Round 5 Trades

[mochacinolatte]

ZWilliams > Heeney = sideways trade or upgrade?


roughead.gif

Idk, Williams is having a meh season so far.

The top 4 defenders at the moment.

Whitfield
Lloyd
Hurn
Laird

The rest seems speculative. Could Williams be Top 6? Not likely imo.

Right now I want Whitfield cause he looks like he is gonna balloon all the way to 660k.

Edit: Didn't even answer your question. Yes I would trade Williams as I believe Heeney will be a Top 6 forward and Keeper compared to Williams he probably hover around 85-90 average. Heeney more likely 100-105. So throughout the rest of the 18 games. You be leaking - 270 points in total. Worth the 100k upgrade.

 

[Blueboys11]

Balta has me stumped. Why only about 40% TOG?

Never going to score playing so little

 

[Benno_900]

So Danger and Setters may be suspended
Rozee and Parker picked up knocks and may be rested
Drew may be dropped
And Balta is a spud

That's okay - I don't need any forwards...

 

[GT619]

Hore or stack

 

[Ingall]

Maybe.....

Moore + Davies-Uniacke > Hurn + Stack

Maybe. I'll probably end up doing nothing this week though.

 

[SumTingWong]

Balta & Parker > Marshall & Stack

Feels nice

Why do people keep thinking they can trade a mid for a forward?

 

[stevebbb]

Why do people keep thinking they can trade a mid for a forward?

They probably have Setterfield in the midfield. DPP wizardry

 

[Juzzomac]

Why do people keep thinking they can trade a mid for a forward?

Dual position players. Likely someone like Setterfield in the mids who will take the FWD place vacated by one of the players.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Was thinking of doing the following:

Lockhart > Hore (Uncle Jisk thinks I'm nuts!)
Shitterfield > Marshall

Leaves me with $175k to either go a 1 down, 1 up next week and turn a Def rookie into Lloyd/ Whitfield or if Sheed decides to stink it up again, I can upgrade him to Piggy.

Any thoughts would be appreciated

 

[hsaklag]

Don't trust Stack's job security so probably no trades and will see how Ross and Rotham go again this week

 

[stevebbb]

Don't trust Stack's job security so probably no trades and will see how Ross and Rotham go again this week

Rotham has played 2 games, going up in price this week. BE of -82, now or never

 

[Keg on legs]

Seagull and 55k

Or

Boak and 115k

Or

Heeney (roughie move) and 143k


Undecided at this stage

 

[rocker_oz33]

I need a forward after trading greene down last week.

Scott to stack.
Butters to marshmallow man .

Fuuuuuu these spud rookies .

 

[DrummoSolo]

Butters > Stack
Parker > Rockliff via Rozee and Duursma DPP

Pending injuries and suspensions.

 

[hsaklag]

Rotham has played 2 games, going up in price this week. BE of -82, now or never

Oh shit you're right. Turns out 2 seconds of research isn't enough

 

[stevebbb]

Seagull and 55k

Or

Boak and 115k

Or

Heeney (roughie move) and 143k


Undecided at this stage

Depends on your on field rookies on each line

Scrimshaw at D6 vs Setterfield/Parker at F6 scenario for example, then you need a forward. I'd go Boak, because Heeney out and Heeney back in is ridiculous a move I simply cannot accept (unless injuries forces them to miss weeks)

Sorry JM!

 

[Andrew Birch]

Why do people keep thinking they can trade a mid for a forward?

Why do you think they can't?

 

[AN1611]

What are everyone's thoughts on
Clark to Hore
Butters to Rocky

Slightly worried Hutchings goes to Rocky

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Who is safer?

Hore or Stack? I feel both could easily be turfed out

 

[nahnah]

Moore’s fattened up nicely, almost ready to be cashed in

 

[Spider Eater]

Is anyone with Bines considering trading in O'Brien for someone and having Bines as a FWD doughnut?
When is Jacobs back for the Crows anyway?

 

[stevebbb]

Is anyone with Bines considering trading in O'Brien for someone and having Bines as a FWD doughnut?
When is Jacobs back for the Crows anyway?

Listed as 1-2 weeks, so it's too risky for me. Sauce will come straight in when he's ready

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

What are everyone's thoughts on
Clark to Hore
Butters to Rocky

Slightly worried Hutchings goes to Rocky

Hutchings surely goes to Boak. Rocky doesn’t hurt you as much as Boak will. Rocky with dinky little kicks and Boak goes longer plus hits the scoreboard(More impact on the game)

 

[evo]

Who is safer?

Hore or Stack? I feel both could easily be turfed out

Dimmer said that Stack reminds him of Byron Pickett (who he played with), seems to be universally loved.

Short is injured for 8 weeks, so Houli is probably Stacks only danger.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Dimmer said that Stack reminds him of Byron Pickett (who he played with), seems to be universally loved.

Short is injured for 8 weeks, so Houli is probably Stacks only danger.

I am thinking of backing him in. I liked what i saw, even if he didn't get scored as well.

Interesting to see him play at Marvel. Could light it up