Round 5 trades

[Obese Arachnid]

Reversed trades. Keeping Goodes in the mids, keeping L Brown.
Not taking Mayes or Evans.
Viney or Crouch to Swan?

I guess it should be Crouch.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Reversed trades. Keeping Goodes in the mids, keeping L Brown.
Not taking Mayes or Evans.
Viney or Crouch to Swan?

I guess it should be Crouch.

I originally traded Viney out but reversed it just now due to Crouch's injury.

So Crouch.

 

[toxic]

Hmm, who would you suggest if not Evans?

Mayes and Paparone, Taylor Duryea from hawks

 

[Double the Fist]

NO LATE CHANGES
INTERCHANGE
Essendon: David Hille, Travis Colyer, Ben Howlett
Substitute: David Myers
Collingwood: Jarryd Blair, Paul Seedsman, Sam Dwyer
Substitute: Tyson Goldsack

... and anyones thougths on Rampe pls.

 

[Sir Skid]

Mayes and Paparone, Taylor Duryea from hawks

Mayes & Paparone but I'd rather go without the Durex!

 

[Double the Fist]

I originally traded Viney out but reversed it just now due to Crouch's injury.

So Crouch.

Agreed. Couch will sit out for two at least I reckon. If you have cover then I'd leave him in. I'm forced to make a trade regrettably.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

After all that think ill hold Caff for now. Should i go Viney to Mayes and Crouch to Paparone? Already have trades for next week planned so cant wait that extra week with Paps

 

[CasuallyDressed]

After all that think ill hold Caff for now. Should i go Viney to Mayes and Crouch to Paparone? Already have trades for next week planned so cant wait that extra week with Paps

Mayes in particular looks very good.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Mayes in particular looks very good.

What about a crouch to paparone trade? I have cover for Crouch if it matters? Should i trade him out though, could be 3 weeks or so on my pine

 

[Sultana]

NO LATE CHANGES
INTERCHANGE
Essendon: David Hille, Travis Colyer, Ben Howlett
Substitute: David Myers
Collingwood: Jarryd Blair, Paul Seedsman, Sam Dwyer
Substitute: Tyson Goldsack

... and anyones thougths on Rampe pls.

Rampe played relatively well in the last game, he didn't get that many possessions but most were effective. He won't be getting that much of the ball though because of Sydney's strong midfield. I would expect about the same scores as he has been getting the two games he's played - mid 40s to mid 50s, if he gets regular games. I would say he's playing better than Tony Armstrong and Jetta at the moment.
If you're thinking about taking him as a rookie midfielder, he may take a bit longer than your average cash cow to mature, but I don't think he will be a complete slow burner.
Hope that helps!

 

[Jiska]

Reversed trades. Keeping Goodes in the mids, keeping L Brown.
Not taking Mayes or Evans.
Viney or Crouch to Swan?

I guess it should be Crouch.

Don't think Viney will play for the next two weeks so much a muchness. As none of those trades involved players playing today, just reverse your trades and sit pretty until teams are announced and trade tomorrow instead.

 

[DeeWong6996]

What to do with Broughton? No spare cash in the bank, so looking to trade sideways or downgrade

 

[Sir Skid]

What to do with Broughton? No spare cash in the bank, so looking to trade sideways or downgrade

Maybe Docherty next week is an option.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

What about a crouch to paparone trade? I have cover for Crouch if it matters? Should i trade him out though, could be 3 weeks or so on my pine

It's up to you.

I still think Viney will make a bit of money from here though.

 

[DeeWong6996]

It's up to you.

I still think Viney will make a bit of money from here though.

Agree, not sure why people are jumping off Viney. He still has quite a bit to rise and the alternatives, namely Evans and Mayes, will be edged out of the 22 when the calvary returns.

 

[DeeWong6996]

Any good mid priced defenders?

 

[rhaz]

He still has quite a bit to rise and the alternatives, namely Evans and Mayes, will be edged out of the 22 when the calvary returns.

Our injury list is basically doesn't exist except for a couple of talls. There are no "cavalry' to return in place of Evans - and with the way he has been playing, I wouldn't be surprised if he was in the side for quite a long time.

 

[M_I_G]

Last minute advice..urgent!! Cloke or westhoff?? Think cloke better in long run but wanted Hoff 3 weeks ago and think I'm living in the past..any help? Guess I'm just worried Carlisle will keep him quiet

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Don't think Viney will play for the next two weeks so much a muchness. As none of those trades involved players playing today, just reverse your trades and sit pretty until teams are announced and trade tomorrow instead.

Can't, need Swan in today, thanks

 

[illnino]

Thinking...

Varcoe ---> Swan/Pendles/Cornes/Watson/Cotchin/Delidio (would leave Viney and Crouch as my bench, with Moloney and O'Meara as my only non-premium starting mids)

Bit too crazy at this time of year? Doesn't leave me much midfield coverage assuming Viney gets dropped and Crouch is out for longer than the expected 2 weeks.

That would leave me, at worst (Pendles - $650k), $196k left. Then thinking...

Spangher (thought he may have played by now after his preseason) <---> Cash-cow forward (would leave me with 3 premium forwards, and with Krakouer and one of Neade, Dwyer, Rowe or said cash cow on the bench)

Thoughts? Hoping Kraks is back within the next week or two after 32 touches in the VFL last weekend.

 

[DeeWong6996]

Our injury list is basically doesn't exist except for a couple of talls. There are no "cavalry' to return in place of Evans - and with the way he has been playing, I wouldn't be surprised if he was in the side for quite a long time.

I agree to some extent, but the willingness of our selection committee to chop and change leaves me in doubt. Evans performed well last week granted, but so did a good chunk of our squad. Toumpas, Kent and Rodan could potentially take his spot in later weeks.

 

[Sultana]

Last minute advice..urgent!! Cloke or westhoff?? Think cloke better in long run but wanted Hoff 3 weeks ago and think I'm living in the past..any help? Guess I'm just worried Carlisle will keep him quiet

I don't think you should be trying to chase Westhoff's points from the past few weeks, Port Adelaide have had an easy run so far. I am skeptical as to how he will do against better teams.

 

[illnino]

Varcoe ---> Swan/Pendles/Cornes/Watson/Cotchin/Delidio (would leave Viney and Crouch as my bench, with Moloney and O'Meara as my only non-premium starting mids)

Ended up with Swan in a last minute trade. $211k still in the bank.

Spangher (thought he may have played by now after his preseason) <---> Cash-cow forward (would leave me with 3 premium forwards, and with Krakouer and one of Neade, Dwyer, Rowe or said cash cow on the bench)

Thoughts? Hoping Kraks is back within the next week or two after 32 touches in the VFL last weekend.

Still after some thoughts on this please guys?

 

[Danco]

Once the rolling lockout starts, you can't reverse trades so you'll be stuck with only the 1st one.

I know i'm stuck with the 1st one once rolling lockout starts... but I don't lose the 2nd trade.

 

[tracygrimshaw]

HELP!!!

Mayes and Lecras
or
Evans and Gibbs