also has DPP special skills .

 

[toxic]

Pendles looks hurt (emotionally) from last year's grand final and is playing like a guy seeking atonement. I can see the logic.

I started with Pendles.
.watched him train in Port Douglas before Xmas.
Man possessed
SC royalty
CD kotd love child
Best midfield in comp

Will average 115+

 

[4tune8]

Gonna make a couple of correctional trades this week, just not sure which way to roll....

If Newman looks the goods, Then Malaria>Newman

Will move English on via Hoff.....so I can get Worpel in, trouble is....I can also grab either Rocky or Sheed via Drew.

So my choice essentially is.....2 of Newman, Rocky, Sheed and Worpel (can't do both of Rocky and Sheed tho)

 

[Deliverance]

McGrath is probably gone if he can't tonne up against STK.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Cant we share ..she also has DPP special skills .

Oh.... OK, you sweet talking kenty.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Worpel looks good but I think (hope) well be right without him, his TOG is real low, had to kick 2 goals and based on R1 and last year, has a lot of clangers. For his game he should have gone more than 110. Not having Rocky and Sheed are a problem and idk what do other than pray.

Yep, I'm scared about not having Sheed and Rocky in my team if they keep this form up.

Do you happen to have a Sheed and Rocky voodoo doll on you mate? I have the pins. LOL!

 

[mochacinolatte]

I started with Pendles.
.watched him train in Port Douglas before Xmas.
Man possessed
SC royalty
CD kotd love child
Best midfield in comp

Will average 115+

Who do you have as your top 10 midfielders for this year?

Would like Pendles in my team but hard to look away from his yearly average decline. So what makes this year more different than last year beside the GF lost? Did Pendles have a full preseason? I know previous year he has interrupted preseason hence a factor in the slow decline. Collingwood have a huge midfield depth, don't you think the inclusion of Taylor Adams might push him out to more a wing role?