Round 3 trades

[DraftPunk]

I'm actually strongly considering Toby Greene now.

It seems R1 was just a shocker for the Giants, they looked a lot better in R2 and will a full side he had 34 touches. Looking like Jack Steele getting dropped may have helped him. Big chance to be a Top 6-8 Forward.

Would be interested in seeing his R2 heat map.

 

[Ingy]

I knew that. Thought he was good to go this week.

The official word is that he pulled up well and is expected to train tomorrow and play on Friday night.

There is a rumour that he is going to miss

 

[Gribnoor]

Indeed.
He smoked us saints last year so I'm not surprised he went big last week.

I started with him, and he's a good pickup even now... But people need to set their expectations accordingly.

He'll be a good 100ish average scorer for the year i think, don't bring him in expecting 120av

At his price, you would take that 100 and run for your life. For what it's worth, I really rate him as a player - his use of ball is class, efforts are excellent and has a serious tank. Think more than that is not out of the question for him.

 

[crowman_23]

Need some advice, is it worth following the crowd and trading

Rich for Johannisen
Westhoff for Hall

Or should I hold my nerve and allow a few more games to play out?

 

[Kadog]

Indeed.
He smoked us saints last year so I'm not surprised he went big last week.

I started with him, and he's a good pickup even now... But people need to set their expectations accordingly.

He'll be a good 100ish average scorer for the year i think, don't bring him in expecting 120av

A 100avg would be sensational result.

 

[Pedro]

OUT - Barlow Rockliff
IN - BenKen, Papley $773,700 in the kitty (I'm pretty hell bent on the 2 INS. How I do it is up for debate)

Should leave enough for next week:

OUT - BCrouch, Gresham
IN- Dangerfield, RGray (Or pretty much any other 2 premos)

Plausible, Stupid,

Would leave me with all the rookies I want, and pending injuries, happy to let them earn for a while and not trade

 

[Hear Me Crow]

The official word is that he pulled up well and is expected to train tomorrow and play on Friday night.

There is a rumour that he is going to miss

But if he is not 100%, PA won't risk Chad early in the season against the Dons.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

People had to stretch there sides to get certain premos in, fair enough.
But most Super Coaches blew an O-Ring trying to get Bar low in.

I just went from Lids to Barlow in the last week, upgraded a rookie and banked the rest.
Should've gone Hall and upgraded another rookie. Ohh well.

 

[Gribnoor]

teams refuse to man up on Mitchell, he's coming in.

Rocky>Mitchell
Barlow>Bken

JJ can wait a week or 2

From a value point of view, JJ would make more sense before Mitchell.

Need help...

Rocky > Parker
Rocky > Priddis
Rocky > Mitchell

Am favouring Parker due to his output at his bargain price. Priddis is a safe bet, but costs about $50k more, so too Mitchell who is even more expensive.

Can Mitchell keep up his scoring? Hasn't copped a tag in his first two games and has the biggest rise in TOG % differential between 2015/2016. Can his body be trusted?

Priddis you pay for what you get - super premo. Parker for best value. Mitchell as the POD of the three.

 

[Kadog]

But if he is not 100%, PA won't risk Chad early in the season against the Dons.

Port just got smashed & Bumbers are on a peptide high after their win. If he's ready, he plays no question.

 

[Kadog]

I just went from Lids to Barlow in the last week, upgraded a rookie and banked the rest.
Should've gone Hall and upgraded another rookie. Ohh well.

I want Hall too. I was a sceptic but his form is no fluke. Turned the corner to be a real stud now.

 

[Pedsy]

This crazy desire to get JJ in has me almost considering moving Bartel out.

 

[Nelso]

I knew that. Thought he was good to go this week.

Wingard will definitely be playing this Friday night.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Need some advice, is it worth following the crowd and trading

Rich for Johannisen
Westhoff for Hall

Or should I hold my nerve and allow a few more games to play out?

you need hall, that said i dont think you need to trade Rich out for JJ

 

[Smithy4322]

You need to get M.Adams in while you can (FWD) opens up DPP. averaging 110, and is cheap as chips... Will rise heaps in value and set in 22 without a doubt.

Parish should take a backseat if you can cover with another rookie.

Get Papley in for Grimley also who will rise an absolute stack.

I told you this already!

This week I decided to do my 2 trades with long and grimely on the bench for M.Adams and Papley.

By doing these 2 trades I had no choice but to leave Simpkin in the middle who didn't play last week.

Was this a wise decision?? I was thinking get in gun rookies before their price goes up?

Also the people who I could have possibly swapped for Simpkin in the middle, aswell did not play that week. If I go this week, I'll probably be a man down.

Is this surrender worth while to be better in the future games??

And also, do you know of a good website that lets you know what players are going to play this week and which arnt?

Cheers man

 

[CGPIES25]

Who to trade out for benken and libba
Rocky, barlowor Gresh?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

What's going on with Chad??

My take is why risk him.
It's a short week and against Essendon. Expect him to miss.

 

[Abstract]

Out: Rockliff, S Jacobs

In: R Gray, Papley

Moved Tippet into the ruck and got a lot of cash to burn next week. It's looking like I'll bring in JJ and Hall next week for De Gooey and Seedsman in an attempt to upgrade my mid-ranges to premiums while they're still good value. After that I'll grab a premium ruck on the cheap.

 

[SC fish]

Getting libba and benken in this week but unsure of who to trade out options are Barlow, rocky, gresh and bcrouch

Can't get rid of both gresh and bcrouch because not enough $ but also don't think trading out bcrouch ATM is needed as he will still genarate cash

I don't really like trading out premos this early but really not seeing anything from barlows games although history shows his scoring being a bit up and down will probably ton up this week

Same with rocky hasn't been scoring to well (although saw some positives in r1 but was very poor in r2) also has injury problems and is a risk so still unsure

Any advice fellas

Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

Rocky is out for two weeks so he's probably your first trade-out target.

I would stick with Crouch I reckon he will come good.

Gresham may be dropped - if so he's your next trade-out.

 

[Aishole]

I don't see JJ's output dropping significantly against the hawks, doubt he'll pump out another 120+ but the hawks won't send a man to sit on him. the doggies have murph, biggs, boyd, wood all down there who are all also capable of cutting teams up and in good form. it'll be more of a team effort and i can see them trying to limit the amount of damage JJ does, not necessarilly his disposal count. If he still racks up 25 possies, with a lower efficiency and gives me around 90 i'd be happy considering i payed just over 400k for him. Get him in now i say, won't be this cheap for a while

 

[CGPIES25]

Rocky is out for two weeks so he's probably your first trade-out target.

I would stick with Crouch I reckon he will come good.

Gresham may be dropped - if so he's your next trade-out.

Rocky not even on Brisbane injury list feel he will only miss 1 if any and will come good after a few more games

Right now leaning towards Barlow and gresh out dont see barlow being consistent enough to become a keeper and feel gresh will be dropped this week

But thanks for the advice if rocky is to miss 2 unsure on what I'll do probably have to stick with barlow and see how he goes


Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk

 

[Aishole]

Also the bloke is quick as f&#%, cant tag him if you cant catch him

 

[stevebbb]

OUT - Barlow Rockliff
IN - BenKen, Papley $773,700 in the kitty (I'm pretty hell bent on the 2 INS. How I do it is up for debate)

Should leave enough for next week:

OUT - BCrouch, Gresham
IN- Dangerfield, RGray (Or pretty much any other 2 premos)

Plausible, Stupid,

Would leave me with all the rookies I want, and pending injuries, happy to let them earn for a while and not trade

Do it.
We can only make decisions based on what's in front of us. The cash cows are performing well and there's nothing to suggest they won't keep it up.

Don't think you should get rid of BCrouch so soon. He's building fitness and confidence. We'll get to that next week though

 

[kane22]

Having doubts about my trades now I'm not sure if i want to get BenKen in, he's the only rookie i missed
i can do:
Rockliff to danger and Barlow to JJ
Rockliff to Parker and Gresham to BenKen
Barlow to JJ and Gresham to BenKen
Rockliff to BenKen and Barlow to JJ and have a less premo for a week or 2
Don't know what to do any opinions would be grateful!

 

[juddola]

Definitely. 10% owned now though. Too much to be a POD anymore?

Higher ownership then what I thought.