Cursedsword02
THE BEAST
- Mar 14, 2021
- 666
- 1,929
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Any chance?
Free Agency Todd Goldstein [Joins Essendon as UFA]
- Thread starter Cursedsword02
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Any chance?
- May 28, 2013
- 25,996
- 28,289
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Seattle Seahawks
Surly if he left he would want some success?
The only thing that'd stop Goldy is the heat death of the universe at this rate. Guy just keeps chugging.
Wtf would bombers want Golstein for? Draper is about to enter his prime and they should keep pumping games into Nick Bryan.
Never change Brad
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Are Scott and Dodoro seriously that desperate for a trade win that they're offering 35 year old Goldy a two year deal?
Even though they already have Draper and Bryan?
If it is true, its hard to begrudge Goldy doing what's best for himself. Even if it means a 300+ game club stalwart finishes his career in rival colours.
I just don't understand how TG helps Essendon start contending again.
Even though they already have Draper and Bryan?
If it is true, its hard to begrudge Goldy doing what's best for himself. Even if it means a 300+ game club stalwart finishes his career in rival colours.
I just don't understand how TG helps Essendon start contending again.
- Apr 23, 2016
- 35,317
- 50,931
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Depends what Goldy has been sold hasn't it?
I wouldn't rely on Draper playing every game, and Bryan playing a full season at AFL level would be a big ask for a young ruckman. If Goldstein is happy to play a supporting role playing a mix of AFL and VFL as needed, with involvement in coaching those two then I think he adds value.
Draper & Bryan are both young and seemingly talented, so learning from a player who is IMO inside the best half dozen (and most consistent) ruckmen of the last 20 years is a good thing for them. Draper especially as he struggles with the basics of the role which is where Goldstein delivered every single week.
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
If its a playing-coaching role, I can understand the appeal.
Even though he's past his prime, he's still the best ruck we've got by some margin. To say nothing about his insane durability.
We just haven't had much luck getting him to upskill his understudies at North.
- Apr 23, 2016
- 35,317
- 50,931
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Not sure the understudies have been great though, Pruess has played under both Goldstein and Gawn and is an absolute physical unit but barely gets on the park.
Similar story for Xerri, Comben and CCJ hasn't it been? Mostly unavailable due to injury but also simply not great players.
Hard when you've had a high level, durable ruckman holding down the role for a decade I guess.
candyapple
All Australian
- May 8, 2023
- 952
- 757
- AFL Club
- Tasmania
- Banned
- #10
North getting pick 4 for him?
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,031
- 65,103
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #12
Actually seems a sensible move for Essendon.
Draper is good and Bryan is promising, but the former has had injury issues, and the latter is very young.
Won’t be on huge money and won’t cost anything via trade, and definitely fills a need.
Draper is good and Bryan is promising, but the former has had injury issues, and the latter is very young.
Won’t be on huge money and won’t cost anything via trade, and definitely fills a need.
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Yeah, we've underinvested in rucks bigtime and we're about to pay the consequences of that.
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
If the idea is that he's a playing coach, it makes sense.
But even with his remarkable longevity, I struggle to see him running out games when he's 38 at the end of the second year.
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,031
- 65,103
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #15
Even if just as a player it makes sense.
Essendon aren’t as far back in the rebuild as North are. A player of his age can add considerable value.
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
When was the last time someone 35+ got a two year contract?
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,031
- 65,103
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #18
Sure they have. That doesn't mean it has been a success, however.
Not sure why that's at all relevant. Only on BF is it more important to be young than it is to be good, and Goldstein is still good.
When was the last time a 35 year old clearly still capable of contributing at the level?
- Aug 6, 2021
- 10,707
- 30,978
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
On whether Goldy is still good: I never said he wasn't, in fact I thought my second post made that clear?
On the other stuff: Drawing that strawman will lead you to conclude that the Pies should've offered Pendles more than one year.
I'm not sure what this means.
Goldie's the same age as Pendles and Hawkins.
They have both contributed quite a lot this year.
- Sep 26, 2004
- 48,031
- 65,103
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #20
And I never said you did. That was clear.
Strawman arguments are pretty easy to pick apart. The difference between Goldstein and Pendlebury could not be more clear.
Are either of them being seriously courted by other clubs?
Doesn’t matter what he’s offered, it won’t be much salary and cost nothing in terms of picks - if he wants to continue playing, he’s more than able to as a depth ruckman.
I’d prefer him in the wings in finals if I was a coach at a contending club than any of Lycett/Hayes/Visentini, Fort, Ladhams, Preuss, whatever Melbourne have once Grundy leaves (no doubt some 20 year old rake).
Only club that wouldn’t benefit that are contending are the Pies who have Frampton as a 3rd choice which is competitive enough.
Essendon could get 6-8 games out of him when Draper gets hurts, only his below average salary that would be solid enough.
He’s also better than the current Eagles back-ups, Conway @ Geelong, Meek, and with Sweet out the door would be handy at the Dogs if English goes down.
I’d prefer him in the wings in finals if I was a coach at a contending club than any of Lycett/Hayes/Visentini, Fort, Ladhams, Preuss, whatever Melbourne have once Grundy leaves (no doubt some 20 year old rake).
Only club that wouldn’t benefit that are contending are the Pies who have Frampton as a 3rd choice which is competitive enough.
Essendon could get 6-8 games out of him when Draper gets hurts, only his below average salary that would be solid enough.
He’s also better than the current Eagles back-ups, Conway @ Geelong, Meek, and with Sweet out the door would be handy at the Dogs if English goes down.
- Moderator
- #23
More space in the salary cap than the soft cap
rye
⠀
- Apr 24, 2022
- 3,749
- 10,267
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
dont understand why north would be wanting to move him on
xerri is injury prone and still unclear whether he makes it. norths ruck depth after him is ccj if goldstein leaves and the less that is said about him the better.
xerri is injury prone and still unclear whether he makes it. norths ruck depth after him is ccj if goldstein leaves and the less that is said about him the better.
- Aug 15, 2011
- 24,928
- 9,014
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide
Similar threads
