-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Steven May - 1 week
- Thread starter Demonic Ascent
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Aug 17, 2012
- 13,978
- 20,910
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Wonder if Goody Goodwin will provide a solid character reference? For all the time that he's known him to be a good bloke?
- Apr 12, 2014
- 32,146
- 56,986
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
On one hand I think May was silly for going for it, on the other hand I think the tribunals reasoning is ridiculous. I mean after they fined Francis last year for literally the perfect bump on O'Meara who knows WTF they will come out with
So if another player without history did the exact same thing no penalty?
I thought it was almost identical to Norths Thompson bump on ???. Player handballed, copped a slightly late shirt front but not too brutal and he went down wirh the air knocked out of him.
It was a tad uncalled for being a preseason game and no doubt he was hurt / winded.
Taller player bumped a shorter player.
A fine for both should be the very maximum penaltt just to let them know it was uncalled for rough conduct.
Last edited:
- Dec 11, 2010
- 10,648
- 12,315
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Two punching incidents in this game as well that were ignored. Vandenberg on Neale & Oliver on Lyons.
- Feb 21, 2006
- 21,203
- 20,253
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Turtles NYJets Celtics Spurs Fake Sports
- Thread starter
- #56
They weren't ignored they were fined
- Aug 17, 2012
- 13,978
- 20,910
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Clear as day that Melbourne are the umpire's pets for 2019. Has to fit the narrative after all the hype
- Aug 17, 2012
- 13,978
- 20,910
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Fined is sufficient considering the AFL said they want to stamp it out of the game?
Nelso
Brownlow Medallist
This appeal is going to end in tears for May
He choose to bump and will now pay the price.
Vandenberg can count himself lucky he did not get rubbed out for a game as well. Gutless coward's punch to the stomach.
He choose to bump and will now pay the price.
Vandenberg can count himself lucky he did not get rubbed out for a game as well. Gutless coward's punch to the stomach.
- Aug 17, 2012
- 13,978
- 20,910
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Oliver is a football enigma.
In many cases he shows serious commitment at winning the hard ball. Puts his body on the line for all the right reasons and thumbs up all round.
And then on other occasions such as the Schofield non hit Oliver falls over in a weak act or trys to draw a free that isnt there.
Bizarre stuff.
I'd spend more of my time worrying about why your team keeps recruiting has-beens to prob you up but not be good enough to challenge.
This is coming from someone who is a big fan of Geelong. I just don't get how Like Dalhaus and Gary Rohan alongside GAJ help you get closer to a flag?
- Dec 11, 2010
- 10,648
- 12,315
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
If you've seen Berry in action soft is the last thing you'd call him. Some Melbourne fans are getting way too unhinged over this whole thing.
So if the appeal fails does May receive two weeks for challenging?
- Mar 28, 2018
- 10,491
- 8,454
- AFL Club
- GWS
Big difference is Shuey puts his head on the line with ball in hand.
Oliver gets blown over by a gust wind and minimal contact whilst trying to get players rubbed out.
One action takes some courage the other action lacks courage.
Considering how much bigger, taller and stronger Oliver is its surprising he takes the soft option.
Bluelegs
Digging into the why
Nah they got rid of that.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,506
- 28,840
- AFL Club
- West Coast
It didn’t seem like medium impact. It seemed borderline medium though.
It's really not the hardest rule to understand. If you elect to bump someone and you're not going for the ball or they've already disposed of it, you're likely going to get a week off. If you watch the replay, he clearly elects to push off his left foot after the ball was disposed of to get into Berry's path and bump him. It wasn't necessary and could have been avoided. If he goes to tribunal and gets off, I don't think anyone's going to be surprised given Berry wasn't concussed and it wasn't the most forceful bump. But surprised so many people are struggling to get their heads around it.
Sylvia Saint
Cancelled
Not the hardest rule to understand yet you don't understand it. All Michael Christian goes by are three categories, impact, contact and intent. Clearly Melbourne will be hoping it gets downgraded to low impact and it might be. Although I think it's borderline so don't care if the appeal fails.
I'll might accept it's a week when I see clear proof beyond a reasonable doubt that he hit him on the chin.
As many times as I've seen the footage I can only see shoulder to upper sternum. Yeah it's close to the chin but nothing conclusive. My guess is any other player they'd go with the benefit of the doubt but they want to get May, even though he did the only noteworthy thing ever in a Q clash.
Establish that it was to the chin and then I'll think about whether the force of a guy standing his ground then bracing for contact is worth medium impact. I don't think it is but it's a fair argument. May will learn he has to avoid contact or go even lower and slower, Berry might learn that if you're drawing an opponent for a handball it's probably not a bad idea to at least then work out where they are after the handball.
As many times as I've seen the footage I can only see shoulder to upper sternum. Yeah it's close to the chin but nothing conclusive. My guess is any other player they'd go with the benefit of the doubt but they want to get May, even though he did the only noteworthy thing ever in a Q clash.
Establish that it was to the chin and then I'll think about whether the force of a guy standing his ground then bracing for contact is worth medium impact. I don't think it is but it's a fair argument. May will learn he has to avoid contact or go even lower and slower, Berry might learn that if you're drawing an opponent for a handball it's probably not a bad idea to at least then work out where they are after the handball.
- Apr 12, 2014
- 32,146
- 56,986
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Were you this critical of Darling exaggerating contact?
- Status
