Round 6 Trades (S.O.S)

[ozzyoslo]

Kreuzer officially back in the 22 (And not on the bench), thank f 4 that!

Blues changes are now only Bower & Ellard in for Judd & Waite

Yeah Im happy....would have been my 1st donut for the season and was happy to go in knowing that after the start to the season.

 

[Propagandhi]

Devon Smith survives by being named. I'd like to keep Chad but he'll cost me another donut this week if I don't trade him and there doesn't seem to be any definite answers on when he'll return.

Out: Cornes, Ablett
In: Zaha, Pendlebury

Gives me Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Martin and Zaha in my fwd line. Hooray for mid priced FWD/MID players that could break out...

 

[toxic]

Pfeiffer's on the bench, so all good there.

I'm facing a donut on the forwards for the second week running. With Smith named, I'm forced to hold on to him so my trade options:

Mumford (only two weeks until he's back) > Renouf (best ruck I could find cheap enough)
Hall > Hawkins

-or-

Hall > one of Pfeiffer (second game), Adams (higher score, only first game), or Wilkes (mature body, also only first game).

Anyone have any thoughts?

rather than renouf (who is a proper spud) consider Sam Jacobs from the crows - seems to ahve finally found his place.
Wilkes - no long term security, Pfieffer - seems a matter of time till he gets dropped and adams will be a part of sheedys rotation policy all year

 

[dlanod]

rather than renouf (who is a proper spud) consider Sam Jacobs from the crows - seems to ahve finally found his place.
Wilkes - no long term security, Pfieffer - seems a matter of time till he gets dropped and adams will be a part of sheedys rotation policy all year

I know that all three have question marks above them, but if I want to downgrade Hall those appear to be my only three realistic options.

As to bringing in Jacobs, he is $488k. Renouf is $248k. I'd only trade Mumford to upgrade Hall, and bringing in Jacobs doesn't let me do that.

 

[Adz]

Is Cameron from GWS playing?

 

[Super Hans]

rioli or zaharakis for fyfe? or maybe beams? cheers

 

[yummy6]

rioli or zaharakis for fyfe? or maybe beams? cheers

Lewis or Sidebottom. But Hawks have a good draw coming.

 

[Chism]

Redden out B Longer in.

Can't afford the doughnut in the ruck this week and whatever he scores will be better than a 0. Redden has been a ghost since opening up well and i don't know if Port will play much this year especially with Lobbe close to healthy now.

Thank god i took Giles from the start and he has been awesome this year.

Sandi injury is hurting me but i am not trading him unless he does not play next week. Word from Freo is he will be good to go and was a chance this week but the flight over etc saw him get another weeks rest.

Rucks have been a nightmare this year.

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

Is Cameron from GWS playing?

J Cameron? Nope out with a Calf...

 

[hawka187]

J Cameron? Nope out with a Calf...

Great I have Smedts as backup hopefully his not sub

 

[jackn]

Trading out fyfe this week and looking for a forward who shares the R12 bye. The top of the (very short, most forwards I like aren't R12 bye) list for me at the moment are zaha and hawkins.

Others I considered were chappy, pav, stevie j, ro'k but I thought they may all be past their SC best. Goodes would be ideal but I can't afford him.

Any thoughts on who you feel would be better between zaharakis and hawkins would be most appreciated.

Note: I have steele already

 

[Antz]

J Cameron? Nope out with a Calf...

If he is out with a calf why is he selected as an emergency?

 

[Satan]

If he is out with a calf why is he selected as an emergency?

Must be a kruezer type injury

 

[silent butcher]

Is Cameron from GWS playing?

No he's injured

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

If he is out with a calf why is he selected as an emergency?

Says on AFL site that he is out with Calf....But Also HS confirmed out in the Friday live teams segment...Maybe not updated yet??

 

[dipper86]

T Adams or Horsley

 

[rocker_oz33]

Trading out fyfe this week and looking for a forward who shares the R12 bye. The top of the (very short, most forwards I like aren't R12 bye) list for me at the moment are zaha and hawkins.

Others I considered were chappy, pav, stevie j, ro'k but I thought they may all be past their SC best. Goodes would be ideal but I can't afford him.

Any thoughts on who you feel would be better between zaharakis and hawkins would be most appreciated.

Note: I have steele already

Allen christensen about 30k cheaper than zaha.

 

[toxic]

Trading out fyfe this week and looking for a forward who shares the R12 bye. The top of the (very short, most forwards I like aren't R12 bye) list for me at the moment are zaha and hawkins.

Others I considered were chappy, pav, stevie j, ro'k but I thought they may all be past their SC best. Goodes would be ideal but I can't afford him.

Any thoughts on who you feel would be better between zaharakis and hawkins would be most appreciated.

Note: I have steele already

cloke, pav, stevie J, christenson and from really left field Sylvia

 

[Seppo]

Thank god for Kruezer coming back in and the reverse trade button!
means I only had to make the 1 trade this week not to cope a big fat donut. Shifted Fyfe to the midfield and upgraded him to Pendles leaving 50k in the bank. Unfortunately that has destroyed my last MPP link to the mid with 4 available in the forward line! Hope to correct that next week with Shield/Coniglio downgraded to Pfeiffer.

Going into this week with:
Brendon Goddard, Greg Broughton, Tomas Bugg, Nick Malceski, Marty Clarke, Brian Lake, Grant Birchall
Chris Yarran, Brandon Ellis (e)

Scott Pendlebury(c), Joel Selwood, Michael Barlow(vc), Luke Parker, James Magner, Dylan Shiel
Gary Ablett jnr, Stephen Coniglio (e)

Jonathan Giles, Matthew Kreuzer
Aaron Sandilands, Jarrad Redden

Lance Franklin, Steele Sidebottom, Dustin Martin, Rhys Stanley, Jason Porplyzia, Adam Kennedy, Billie Smedts
Aaron Hall, Adam Treloar(e)

Have no playing emergency up front, but want to risk it to save making another trade (19 left).

 

[Eons]

T Adams or Horsley

Horsley. Think he'll be a more consistent scorer than Adams and he won't get rested like all the kids at GWS.

 

[hellfire]

I'll either do:

IN: Swan, Lewis
OUT: Ablett, Fyfe

or

IN: Pfeiffer, Lewis
OUT: D.Smith, Fyfe

Also considering Dangerfield given he is roughly $50k cheaper, but I'd feel more comfortable with Lewis.

 

[m!nt]

Out: Fyfe, D. Smith
In: Pfeiffer, Sidebottom

 

[pulpdriver]

What sounds better to everyone?

Fyfe > Brown (and hope he has his regular Ess style game and becomes solid F7)
Magner > Pendlebury

or

Fyfe > Sidebottom
Smith > Pfeiffer
(leaving Pendles to come in next week)

 

[cooneyman]

Tossing up between Pfeffier and Taylor Adams as replacement for Devon Smith?

Thoughts ?

 

[BORK]

19 left before these trade scenarios..

Out Whitecross Magner/Sheil
In Pfieffer Pendlebury

or
Out Hall In Pfeiffer

Should I give up on Whitecross if it means I get Pendlebury?? And which of Magner or Sheil should go?

May hold Ablett. Does my head in though.