Round 4 Trades

[Big Fozza]

What are people's thoughts on mummy to goldy. Obviously very sideways but Goldy is absolutely killing me

 

[Big Fozza]

Bartel -> Swan
Goodes -> Sloane Via Saad DPP

Solid

 

[Stealthchicken]

No trades this week. Might cashing in on guys like Salem next week.

 

[12Chill]

Bartel > Bontempelli.

Might go Anderson (anyone have his B/E?) to Krak and then do a couple more downgrades next week. Whitecross and Tarrant on radar.
Cut a couple of rookies that have completed mooing and by the bye rounds I should have built up a massive war chest to bring in guns as they return from byes. That's the plan.

 

[SureBuddy]

Just the one for me. Bartel to Swan.

I know I am getting Swan above his starting price, however I am more than happy to have waited to see how he would perform this year for the sake of an extra 37k.

My premos will come good, so not too fussed. Defintely won't be any sideways trades happening. Really not happy with Goodes, but there is really nothing I can do to get rid of him. he can just sit on the pine for a while.

 

[NinjaSwan]

Probably no trades, might go Anderson/Lonie > Krak, I would rather get rid of Anderson but I would also prefer having him in the forward line, might just wait a week.

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Hibberd or Newnes to anyone better.

Is it worth it. A case can be made for both, but they are shitting me so far.

Ive got both and keeping both. Hibberd played in shocking conditions in round 1, and was tagged against Carlton. While Newnes DE was shocking and can partly be blamed on the wet weather, and still averaging 77. Keep both

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Jake Kelly or Harris Andrews, who has better JS?

 

[dewah07]

eye test?

watching griffen on tv and evaluating him

 

[Gene Simmons]

Hey guys,

I need your recommendation... Here is my team with $203k in the bank.

I think my DEF is a liability, no depth/coverage and Newnes/Goodes have been disappointing.

I wouldn't mind upgrading in my MID either, What are thoughts on A.Swallow??

I'm prepared to stick with my ruck combo atm, as any trade i make would be sideways..

Cheers in advance

 

[rocker_oz33]

[

Hibberd or Newnes to anyone better.

Is it worth it. A case can be made for both, but they are shitting me so far.

Birchall in another week maybe
But hibberd was sat on he'll prob get better what did he get 85 ish..?
Mr 6kegs getting the bill just a butcher of balls.

 

[SniffySnort]

Parker to Sloane? Too early?

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Anderson has to go, he's been subbed to supercoach death.

Anderson to Krak next week for me.

This week
Bartel > Bont or Bartel > Gray
Griffin > Sloane

 

[YouCantCatchMe]

Bartel > Swan

Holding on Goodes for bench this week, hoping he's either dropped or not sub..

Will downgrade to Whitecross most likely unless a rookie defender looks great and has decent JS.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Hibberd or Newnes to anyone better.

Is it worth it. A case can be made for both, but they are shitting me so far.

I'm not touching any defenders for the time being, there haven't been many that have gone over 90 per week.

I want to fix my mids, Danger and Griff are killing me

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hey guys,

I need your recommendation... Here is my team with $203k in the bank.

I think my DEF is a liability, no depth/coverage and Newnes/Goodes have been disappointing.

I wouldn't mind upgrading in my MID either, What are thoughts on A.Swallow??

I'm prepared to stick with my ruck combo atm, as any trade i make would be sideways..

Cheers in advance

View attachment 126069

Doggies have some injury worrys so LWebb or Hamling likley to gets games for Goodes.
I'd keep Swallow hes not injuied bat him down the order.
if anderson the sub/dropped maybe get krack 100 rookie.
bank some cash turn NVB into a super premo in weeks to come.
my 5cents worth.

 

[TheOz]

Anderson to Krak next week for me.

This week
Bartel > Bont or Bartel > Gray
Griffin > Sloane

Anderson has a BE of 28, if he's sub again he might not even get it. **** I hate Hawthorn.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Anderson has a BE of 28, if he's sub again he might not even get it. **** I hate Hawthorn.

He might get dropped, who knows ...

He wont lose too much coin so a swap to Krak will free up 40 odd k

I don't think I'm alone on this one but Anderson is the least of my problems ATM

 

[Gene Simmons]

Anderson has a BE of 28, if he's sub again he might not even get it. **** I hate Hawthorn.

TBH, I expect Anderson will get dropped next week - I think they'll give him at least 1 full game at Box Hill... But Clarko (& the fans) love him and he'll be back in the seniors - although I expect he'll be a vest candidate most weeks.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Just jotted down the most obvious trade questions I think are worth pondering this week...

Best replacements for Wines at that price? Perhaps a Premium Forward with DPP? Or you spend 2 trades to get to a Sloane/Selwood/Fyfe etc

Best replacement for Bartel? If you have Bont and Swan, who is next best choice (hint not Goddard). If you have the forward cover could you wait a week and be close to parity with Gray who should fall further in price (if you don't currently have 29K spare)?

Assuming Bont is back next week is he a must have after this weeks events? Especially if you need to trade a Premo out to get him?

Several good rookies might be on the bubble the week after next – do you take one this week just in case you want to use more than 2 trades the week after?

Who are the obvious candidates for this weeks 'ditching them too early' trade? Cripps and Beams were some of the round 3 mistakes. Who will thousands prematurely jump off this week? Newnes, Goddard or Griffin perhaps? Or will they continue to underwhelm and be important corrections?

 

[rocker_oz33]

TBH, I expect Anderson will get dropped next week - I think they'll give him at least 1 full game at Box Hill... But Clarko (& the fans) love him and he'll be back in the seniors - although I expect he'll be a vest candidate most weeks.

Yeah i think he'll get dropped too.
Pity he didnt play better last week to get a full game this week,bit of moo would of been nice.

 

[IGetBuckets]

Bartel>> Roughhead
Bartel>>E Betts
Bartel>> Buddy

so caught up on who to choose , i feel roughead is the way to go , most consistent.

 

[buttox]

Several good rookies might be on the bubble the week after next – do you take one this week just in case you want to use more than 2 trades the week after?

this for me almost certainly. got griff gibson newnes and goodes also.
if i go goodes--> andrews i'll have 425k in bank for most likely cey and heeney to super prems in 3-4 weeks

 

[Unknown Identity]

Goldstein now a must have with Bellchambers not doing enough at R2.

Downgrading Griffin or Goddard to Bontempelli.

Who should make way for this as its going to happen!

 

[Lums23]

Who to get rid of Kolodjashnij or Wells? Considering holding onto Kolo for one more week because his BE is more gettable.

Trade Wells. There's a bit of uncertainty over his fitness