The official "X v Y" thread

[marcmurphy3]

Bartel plus 90k in the bank or Ablett?, keeping in mind I dont really have anything I want to use the 90k on. Would probably stay in the bank if i got bartel

 

[sainta4life]

skipworth as 6th midfielder, hill as 7th backmen
or
otten/rich as 6th midfielder, dempsey 7th backmen?

 

[eugene_tomas]

skipworth as 6th midfielder, hill as 7th backmen
or
otten/rich as 6th midfielder, dempsey 7th backmen?

1st one dude

 

[mattys123]

Henstchel 214k vs Skipworth 219k

and;

Maric 387k vs Simmonds 393k

Thoughts?

 

[Baxter23]

Henstchel 214k vs Skipworth 219k

and;

Maric 387k vs Simmonds 393k

Thoughts?

Skipworth cos he'll play in the mid field and kick goals while resting the fwd.

Simmonds. He'll be better off after a good year last year and another pre season

Petterd or Sphanger?

 

[Big Hille]

Petterd

tuck or dane swan?

 

[Baxter23]

Petterd

tuck or dane swan?

Swan

 

[Stanton_Legend]

Franklin or J Brown?

 

[Hot Tiges]

Petterd

tuck or dane swan?

Trav Tuck looked good at the end of last year. Dane Swan is more DT I reckon.

Selwood VS Salopek?

 

[Baxter23]

Trav Tuck looked good at the end of last year. Dane Swan is more DT I reckon.

Selwood VS Salopek?

Selwood. Not being on the band wagon or anything but the kid is a freak.

 

[RWnBluey]

out of the first two. but i'd also consider Suban. Dawson just doesn't score at all (his pre-season SC avg is 30.3).

i'd leaning towards Broughton. as he should play more games.

Ok then, another... Broughton vs Suban?

Or perhaps it may be wise to put Hill as your last defender and have BOTH Broughton and Suban on your bench... Guaranteed emergencies... well almost.

 

[Big Hille]

i meant shane tuck from richmond.

thanks anyway.

 

[RevDog]

L Anthony vs. M Robinson

J Ziebell vs. J Smith

 

[Pendles!]

i think selwood and gibbs are both must-haves this year.

imo dont even worry about the pendlebury-cross decision and choose both gibbs and selwood.



broughton vs petrenko vs dawson? which 2 should i have as my 2 emergency defenders?

Cheers mate.
um probabley petrenko and dawson, if Broughton isnt named rd 1. If he is i would go broughton and petrenko.

 

[Hot Tiges]

L Anthony vs. M Robinson

J Ziebell vs. J Smith

Anthony I think and Ziebell


What's the news on Andy Otten? Apparently avg of 85 during pre-season? Another option to Rich maybe?

 

[Allfooty]

Anthony I think and Ziebell


What's the news on Andy Otten? Apparently avg of 85 during pre-season? Another option to Rich maybe?

yeah is a terrific player and had been ultra impressive although his spot in the side has not yet been confirmed and may have to fight it out with petrenko and dangerfield and those types.

Jack Riewoldt or ryan gamble

sam gilbert or nick malcheski

 

[Pendles!]

Anthony I think and Ziebell


What's the news on Andy Otten? Apparently avg of 85 during pre-season? Another option to Rich maybe?

Yeah mate, looks the goods. but the question is, where will he play in their side? he might not get a game infront of symes and the likes. but is said to be infront of dangerman. could be a good pickup, if he plays.

Adock vs Malceski.

 

[SJ]

We will know if Otten is named or not for Round 1, unlike Anthony, Ziebell, Suban, Broughton, Ballantyne etc.

 

[gazzasuperstar29]

Alwyn Davey and Foley/Kerr
or
Nathan Krakouer and Judd

What peoples thoughts?
Foley or Kerr to fit in Judd?

 

[TheVelourFog]

Alwyn Davey and Foley/Kerr
or
Nathan Krakouer and Judd

What peoples thoughts?
Foley or Kerr to fit in Judd?

You would have to go Krakouer and Judd. I just don't think Davey will score as highly as Kraks and I also think Port are going to improve massively on last year and he should have a spot on half back sewn up. Plus I really don't like Kerr, he needs help and probably won't get much this year.

Goodwin or Deledio?

 

[gazzasuperstar29]

Id go Deledio cos he has more improvement in him than Goodwin. Deledio will be a star this year
Judd and Malceski
or Kerr and Mackie

 

[marshie_blues]

Id go Deledio cos he has more improvement in him than Goodwin. Deledio will be a star this year
Judd and Malceski
or Kerr and Mackie

judd and malceski for sure
kerr i worry bout, hes gonna get tagged every week and we all know how easily he can snap
plus malceski will improve on last year after gettin over the knee

 

[Judd_Magic]

We will know if Otten is named or not for Round 1, unlike Anthony, Ziebell, Suban, Broughton, Ballantyne etc.

Ballantyne is at least 6 weeks away due to his broken hand. Will be a good downgrade option though after he has played two games.

 

[SJ]

Ballantyne is at least 6 weeks away due to his broken hand. Will be a good downgrade option though after he has played two games.

Ah cheers.

 

[Newton Blues]

Houlihan/T.Tuck
Dalsanto/T. walker starting

I will have t walker on me reserves anyway... this will jsut meen i bring in mith brown to my reserves as well with ziebel... i am alittle worried with have walker and tuck because i have ottens rich starting in my widfield and hill in my backline who would use guys go?