Round 5 Discussion

[Sydney Kicker]

So with Buddy out, will SYD be forced to play Heeney FWD rather than midfield ? ......Reid out long-term, so what are the other fwd options ?

With Hannaberry out, you'd think Parker would get more mid time? Franklin out might mean Cameron in and Sinclair forward?

Horse will do whatever f$#%s up our SC teams the most

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

18/1587

Gawn
Devon

Dusty C
Muzza

 

[evo]

I agree with the "revised" position of the AFL ......in our game of contact, there'll always be accidental head clashes .....if you try & eradicate, how long is a piece of string

I do too. Glad Burton got off.

 

[jdwood]

Awesome. He gets 0 weeks now unless his bad record comes into it, 1 max.

This is predicated on the basis that the AFL cares about such things as "precedent". Ironically, the precedent they have set suggests that they do not.

He will go.

 

[Thorgils]

Hibbo + Nank + Petracca V 240 + Hurley

Who wins?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Dunno whether to put the C on Dusty or Gawn. Dusty has the higher ceiling but Jones could tag him

Gawn (top 5 scores) 160, 160, 167, 172, 174

Dusty (top 5 scores) 159, 160, 165, 167, 168

 

[catstragic]

There's HOPE Sicily owners ......a precedent !!!!

Given legal inflation in the AFL a $1200 fine in 2013 roughly equates to a flogging and twelve weeks now.

 

[evo]

Hibbo + Nank + Petracca V 240 + Hurley

Who wins?

Hurley.... Hibberd doesn't oink anymore, Petracca will be close checked by Tiges and Nank will be flogged by Gawny

 

[SavDog23]

There's HOPE Sicily owners ......a precedent !!!!

gawn

 

[PoopingHindi]

Hibbo + Nank + Petracca V 240 + Hurley

Who wins?

the second guy easy.
i hope thats you.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

This is predicated on the basis that the AFL cares about such things as "precedent". Ironically, the precedent they have set suggests that they do not.

He will go.

There is grey area between comparing head high bumps because there a more variables, but this is a complete like for like, if anything Enright used a bit more force. I don't understand how this gets a different outcome to Enright, what is the Tribunal suppose to do when they see the previous case?

 

[Marlowe]

Gawn C
+
Oliver
+
Petracca
=

500, surely.

 

[Thorgils]

the second guy easy.
i hope thats you.

 

[Waddatars]

There's HOPE Sicily owners ......a precedent !!!!

Same charge but different type of incident. Enright trying to put his feet down to man the mark. Sicily running on and chooses to stomp on Atley. Punchable is gone.

 

[evo]

raining a bit ATM. Probably hurt Gawnys score a bit. Not sure what it does for Dusty - might help

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Same charge but different type of incident. Enright trying to put his feet down to man the mark. Sicily running on and chooses to stomp on Atley. Punchable is gone.

Enright pleaded guilty, the incident is exactly the same

 

[balmainforever]

raining a bit ATM. Probably hurt Gawnys score a bit. Not sure what it does for Dusty - might help

The wetter the better for dusty

 

[Waddatars]

Enright pleaded guilty, the incident is exactly the same

Yep read that after. So yeah, Enright guilty too. I guess what looks worse with Sicily is the footage shows his one is such a cheap shot and his poor record and reputation.

 

[SavDog23]

Poster on our board said that has been a death in the Dustin Martin family. Don't know how close Dusty was to the person and if it will effect him. ALSO don't know if this is true as I haven't seen any news or anything about it, could be a private thing.

I've still got the C locked on him because he is plays better during these types of things, examples being when his Father was sent to NZ and during the contract saga last year. So I think he will use it as a motivator to go beast mode tonight.

The other possibility is he is a bit flat or down tonight and it impacts his scoring.

So if you have the C on him, might want to reconsider or look for alternatives if you don't feel confident.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Enright pleaded guilty, the incident is exactly the same

If anything Enright's example was more intentional .....and Sicily definitely did not stomp on the players leg

 

[Deliverance]

Yeah I'll stick the C on dusty I think. Melbourne have no match up for him when he goes forward. He should bag a few goals as well as running through the middle most of the game

Hibbard. Won't be effective, but will see Hibbard owners melt.

 

[Huttabito]

The wetter the better for dusty

I thought rain helps keep the dust down.

 

[Deliverance]

Poster on our board said that has been a death in the Dustin Martin family. Don't know how close Dusty was to the person and if it will effect him. ALSO don't know if this is true as I haven't seen any news or anything about it, could be a private thing.

I've still got the C locked on him because he is plays better during these types of things, examples being when his Father was sent to NZ and during the contract saga last year. So I think he will use it as a motivator to go beast mode tonight.

The other possibility is he is a bit flat or down tonight and it impacts his scoring.

So if you have the C on him, might want to reconsider or look for alternatives if you don't feel confident.

Hard to see it having an impact. I'm not sure there's a huge part of Dusty's grey matter dedicated to emotions. Or anything other than football, really.

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Poster on our board said that has been a death in the Dustin Martin family. Don't know how close Dusty was to the person and if it will effect him. ALSO don't know if this is true as I haven't seen any news or anything about it, could be a private thing.

I've still got the C locked on him because he is plays better during these types of things, examples being when his Father was sent to NZ and during the contract saga last year. So I think he will use it as a motivator to go beast mode tonight.

The other possibility is he is a bit flat or down tonight and it impacts his scoring.

So if you have the C on him, might want to reconsider or look for alternatives if you don't feel confident.

Apparently he has been flying to and from NZ on a regular basis since early 2016 (sometimes weekly) so despite his family issues he seems to be managing it very well given his on field input in the last two years.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Fritz out still?