Teams SC 2015 - My team (During NAB)

[Krujan]

Alright cheers Thanks for the advice. Any other small changes needed to happen?

I wouldn't have even made those 2 changes. Reckon KK will score well & Dusty to average more than Swan this year.

I don't like the Higgins selection, but that's personal. Hard to find anything positive to say about the burnman posterboy.

 

[Fitzey]

I wouldn't have even made those 2 changes. Reckon KK will score well & Dusty to average more than Swan this year.

I don't like the Higgins selection, but that's personal. Hard to find anything positive to say about the burnman posterboy.

Thanks, Should I trade him to Docherty or who else?

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

my current beast

def
gibson, jaensch, higgins, shephard, clanceeeee, dalgleish, dick, saad

mids
ablett, kennedy, sidebum, danger, griff, a swallow, montagna, vandenberg, ellis-yolmen, c smith, krak

rucks

maric, nic nat read

for's
gray, dusty, salem, m clark, j hogan, lonie, karnezis, lambert

Picking 7 prems in the midfield is too many.
Need at least 1 more rookie in there for cash generation.

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Any advice/suggestions? Played Supercoach before but only casually, looking to challenge some of my mates this year. Have 62k salary cap remaining.

Backs - Heath Shaw, Brodie Smith, Jack Newnes, Taylor Hunt, Jamie MacMillan, Nathan Brown (Shaun Edwards, Joel Hamling)

Mids - Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Matt Priddis, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Steven, Daniel Rich, Nathan Van Berlo, Ben Newton (Jed Anderson, Nathan Freeman, Trent Dumont)

Rucks - Todd Goldstein, Nic Naitanui (Sam Durdin)

Forwards - Dane Swan, Jack Ziebell, Tom Mitchell, Jeremy Cameron, Mitch Clark, Jesse Hogan (Jack Steele, Nathan Krakouer)

Look at downgrading at least 1 of your midfield midpricers to a rookie.
This will give you some more money to upgrade the forward line.
Traditionally key fwds are inconsistent supercoach scorers. I'd look at upgrading Cameron to Dusty or even Gray if u have the $$.

 

[buttox]

i think the 6 foreward rookies should cover it nicely. also cant see a prem foreward except the 2 ive got + bartel and godard (whove bounced in and out of my team) score more than montagna at d7

 

[Krujan]

Thanks, Should I trade him to Docherty or who else?

Just because I don't like the selection, doesn't mean you should trade him. If you think he will score enough to justify his 410k price tag & not get injured, then back him in. Docherty isn't going to make much difference, either way. But out of the 2 Doc has more upside IMO.

 

[Fitzey]

Just because I don't like the selection, doesn't mean you should trade him. If you think he will score enough to justify his 410k price tag & not get injured, then back him in. Docherty isn't going to make much difference, either way. But out of the 2 Doc has more upside IMO.

I really have no clue mate haha. Coming from an AFL Fantasy background this is a whole different comp. I will keep looking around and might bring in doc atm.

 

[Stickers32]

I wouldn't have even made those 2 changes. Reckon KK will score well & Dusty to average more than Swan this year.

I don't like the Higgins selection, but that's personal. Hard to find anything positive to say about the burnman posterboy.

they'll end up probably averaging the same yet swan is 70k cheaper. no brainer.

doesn't bother me though just my opinion.

 

[Kadog]

Fitzey i think your team overall is pretty solid as is. KK @ d5 is good.

 

[Krujan]

they'll end up probably averaging the same yet swan is 70k cheaper. no brainer.

doesn't bother me though just my opinion.

I have both.

 

[Deddy]

Look at downgrading at least 1 of your midfield midpricers to a rookie.
This will give you some more money to upgrade the forward line.
Traditionally key fwds are inconsistent supercoach scorers. I'd look at upgrading Cameron to Dusty or even Gray if u have the $$.

IN - Gray, Martin, Salem, Cripps
OUT - Ziebell, Mitchell, Cameron, Rich

Backs - Heath Shaw, Brodie Smith, Jack Newnes, Taylor Hunt, Jamie MacMillan, Nathan Brown (Shaun Edwards, Joel Hamling)

Mids - Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Matt Priddis, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Steven, Nathan Van Berlo, Ben Newton, Patrick Cripps (Jed Anderson, Nathan Freeman, Trent Dumont)

Rucks - Todd Goldstein, Nic Naitanui (Sam Durdin)

Forwards - Robbie Gray, Dustin Martin, Dane Swan, Christian Salem, Mitch Clark, Jesse Hogan (Jack Steele, Nathan Krakouer)

Thoughts now?

 

[Sydney Kicker]

IN - Gray, Martin, Salem, Cripps
OUT - Ziebell, Mitchell, Cameron, Rich

Backs - Heath Shaw, Brodie Smith, Jack Newnes, Taylor Hunt, Jamie MacMillan, Nathan Brown (Shaun Edwards, Joel Hamling)

Mids - Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Matt Priddis, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Steven, Nathan Van Berlo, Ben Newton, Patrick Cripps (Jed Anderson, Nathan Freeman, Trent Dumont)

Rucks - Todd Goldstein, Nic Naitanui (Sam Durdin)

Forwards - Robbie Gray, Dustin Martin, Dane Swan, Christian Salem, Mitch Clark, Jesse Hogan (Jack Steele, Nathan Krakouer)

Thoughts now?

Good team - If I was to make one suggestion... Being a North fan what about Swallow for Steven - you could find the cash by downgrading Gray to a cheaper forward premo. Gray is an absolute gun but is also overpriced and perhaps would be a better upgrade target. Would hopefully leave you with one more keeper.

 

[Deddy]

Good team - If I was to make one suggestion... Being a North fan what about Swallow for Steven - you could find the cash by downgrading Gray to a cheaper forward premo. Gray is an absolute gun but is also overpriced and perhaps would be a better upgrade target. Would hopefully leave you with one more keeper.

I know Swallow is a good choice, but is a very common option and is more of a consistent 100 a week player. I believe Steven has a higher scoring potential to average about 110 and have a few 120+'s.

Also believe Gray is going to be a super premium this season, and is worth the extra $

 

[Hungrywog]

Hey guys, just wondering what are your thoughts of my team?

 

[Danog]

Any reason people are taking Rich out of their teams?

 

[Sydney Kicker]

I know Swallow is a good choice, but is a very common option and is more of a consistent 100 a week player. I believe Steven has a higher scoring potential to average about 110 and have a few 120+'s.

Also believe Gray is going to be a super premium this season, and is worth the extra $

I've had both Steven and Swallow in my team at various stages. I keep worrying about Steven getting the tag and while he is fantastic value I think the chance of him becoming a keeper are pretty low - maybe he'll average 100. Agree though he's probably the best choice in his price range and if he does score back at 110 ave you'll be on a winner.

I'm hoping Swallow will average 108-110 and become a keeper M8.

History says the odds of Gray making last years average at the end of the year are low and Port have a hard start to the year. Little doubt he'll be a top 6 forward but I'm expecting (hoping) an early price drop. Again you'll be laughing if he cracks out a few 120+ scores in the first few rounds which I concede is very possible.

 

[CJApples87]

Just completed my first draft for any type of game this season and considering I was in 8th of 8 players in the order, I think I've done pretty well.



It's a team full of potential with the odd veteran who should keep the pace up.

 

[Stickers32]

Any reason people are taking Rich out of their teams?

he's a mid price midfielder i'm guessing... personally i've never touched him.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Hey guys, just wondering what are your thoughts of my team?
View attachment 116368

I'd avoid the Hawks ruckmen - I expect rotation and Big Boy's likely to spend plenty of time forward and not enough time rucking

 

[Hungrywog]

I'd avoid the Hawks ruckmen - I expect rotation and Big Boy's likely to spend plenty of time forward and not enough time rucking

Who should I replace Big Boy McEvoy with? Trying to fit Maric in, but I can't quite

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Who should I replace Big Boy McEvoy with? Trying to fit Maric in, but I can't quite

I wish I knew. I refuse to endorse any ruck this year. I'm probably going Nic Nat if he plays a NAB game and maybe a cheapo R2 with a view to upgrade once we get some idea of who are the best picks for the year. But it's a massive risky strategy I admit!

 

[Danog]

he's a mid price midfielder i'm guessing... personally i've never touched him.

He'll average 90 and he's priced at 65. Seems like a bargain to me.

 

[VictorianBitter]

I really need to move c.pearce out but am stuck atm. any ideas on this and my team?

K.simpson, Smith, Hibberd, Newnes, C.Pearce, Edwards, (Hamling, Saad)

Ablett, Fyfe, Sloane, Kennedy, Griffen, Anderson, Heeney, Boekhordt ( Vanfenberg, Krakouer, Dumont)

NicNat, Bellchambers (Cox)

Deledio, D.martin, Bennell, Swan, M. Clark, Hogan ( T. Lamb, Lambert)

 

[hoddo]

Who should I replace Big Boy McEvoy with? Trying to fit Maric in, but I can't quite

In that price range Minson would be your best choice

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

IN - Gray, Martin, Salem, Cripps
OUT - Ziebell, Mitchell, Cameron, Rich

Backs - Heath Shaw, Brodie Smith, Jack Newnes, Taylor Hunt, Jamie MacMillan, Nathan Brown (Shaun Edwards, Joel Hamling)

Mids - Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Matt Priddis, Patrick Dangerfield, Jack Steven, Nathan Van Berlo, Ben Newton, Patrick Cripps (Jed Anderson, Nathan Freeman, Trent Dumont)

Rucks - Todd Goldstein, Nic Naitanui (Sam Durdin)

Forwards - Robbie Gray, Dustin Martin, Dane Swan, Christian Salem, Mitch Clark, Jesse Hogan (Jack Steele, Nathan Krakouer)

Thoughts now?

I wouldn't pick Van Berlo, not likely to score very high at all IMO. There will be 120K rookies that score more than him.