Cheers mate, that's what i thought. I think il steer clear cuz i just dont think he will get too many games compared with walker (whom i have atm) as Adelaide really need fwd targets and Hogan doesnt really fill any void.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The official "X v Y" thread
- Thread starter Ben the Gooner
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Cheers mate, that's what i thought. I think il steer clear cuz i just dont think he will get too many games compared with walker (whom i have atm) as Adelaide really need fwd targets and Hogan doesnt really fill any void.
Doug Barwick
Draftee
I would go with Selwood and Cross just not sure about Pendles just yet wait and see if he can shake the tag. Cross is a safe option.
I am having trouble choosing between K.Simpson and C.Knights??
marshie_blues
Debutant
- Feb 18, 2009
- 114
- 0
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Storm, Victory
any thoughts on this one guys?
kreuze control
Team Captain
i think selwood and gibbs are both must-haves this year.
imo dont even worry about the pendlebury-cross decision and choose both gibbs and selwood.
broughton vs petrenko vs dawson? which 2 should i have as my 2 emergency defenders?
out of the first two. but i'd also consider Suban. Dawson just doesn't score at all (his pre-season SC avg is 30.3).
i'd leaning towards Broughton. as he should play more games.
Adcock & Lucas
verses
Drummond & Stevie J
Doing my head in!!
verses
Drummond & Stevie J
Doing my head in!!
kreuze control
Team Captain
i'd go with ablett and mackie only because ablett is likely to average about 20 more than bartel and when you make him captain that becomes 40.
mitch brown vs scott gumbleton vs taylor walker? which 2 should i have as my emergency forwards. at the moment i've got brown and walker as i'm a bit put off by gumby's injuries.
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
mitch brown vs scott gumbleton vs taylor walker? which 2 should i have as my emergency forwards. at the moment i've got brown and walker as i'm a bit put off by gumby's injuries.[/quote said:
kreuze control
Team Captain
thanks mate. as for your one, i like harvey and beams a lot more. you know what you're going to get with harvey, ultra consistent proven performer with the added motivation of being captain for the first time whereas brown may struggle a bit this year. also think beams could easily have just as good a year as otten.
pavlich and hurn vs l.hodge and n.krakouer? atm i have hodge and n.krakeour.
first option for me. N Brown is better value than Boomer and A Otten will be one of the best sub 150k scorers this year.
if the stars align then the second option has the potential for big scores. the first is a bit safer and less bang for your buck. i'd look at the rest of my side and see how many risks i was taking. if you're playing it relatively safe elsewhere then go the second, else go the first.
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
option 1 for me mate, n.brown to have huge year, dont know why people think hell struggle and otten and be one of better rookies.
i have both of them starting at this point
kreuze control
Team Captain
Probably asked like 1,000,000 times re: back ups mids
Which two would u go with out of:
Ziebell, L Anthony, Beams, Robinson, other (please specify)
i have beams and robinson in my side.
anyoe got an opinion for pavlich and hurn vs l.hodge and n.krakeour?
eugene_tomas
Team Captain
id got pav (i think hodge will com down) and krak instead of hurn
drummond (mr injury hopefully hes over it) v chad cornes (let me down big time last year)
drummond (mr injury hopefully hes over it) v chad cornes (let me down big time last year)
Probably asked like 1,000,000 times re: back ups mids
Which two would u go with out of:
Ziebell, L Anthony, Beams, Robinson, other (please specify)
Robinson looks like he could play Thursday night and looks a good cash cow prospect...
And Anthony has been tearing it up in the NAB cup. Although we all know Dean Laidley's approach to playing good SC players....
If you've got the cash, I'd go with Robinson and Ziebell...the kid's too good not to play...
Don't like either Fevola or Wells, but I'd have to go with option 1.
I just have a feeling that Fev will lift his consistency this season and should get you a good round 1 score (80,000+ at the G - the guy loves centre stage). And Goodes somehow seems to score 90+ with under 20 touches...
- Status
