Votes St Kilda Best and Fairest Round 5 v Port Adelaide

[Kildonan]

15 points to distribute with a maximum of 5 points to any one player.

If you are disappointed with the match why not leave the voting until tomorrow when you've had some time to think about it more rationally.

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

5 A Schneider
4 C Jones
3 S Gilbert
2 L Montagna
1 S Baker

 

[Rough_Edges]

5 - Gilbert
4 - Schneider
3 - Montagna
2 - Baker
1 - Fisher

 

[stkildathunda]

5. Gilbert
5. Montagna
3. Jones
2. Schneiderman

 

[goodie23]

4 - Schneider
4 - Gilbert
4 - Montagna
2 - Baker
1 - Milne (just for the sheer arseness of that goal)

 

[samwise]

5. Gilbert
4. Montagna
2. Schneider
2. Baker
2. Jones

 

[StFly]

4. Schneider
4. Gilbert
2. Montagna
2. Baker
2. Jones
1. Gwilt

 

[karmafree]

5. Gilbert
4. Montagna
3.Schneider
2.Jones
1.Fisher

 

[Kildonan]

5 L Montagna
4 S Gilbert
3 C Jones
2 S Baker
1 A Schneider

 

[Budgie63]

5. Montagna
4. Jones
3. Schneider
3. Gilbert

 

[Plugger35]

Normally it's difficult trying to squeeze everyone into the votes but this week I'm struggling to think of enough players that deserve them.

5.Gilbert
4.Schneider
3.Montagna
2.Jones
1.Blake

 

[SaintsManMat]

5 - gilbert (clearly our best)
4 - montagna (tried all game)
3 - schneider
2 - baker
1 - clint jones

 

[LordJimmy]

3 - Gilbert
3 - Schneider
3 - Montagna
3 - Baker
3 - Fisher

Minus points to all others involved.

 

[CHBench]

5. Gilbert
4. Montagna
3. Schneider
2. Jones
1. Baker

 

[saint jack]

5. Gilbert
4. Gwilt
3 Jones
3 Dal Santo

Gwilt must be most under-rated player. Reads play well and is always doing the right thing.

 

[Zagg]

5 - Gilbert
4 - Schneider
3 - Fisher
2 - Montagna
1 - Gwilt

 

[SaintsSeptember]

4 - Gilbert
4 -Schnieder
3 - Montagna
1 - Jones
1 - Hayes
1 -Baker
1 - gwilt

 

[Half Back Pocket]

3- Gilbert
3 -Schnieder
1 - Montagna
1 - Hayes
1 -Baker

pretty average, really.

 

[Look2Me4Guidance]

5 - Gilbert

4 - Gwilt

3 - Schneider

2 - Jones

1 - Fisher

 

[Defacto]

5 gilbert
4 gwilt
3 baker
3 clarke

 

[SammyFish25]

5 - Gilbert
4 - Schneider
3 - Gwilt
1 - Fisher
1 - Jones
1 - Baker

 

[goodie23]

Spoiler

Gilbert 88
Schneider 59
Montagna 54
Jones 32
Baker 22
Gwilt 18
Big Fish 11
Clarke 3
Dal Santo 3
Hayes 2
Milne 1
Blake 1

 

[Hugh Jars]

Slow off the mark this week.

5. Gilbo
4. Joey
3. Schneiderman
2. Bakes
1. CJ

 

[goodie23]

Unless there are any more votes, final tally should stand at

Gilbert 93
Schneider 62
Montagna 58
Jones 33
Baker 24
Gwilt 18
Big Fish 11
Clarke 3
Dal Santo 3
Hayes 2
Milne 1
Blake 1

 

[John Bonney]

votes are superflous,think who actually won the game for Saints