Trades Round 5 Trades

[cdcanman]

Waterman vs Bergman?

A phrase I never thought I would hear myself saying.

No, but really, Waterman vs Bergman?

 

[toxic]

Waterman vs Bergman?

A phrase I never thought I would hear myself saying.

No, but really, Waterman vs Bergman?

Berg

 

[Tulendeena]

Brock,Scott > Heppell,Aquaman

Can't decide which to flick so they can both go

 

[stevebbb]

faaaarking hell, still can't decide between Jordon or Campbell out for Waterman. Need the cash so it has to happen

I'm $300 off booting Brockman and holding both Jordon and Campbell, which sucks, but I think Brockman is decent long hold, so that softens the blow

50/50 call, I just know I'm going to make the wrong decision lol

Campbell has 100s in him with his role and taking kick-ins, but Jordon has shown he can score well, tackles a lot, and maybe he gets more midfield time over the next couple weeks with Fritsch out

aaarrgghhhh this decision is going to be the death of me

 

[JT_the_Man]

After mulling it over for far too long

Butters to Waterman
Daniel to Mills

Can’t stand the sight of that Helmet in my team anymore. So he must go.

 

[toxic]

faaaarking hell, still can't decide between Jordon or Campbell out for Waterman. Need the cash so it has to happen

I'm $300 off booting Brockman and holding both Jordon and Campbell, which sucks, but I think Brockman is decent long hold, so that softens the blow

50/50 call, I just know I'm going to make the wrong decision lol

Campbell has 100s in him with his role and taking kick-ins, but Jordon has shown he can score well, tackles a lot, and maybe he gets more midfield time over the next couple weeks with Fritsch out

aaarrgghhhh this decision is going to be the death of me

Bye Jordon

 

[Tso1967]

Just Jordan to F. Macrae - 175k in bank if Flynn is named.

Flynn FFS

Meek to Hickey 2nd trade- Sod all in bank now.

F. Macrae on E loop

 

[JT_the_Man]

faaaarking hell, still can't decide between Jordon or Campbell out for Waterman. Need the cash so it has to happen

I'm $300 off booting Brockman and holding both Jordon and Campbell, which sucks, but I think Brockman is decent long hold, so that softens the blow

50/50 call, I just know I'm going to make the wrong decision lol

Campbell has 100s in him with his role and taking kick-ins, but Jordon has shown he can score well, tackles a lot, and maybe he gets more midfield time over the next couple weeks with Fritsch out

aaarrgghhhh this decision is going to be the death of me

Campbell has the higher BE iirc

Don’t envy having to make that call though...

 

[Chipmunk]

With Fullarton being dropped, is Fullarton -> Waterman an option?

Reasons against are it’s only 60k gained, and although I’m on Gawndy-Flynn he may be useful as an R3 down the track.

Otherwise as an existing Bergman owner I have my shiny new Fwd already so might pass on Waterman and do no trades. I have Daniel but holding him and hoping he comes good.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

What are all you kents doing with Brockman?

Hold, Kosi out for Aquaman

Reckon Brockman will stay in, but if misses I have a loop.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

What are all you kents doing with Brockman?

Holding til Macrae is on the bubble after next week easy trade

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

With Fullarton being dropped, is Fullarton -> Waterman an option?

Reasons against are it’s only 60k gained, and although I’m on Gawndy-Flynn he may be useful as an R3 down the track.

Otherwise as an existing Bergman owner I have my shiny new Fwd already so might pass on Waterman and do no trades. I have Daniel but holding him and hoping he comes good.

I'd hold. Perfect to move to R3 when trading out Flynn. You might have to skip Waterman. Not the end of the work, lots of rookies coming in the next few weeks.

 

[Hamez]

Who would you trade out of Scott or HJones > Waterman

 

[Blackhawk42]

Okay screw it, Bergman has to stay.

Jordon to Waterman
Sharp to Jiath

That will leave me with over $100k going into next week too.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Waterman vs Bergman?

A phrase I never thought I would hear myself saying.

No, but really, Waterman vs Bergman?

One costs 102K, has a BE of -77 and is pretty secure in the team.
Other costs 123K, has a BE of -17 and is only in the team due to injuries.

Does that help?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Who would you trade out of Scott or HJones > Waterman

Scott probably only has one week left before getting dropped. Jones has great JS. If you don't trade Scott this week it will be soon.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Who would you trade out of Scott or HJones > Waterman

Scott handy dpp
Jones better job security

think Scott will score slightly better in the next few weeks so I would trade Jones on that premise

 

[Cactus_]

I’m not so big a man that I can’t admit when I was wrong:

Phillips —> L.Jones (via DPP)
Meek —> Grundy

 

[hoddo]

Selection/injury carnage means I have two trade options this week. Both of them will result in an unavoidable donut in either defence or the ruck. I'll have to miss out on Waterman or I'll cop a second donut.

Option 1:
May>Ridley and Parks>Jones
This option means a donut in the ruck.
Pros ... Get Ridley before he rises more in price.
Cons ... If Flynn and Meek miss again next week I'll need a further trade to avoid another donut and may not be able to afford a decent one.
Bank ... about $112k

Option 2:
May>Jones and Meek>Grundy
This option means a donut in defence.
Pros ... With Daniel returning there should be no likely donut next week.
Cons ... If Flynn returns next week and keeps playing it will mean a lot of cash and a lot of points sitting on the bench.
Bank ... about $189k

Option 2 seems the best to me but I'd love to know what others think.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Holding til Macrae is on the bubble after next week easy trade

So, out of Brock, Jordan, Cambpell, Scott and McNeil, who would you flick for Waterman?

The Dogs guys don't score much but don't look like getting dropped. Also low breakevens and both picked this week.

Brockman poor scorer too but DPP and reasonable job security.

Campbell is easily the best scorer but has that 29 to with through. Probably still has cash to make.

Jordan started well but dropped off against good teams. Has a couple of easier games coming through.

It's a really tough pick.

 

[GOAUS!]

Butters to Waterman and Sharp to Jones (P.A.). Gotta get that ca$h generation.

I'm holding onto Jelly and Daniel.

 

[Northernsoul74]

What are all you kents doing with Brockman?

Leaving him on the bench.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Butters to Waterman
Kosi to Jiath

Hold spud Daniel

Only problem I see is that completes my backline and I don’t have the Gull or Mills.

Or Whitfield.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

So, out of Brock, Jordan, Cambpell, Scott and McNeil, who would you flick for Waterman?

The Dogs guys don't score much but don't look like getting dropped. Also low breakevens and both picked this week.

Brockman poor scorer too but DPP and reasonable job security.

Campbell is easily the best scorer but has that 29 to with through. Probably still has cash to make.

Jordan started well but dropped off against good teams. Has a couple of easier games coming through.

It's a really tough pick.

McNeil or Scott for me. One of them will go out for Helmut next week. Which one is anyones guess, probably the one you hold!

 

[JuddgementDay]

I've been having to do 2 trades each week so far, due to a mix of injuries, suspensions and team selections.

So this week another two:
1. Heeney to Waterman/ Berg???
2. Fullarton to Hickey