Round 5 trades

[SCchamp]

Viney to Mayes

Also contemplating Stevenson to Docherty only because i want to do 2 pre planned trades next week!

 

[Crafted]

Dilemma - Mayes, Kerridge or Paparone? (that's in my preferred order, but interested in other opinions).

Mayes by a mile

 

[rocker_oz33]

I might bring in kerriage next week have it both ways if crouch is out longer he make have hes spot and hes dpp is handy.

Dam changing my mind Thinking mayes for viney the dpp is really handy good god 30K extra for viney is not really enough or wait on pizza man.

 

[illnino]

Mayes by a mile

Done.

Not too happy that I still have both Viney and Crouch but at least they are both on my bench. At least 1 will have to go next week I think.

 

[raymagoo]

Dilemma - Mayes, Kerridge or Paparone? (that's in my preferred order, but interested in other opinions).

No idea why you are all doing it tonight! Most involved are Sunday players or sat night. Wait to see who is sub or a late change! Not many involved tonight at all?

 

[tracygrimshaw]

Done.

Not too happy that I still have both Viney and Crouch but at least they are both on my bench. At least 1 will have to go next week I think.

Who did you trade out if you still have Viney and Crouch???

 

[LaffertyDaniel]

Wondering what to do with my rookies. Got one trade left this week.
Current rookies on the block include Stevenson, Viney, Crouch, Dywer, Caff and Neade. Thinking Stevenson > Docherty and Neade > Kerridge. So basically is it worth Crouch or Viney > Mayes? Burnt 7 trades already.

 

[illnino]

No idea why you are all doing it tonight! Most involved are Sunday players or sat night. Wait to see who is sub or a late change! Not many involved tonight at all?

Busy most of tomorrow...will take my chances

 

[illnino]

Who did you trade out if you still have Viney and Crouch???

Spangher

Left it til the last minute to finalize my team and ended up with him and Krakouer...Spangher had a decent preseason with us so I though he was a chance early. Will hold onto Krakouer after his promising effort in the VFL last weekend and Collingwood's disappointing effort last night. Not an ideal start I know, but I've surprisingly made a fair bit of cash even with those two wasting away on my bench. 2-0 too

 

[raymagoo]

Duffield late out & king

 

[Lotch]

Vlaustin (and Ellis) avoids starting as the sub to make way for Nahas.

Suban in for Duffield.

 

[PP34]

Duffield out.

Duffield >>> Dixon/Hartlett/Thomspon/Burgoyne/Grimes

Or do I go Duffield >>> Birchall by going Viney >>> Mayes ?

 

[Super Hans]

Duffield, Hanley, Stevenson, Viney, Crouch out. Sweeeeeeeeet.

Should I go Viney>Evens Duffield>Birchall?

 

[Satan]

Duffield out.

Duffield >>> Dixon/Hartlett/Thomspon/Burgoyne/Grimes

Or do I go Duffield >>> Birchall by going Viney >>> Mayes ?

opt 2

 

[TheOz]

Duffield out? So long ya spud.

 

[Plugger35]

Maister > LeCras
Siposs > Mayes

 

[LaffertyDaniel]

Finally settled with my trades.
Griffen > Buddy
Duffman > Birchall

 

[Super Hans]

Viney>Mayes.
Duffield>Grimes.

Done.

 

[TheOz]

Viney>Mayes.
Duffield>Grimes.

Done.

Great get is Grimes, been slowly going under the radar this year in a team being annihilated every week.

 

[Satan]

Great get is Grimes, been slowly going under the radar this year in a team being annihilated every week.

having a decent pre season helps

 

[Super Hans]

Great get is Grimes, been slowly going under the radar this year in a team being annihilated every week.

With everyone getting Birch in for Duffield, thought I'd take the unique and cheaper option.

 

[LaffertyDaniel]

With everyone getting Birch in for Duffield, thought I'd take the unique and cheaper option.

The question is, will Grimes be in the top 6 backs at the end of the year?

 

[TheOz]

With everyone getting Birch in for Duffield, thought I'd take the unique and cheaper option.

Would have done the exact same thing had I not started the season with Grimes. Hartlett would have been another option, take out the 38 in an injury affected game and his average is 120+.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

This is bad, real bad... Didn't know Duffman was a late exclusion so now that leaves me really thin at the back-line and I can't trade him out!
Terlich is my emergency, should I use him or trade him out?

 

[Deliverance]

The question is, will Grimes be in the top 6 backs at the end of the year?

No, the question is will Grimes be in the top six backs from round 5 onwards? Birchalls whole season average is irrelevant now.