Round 5 Trades

[MightyMark]

Pendles is looking at a BE around 200 this week, Im holding off and waiting for one of my mid pricers like Parker to jump up before i make the move to him...

Yeah thats why im holding off an extra week, hoping to pick him up under 600k after next week, before that 62 is out of the equation. He has given us a golden opputunity to get him as a bargain.

It's prob going to screw me for the byes, but i've given up trying to navigate that, too many other issues to deal with.

 

[mrbewbs]

Dickson > Treloar, and I may look at offloading Smith soon if he isn't named.

 

[JasRulz63]

Gray has to go for obvious reasons, I guess the one positive is that he hasn't dropped him price. Poor bugger though, that injury was painful to watch, let alone endure.

Anyway I'm thinking;
Dickson > Treloar
Gray > Sidebottom (not many other options, I can swing Smedts forward, which gives me a choice of defenders under 488k; Sucking/Malceski etc.)

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Care to tell me where you are ranked overall ya flog?

I wouldn't want to make you feel inadequate.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Not resorting to name calling here.

Just stating the fact that he's a flog like a few of the other flogs, muppets and trolls on here thats all.

EEEEK I'm glad I aint one of those guys ^^^^ miss piggy!!

 

[Dirtywhirl]

Tempted to go Ledger to Treloar, but don't want to be left with too many GWS rookies and no-one to downgrade to mid-season

 

[CrimsonButterfly]

OUT: Fyfe IN: Tippett + $$$

Have to wait on Ablett, I guess.

 

[Adz]

Do you guys think it's worth trading Martin for someone like Dahlhaus or Sidebottom??

 

[St 07]

I'll do it while crying but it's come down to Carrazzo for either Geary or Suckling for mine.

And I can't bloody decide which. Any advice?

The head says Suckling but the heart (and wallet) say Geary.

 

[MightyMark]

Do you guys think it's worth trading Martin for someone like Dahlhaus or Sidebottom??

I'd go Sidebottom, I think with Ball out he will be playing a bigger role.

Dahlhaus will be a better POD, I just dont think he will be getting big scores against the better opposition.

 

[scythe]

ledger > parker. paid a 50k premium for not noticing him earlier, but i reckon it'll be worth it.

my gut says consider ablett > stanton, anyone care to talk me out of it?

 

[MightyMark]

ledger > parker. paid a 50k premium for not noticing him earlier, but i reckon it'll be worth it.

my gut says consider ablett > stanton, anyone care to talk me out of it?

Based on what the medico's have said, and Abletts facebook/twitter, it was just a strain, nothing to serious.

 

[Marlowe]

Swan's price continues to drop, and I'm really starting to regret not trading him for Murphy back in round 2. At this point I'd have to settle for either S. Selwood, Kennedy or Stanton, I don't think it's worth it at the moment, however.

Decisions, decisions...

 

[MightyMark]

Swan's price continues to drop, and I'm really starting to regret not trading him for Murphy back in round 2. At this point I'd have to settle for either S. Selwood, Kennedy or Stanton, I don't think it's worth it at the moment, however.

Decisions, decisions...

Why trade Swan, 121 on the weekend, looks like he might be finding some form. No point sideways trading premiums just for cash.

Unless of course your one of those lucky bastards that doesnt have to fix up your team.

 

[TigerGlory]

Fyfe -> Treloar

Carrazzo -> God help me I dont know.

 

[MightyMark]

Fyfe -> Treloar

Carrazzo -> God help me I dont know.

Scotland probably your best bet scoring wise.

But Geary could be handy, plus he could save you another 150K. Which added to your saving from the FYfe trade, could net you 2 premiums the following week.

 

[NSWCROW]

Hurley>Darling thoughts ??

 

[christoff91]

what are peoples thoughts on treloars job security?

 

[MightyMark]

Hurley>Darling thoughts ??

Yeah could work nicely, had a shocker against GWS, but otherwise has done well. Another left field option, if your a risk taker, could be Clancee Pearce, pretty much the same price. If you exclude is sub affected 15 from round 1, he is killing it, plus he is MPP.

 

[NSWCROW]

Another left field option, if your a risk taker, could be Clancee Pearce, pretty much the same price. If you exclude is sub affected 15 from round 1, he is killing it, plus he is MPP.

Hmmmmmmmmm

Thx bloke

 

[hawkman]

Caddy > McDonald will give me 420k spare so i will upgrade Magner to Pendlebury the following week

 

[Sainters12]

Gone with Boyd > Parker & Ledger > McDonald

Boyds' disposal worries me, gets a lot of the ball but usually handballs or misses targets. Should be avging 150 when getting 35+ touches but disposal efficiency lets him down big time, add the fact that Dogs aren't winning . Parker is coming good in a winning team, hopefully continues his good form!

Ledger to McDonald is pretty straight forward. McDonald at 106k is a bargain and will get a game every week whereas Ledger is pretty injury-prone.

Also gives me 420k in the kitty

 

[MightyMark]

Gone with Boyd > Parker & Ledger > McDonald

Boyds' disposal worries me, gets a lot of the ball but usually handballs or misses targets. Should be avging 150 when getting 35+ touches but disposal efficiency lets him down big time, add the fact that Dogs aren't winning . Parker is coming good in a winning team, hopefully continues his good form!

Ledger to McDonald is pretty straight forward. McDonald at 106k is a bargain and will get a game every week whereas Ledger is pretty injury-prone.

Also gives me 420k in the kitty

Not sure i'd be downgrading Boyd just yet, he is a proven scorer and his efficiency has been an issue for a long time, and he still manages to dominate.

Keep in mind he still managed 85 from 19 touches whilst being tagged this week.

Parker would be a handy pick up, but trading out a premium is generally a bad idea, especially as he isn't exactly bombing at the moment.

Thats my two cents.

 

[Ed_Gein]

^ yeah i was going to say that. boyd has always had efficiency problems, no doubt it should have been in mind when selecting him.

for me just 1 trade, i'll probably bring in treloar for either boumann or ledger.

 

[dlanod]

what are peoples thoughts on treloars job security?

Should be good. Always been one of the highly regarded GWS kids (along with Shiel), and it looks like they're not going to go as heavy on the rotations as GC did.