-
LIVE: Sydney v Port Adelaide - 7:40 / 7:10 Fri
Squiggle tips Swans at 57% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
LIVE: Geelong v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Cats at 54% chance -- What's your tip? -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Prelim Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round SF Winner: And_ROOS
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
SC Trading Thread (Part II)
- Thread starter Cats_29
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Most common trade this week... Tippett
I myself am considering it, but my version is:
Kennelly -> Silvagni
Tippett -> Brown
Trouble is, with Shaw now on my bench (injured) I would have to play Silvagni on field.
The rush with Tippett is we all want to jump off him before the price changes.
Most common trade this week... Tippett
I myself am considering it, but my version is:
Kennelly -> Silvagni
Tippett -> Brown
Trouble is, with Shaw now on my bench (injured) I would have to play Silvagni on field.
The rush with Tippett is we all want to jump off him before the price changes.
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
I want to get both these players in this week too, but haven't decided what to do yet.
a) Harvey & Hall ---> Peterson & Brown (end up with about $240,000 in the bank, and the option to trade Harvey back in when his price plummets and Peterson's rises, and some cash left over to help upgrade a midfielder in a couple of weeks to someone like Judd). I think it's OK cash wise but uses up a few trades.
b) Do nothing and keep 20 trades.
Leaning towards the second option.
I like this trade munk3ymark. I'm really worried that Barry couldn't score more than 46 points in a thrashing of Richmond. You get a gun (Brown) and a great cash cow (Peterson).
I want to get both these players in this week too, but haven't decided what to do yet.
a) Harvey & Hall ---> Peterson & Brown (end up with about $240,000 in the bank, and the option to trade Harvey back in when his price plummets and Peterson's rises, and some cash left over to help upgrade a midfielder in a couple of weeks to someone like Judd). I think it's OK cash wise but uses up a few trades.
b) Do nothing and keep 20 trades.
Leaning towards the second option.
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Thanks '89. Option a - you had me until you started talking about trading Boomer back in. A cardinal sin in my book. But that much cash will come in handy in any number of other areas down the track.
My only concern with Peterson is whether he'll keep his spot, but the Hawks do keep hurting themselves, so he's surely got a few more weeks up his sleeve...
Thanks '89. Option a - you had me until you started talking about trading Boomer back in. A cardinal sin in my book. But that much cash will come in handy in any number of other areas down the track.
My only concern with Peterson is whether he'll keep his spot, but the Hawks do keep hurting themselves, so he's surely got a few more weeks up his sleeve...
Bombersfan81
Debutant
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
Just bumping this as I got no replies about 5 pages ago.......
I'm in almost the same boat, have Clark & Hille spudding it up in my rucks, after having sandi & seaby in there the day b4 lockout....thumbsd: FAIL on coaches part) & am now VERY iffy on Clark, I'm falling behind the pack
Thinking of doing a double trade, getting rid of Clark & hall (two of my 3 50ppg on field players) for either of Seaby or kruezer in the ruck, & Baz for Brown in the fwds.
The main thing thats making me lean towards seaby atm is that big bank would be rather useful come about round 5 round 6 to turn a mid rookie or midpricer into C Judd.....
- seaby leaves me with 164600 in the kitty & 248ppg between him & brown,
- kruze leaves me with just 31600 but a boost of 255ppg on current averages
Thoughts?
Just bumping this as I got no replies about 5 pages ago.......
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
I like Hille>Seaby, but it's a bit too sideways considering you don't already have Sandi.
Try to free up some cash in other areas of your ground to go Clark>Sandi.
I like Hille>Seaby, but it's a bit too sideways considering you don't already have Sandi.
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
Trading either Hall or Tippett to ROK, but can't decide who. Tippett would obviously give me more money for upgrades. Could I have some thoughts? Thanks
If you have enough money to get Brown as well, i'd probably go Clark --> Kruezer. Kruezer looks like potentialy becoming a premium ruck and premium rucks seem few and far between this season.
Trading either Hall or Tippett to ROK, but can't decide who. Tippett would obviously give me more money for upgrades. Could I have some thoughts? Thanks
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
But the 100k that comes with Tippet is handy, no doubt.
Hmm at this stage i'd say Hall, considering Tippett kicked 5 against Melbourne in the pre season, but Barry kicked a bag against the hawks too.
But the 100k that comes with Tippet is handy, no doubt.
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
Wrote this in the 'Heath Shaw thread' but didn't get any love and I'm running out of time.
Can't help but think H.Shaw to Malceski is worth it.
H.Shaw - 503,100 (Assumed average 100-110)
Malceski - 273,500 (Assumed average 90-100)
That's an extra $229'600 in the kitty. In 1 to 2 weeks time that's Hunt/Ladson to Enright/Duffield.
Lost a keeper but gained 2 keepers and don't have to gamble with Maguire scoring poorly or H.Shaw missing more then 1 match.
Thoughts.
Wrote this in the 'Heath Shaw thread' but didn't get any love and I'm running out of time.
Can't help but think H.Shaw to Malceski is worth it.
H.Shaw - 503,100 (Assumed average 100-110)
Malceski - 273,500 (Assumed average 90-100)
That's an extra $229'600 in the kitty. In 1 to 2 weeks time that's Hunt/Ladson to Enright/Duffield.
Lost a keeper but gained 2 keepers and don't have to gamble with Maguire scoring poorly or H.Shaw missing more then 1 match.
Thoughts.
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
I reckon trades will make more points for you but how much more is what you have to weigh up against making 2 trades.
Not sure about Duffield, how has he scored playing midfield this season.
I reckon trades will make more points for you but how much more is what you have to weigh up against making 2 trades.
Not sure about Duffield, how has he scored playing midfield this season.
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Need some trade advice.
Rucks: Mitch Clark,Warnock,McEvoy,Trengove
Getting nothing from 2nd ruck & Mitch Clark but he should improve.
trade
Seaby IN for McEvoy OUT
only way I can do this is trade Dustin Martin out for Michael Barlow.
Don't want to lose Martin but gaining anyway by bring Barlow in.
Advice Appreciated.
Need some trade advice.
Rucks: Mitch Clark,Warnock,McEvoy,Trengove
Getting nothing from 2nd ruck & Mitch Clark but he should improve.
trade
Seaby IN for McEvoy OUT
only way I can do this is trade Dustin Martin out for Michael Barlow.
Don't want to lose Martin but gaining anyway by bring Barlow in.
Advice Appreciated.
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Robbie Tarrant and Relton Roberts out for Peterson and Duncan...
No more trades needed for a while now! Good that Rockliff is playing this week!
Robbie Tarrant and Relton Roberts out for Peterson and Duncan...
No more trades needed for a while now! Good that Rockliff is playing this week!
Re: Official SC 2010 Trading Thread
I'm in the same boat as bomber.. I would love to go Clark to Sandi but i just don't have the cash for it at the moment so i'm looking at Clark-Kruez or Clark-Seaby (my head hurts from trying to decide which one!).
Here's another thought, though I'm not really sure if i like it..
Trengove-Bastianc
Clark-Sandi
But then I still have Gray on the bench and no J.Brown which is the second trade i'll do if i go for Clark-Kruez or Clark-Seaby...
Tell me that trade is crazy right?!
I'm in the same boat as bomber.. I would love to go Clark to Sandi but i just don't have the cash for it at the moment so i'm looking at Clark-Kruez or Clark-Seaby (my head hurts from trying to decide which one!
).Here's another thought, though I'm not really sure if i like it..
Trengove-Bastianc
Clark-Sandi
But then I still have Gray on the bench and no J.Brown which is the second trade i'll do if i go for Clark-Kruez or Clark-Seaby...
Tell me that trade is crazy right?!
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
in a quandry over
hille > Seaby( happy with this other than the fact I need to do it)
Bradshaw/tippett > brown
was all set to to do bradshaw and keep tippett because he is a mpp and younger but reading about his knee issues worries me now.
any advice
in a quandry over
hille > Seaby( happy with this other than the fact I need to do it)
Bradshaw/tippett > brown
was all set to to do bradshaw and keep tippett because he is a mpp and younger but reading about his knee issues worries me now.
any advice
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Hi, need advice on my trades. Ideally would love to do the following, would appreciate a yay/nay for each.
Kennelly -> Malceski
Rockliff -> Carl Peterson
Hille -> Seaby
Jolly -> Kruezer
Don't want to use too many trades this early, but will definitely use one.
I am thinking Jolly -> Kruezer is a definite ... Jolly is killing me.
Whether Seaby can provide long term value is an unknown ?
Hi, need advice on my trades. Ideally would love to do the following, would appreciate a yay/nay for each.
Kennelly -> Malceski
Rockliff -> Carl Peterson
Hille -> Seaby
Jolly -> Kruezer
Don't want to use too many trades this early, but will definitely use one.
I am thinking Jolly -> Kruezer is a definite ... Jolly is killing me.
Whether Seaby can provide long term value is an unknown ?
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Hold onto Rockliff is in and named on a wing, going by preseason form he should do alright and keep his place.
Hold onto Rockliff is in and named on a wing, going by preseason form he should do alright and keep his place.
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Rockliff > Peterson ; Rockliff was named this week
How about you make your two trades..
Jolly>Sandi
Hille>Seaby
Then you will have the best ruck combo in the game, as Kreuzer won't keep it up and Clark won't bounce back.
Kenelly > Malceski is a waste
Rockliff > Peterson ; Rockliff was named this week
How about you make your two trades..
Jolly>Sandi
Hille>Seaby
Then you will have the best ruck combo in the game, as Kreuzer won't keep it up and Clark won't bounce back.
- Jul 15, 2009
- 8,383
- 9,309
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
08yearofthetiger
Senior List
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
I really need some help .
This is my team :
Backs: Goddard Enright Hodge Hurn H.Shaw Malceski Kennely
Em Waters Nason
Midfield: Selwood Pendlebury Mitchell Barlow Martin Connors
Em Trengove Shuey
Rucks: Clark Nicnat
Em Warnock Lobbe
Forwards: Riewolt Okeefe Gia Gray Hall Mayne Hitchcock
Em Gumbleton Roberts
I have several under performing premiums. My backline is just about set although suspension to Hurn and injury to Shaw has me in a little trouble this week. my first question is, should sivagni/maguire be traded in to free up some cash for either Kennely?
Happy with my midfield.
Rucks Nicnat is travelling okay with Clark struggling but should soon bounce back.
FORWARDS have made some poor premium choices and had some bad luck with Gray. Should i trade out say Hall and Gray for Brown and Ballynte ? or something of the like. Gia is also a poor pick but looks as though he ll be staying. WILL GRAY BE BACK NEXT WEEK?
Option 1. Kennely > maguire /silvagni then Hall > J.Brown
Option 2. Hall > Ballynte then Gray > Brown
PLEASE HELP thanks
I really need some help .
This is my team :
Backs: Goddard Enright Hodge Hurn H.Shaw Malceski Kennely
Em Waters Nason
Midfield: Selwood Pendlebury Mitchell Barlow Martin Connors
Em Trengove Shuey
Rucks: Clark Nicnat
Em Warnock Lobbe
Forwards: Riewolt Okeefe Gia Gray Hall Mayne Hitchcock
Em Gumbleton Roberts
I have several under performing premiums. My backline is just about set although suspension to Hurn and injury to Shaw has me in a little trouble this week. my first question is, should sivagni/maguire be traded in to free up some cash for either Kennely?
Happy with my midfield.
Rucks Nicnat is travelling okay with Clark struggling but should soon bounce back.
FORWARDS have made some poor premium choices and had some bad luck with Gray. Should i trade out say Hall and Gray for Brown and Ballynte ? or something of the like. Gia is also a poor pick but looks as though he ll be staying. WILL GRAY BE BACK NEXT WEEK?
Option 1. Kennely > maguire /silvagni then Hall > J.Brown
Option 2. Hall > Ballynte then Gray > Brown
PLEASE HELP thanks
Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010
Thanks for the advice (to both of you). Good that Rockliff is named on the wing and you are right, Kennelly is a side-ways trade.
Thanks for the advice (to both of you). Good that Rockliff is named on the wing and you are right, Kennelly is a side-ways trade.
- Status
