Round 5 trades

[Krujan]

He has no Franklin though and I doubt Westhoff is going to keep up that hot streak all season.

Clokes a spud too, just been having a purple patch at the moment. Anyone remember last years Cloke?

I have Franklin. He's my F5

Cloke's B/E is -39. I'd rather have him starting than a rookie.

 

[toxic]

He does tag a fair bit so IMO I could see him having some average weeks when vsing solid opposition. Great player though!

He just tagged the best player we may all see and scored 150 odd - i'm amazed at ports improvement - whilst they are winning he will continue to score well

 

[Island Bomber]

To keep H Shaw or not? That is the big question.

 

[Shane Mead]

Come on guys...I have Kennedy and Lecras...think it is time to possibly bring in Cloke for one of those guys.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I have Franklin. He's my F5

Cloke's B/E is -39. I'd rather have him starting than a rookie.

Dwyers getting downgraded to Kerridge next week for me and Neade will become Buddy.

Kennedy will be my 6th forward but will eventually upgrade him.

 

[Krujan]

Dwyers getting downgraded to Kerridge next week for me and Neade will become Buddy.

Kennedy will be my 6th forward but will eventually upgrade him.

I'm planning on downgrading Hoff to Daisy in 2 weeks time and making 200k profit.

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'm planning on downgrading Hoff to Daisy in 2 weeks time and making 200k profit.

Nice mate

 

[digitalnash]

Preliminary trade thoughts for me... keep in mind I'm only 45 points off the leader, so I need to make season-long decisions.

Hanley -> Birchall.
Viney -> Evans.

Only questions are... is Hanley worth keeping, or do I need to get on Birchall NOW? (I'm leaning towards the latter)
And should I keep Viney around as a cash cow... I think there might be others who pose more value than him (Such as Kerridge, Evans etc)

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

May well hold off on trades this week. Only possible one i would think of doing would be Viney to Mayes, opening up my MID/FWD MPP. Next week will more than likely go Dwyer to Kerridge and maybe even Neade to Buddy. Will watch Docherty and Paperone closely this week and they may get traded in

 

[Kozivan]

Torn.

Hold off on trades this week and wait to downgrade the likes of viney, macaffer, stevenson, for next week when (kerridge,mayes,docherty) are on the bubble?

Or do something like viney>kerridge and stevenson>Birchall/Hanley straight up this week??

 

[GOAUS!]

Torn.

Hold off on trades this week and wait to downgrade the likes of viney, macaffer, stevenson, for next week when (kerridge,mayes,docherty) are on the bubble?

Or do something like viney>kerridge and stevenson>Birchall/Hanley straight up this week??

Mayes is on the bubble this week. Viney-> Mayes is looking very tempting.

 

[digitalnash]

Why would you guys trade to Mayes instead of to Evans?

 

[GOAUS!]

Why would you guys trade to Mayes instead of to Evans?

I don't know about Evan's JS. However if I go Evans this means I could go Neade -> Kerridge and Dwyer -> Buddy next week.

 

[Super Hans]

I don't know about Evan's JS. However if I go Evans this means I could go Neade -> Kerridge and Dwyer -> Buddy next week.

I might do a simular thing. Viney>Evans this week. Then Stevenson>Docerty and Stevens>Dangerfield

 

[JR95]

Hey guys first time poster in this thread but a huge SuperCoach fan. Was wondering if I.could get some feedback on my team by posting it here and seeing what some of you guys would do?

 

[ohh_v]

Does Gawn have good JS? Was thinking of going Blicavs to Gawn/Daw and then Duff to Birchall.

 

[Sidebottom2Beams]

He has no Franklin though and I doubt Westhoff is going to keep up that hot streak all season.

Clokes a spud too, just been having a purple patch at the moment. Anyone remember last years Cloke?

Cloke is playing this year as a stay at home FF and Lynch is drawing the help away from him. There is a huge difference in this year and last year when talking about Cloke.

 

[Super Hans]

To keep H Shaw or not? That is the big question.

Can't see why you'd trade him. When you picked Shaw you knew what you were going to get.. Inconsistent and will miss games, but is a gun.

 

[Sidebottom2Beams]

Just cancelled my trade and have gone Blicavs to Osborn and Moloney to Mark Murphy.

 

[dlanod]

SC Gold has it at 135

SC Gold's break evens are wrong.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

SC Gold's break evens are wrong.

Who's BE's are correct? Is TooSerious close?

 

[September 27 2008]

Who's BE's are correct? Is TooSerious close?

http://supercoachcoach.com.au/blog/comments/round-4-breakeven-table

This goes alright!

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

http://supercoachcoach.com.au/blog/comments/round-4-breakeven-table

This goes alright!

Cheers mate, very similair to TS

 

[toxic]

Come on guys...I have Kennedy and Lecras...think it is time to possibly bring in Cloke for one of those guys.

Certainly not LeCras - massive upside in the silky frenchman

 

[toxic]

Can't see why you'd trade him. When you picked Shaw you knew what you were going to get.. Inconsistent and will miss games, but is a gun.

Spot on - all about the average not the game to game performance