Top 10 youngsters (under 20)

[Mocca]

Originally posted by Rohan_
The same survey that predicted a landslide Labor win in the last election?

No, a completely different survey, with different samples, questions, responses, markets, purposes, outcomes and conclusions.

 

[Hawkforce]

Originally posted by Lockyer24


Where was your loyalty with Croady?

No wonder Chick had his bags packed a longggg time ago.

Is this in any way relevant to the Davis situation or were you just lashing out in a blind temper?

 

[Rohan_]

Originally posted by Mocca
No, a completely different survey, with different samples, questions, responses, markets, purposes, outcomes and conclusions.

But with the same accuracy. Kim Beazley was meant to be the PM according to Roy Morgon.

 

[Mocca]

Yours, Dave.

 

[King Crow]

Originally posted by Lockyer24


you're as clueless as sabre!

What a load of crap, McPharlin is twice the player Fraser is, and will always be that.

 

[Dave]

Originally posted by Rohan_
But with the same accuracy.

Gotta love that from the man who's predictions have been less accurate than the weather bureau's....

Tell us again about Black....

 

[windyhill]

And Anelka, tell us about Anelka winning the title for Liverpool last year.

 

[Mocca]

Great teamwork, old son.

*Gives Dave a high five*

 

[Dave]

*takes bow*

A pleasure sir.

now to scarper off home...bye all.

 

[Falchoon]

Originally posted by Rohan_


You don't really understand it because you follow "just another club". It's not really a desperate need, its our culture to be depised and hated. Collingwood V the rest of the world.

When we are hated it means we worry others. A sign that we are coming back.

You're hated only because your supporters are the biggest knobs.

Keep proving it.

 

[LozNger_6]

This is my top 40:
Riewoldt (SK)
Kerr (WC)
Judd (WC)
Fraser (CO)
Corey (G)
Ries (H)
Hodge (H)
Koschitzke (SK)
Cloke (CO)
Kelly (G)
Giansiracusa (WB)
Lonie (CO)
Guerra (P)
Murphy (WB)
Coughlan (R)
Brown (H)
Didak (CO)
S. Burgoyne (P)
Petrie (K)
Johnson (G)
Mcgough (CO)
Zantuck (R)
Mcmahon (WB)
Houlihan (CA)
Cupido (B)
Mcphee (F)
Stevens (S)
Dal Santo (SK)
Rodan (R)
Sporn (CA)
K. Cornes (P)
Beetham (SK)
Humm (WC)
D. Motlop (K)
Mitchell (H)
Armstrong (M)
Bartel (G)
Pettifer (R)
Brown (F)
Ablett Jr (G)



Id have to agree with this one more than the first one. At least one has a Geelong player in it. How could you ignore one of the youngest teams in the country with loads of talent, and not even put an enright, a corey, a bartel/kelly/johnson???

 

[Kenny_01]

Originally posted by King Crow


What a load of crap, McPharlin is twice the player Fraser is, and will always be that.

Thankyou

 

[sabre_ac]

Originally posted by Lockyer24


you're as clueless as sabre!

Firstly that wasnt my post.
Secondly Fraser might have all ability in the world but the fact remains he is slow and he lacks heart.
In other words he is as soft as butter.
The sad part about this is that once your soft its not like you can bulk up or better your skills, the truth is once soft your always soft.
Thirdly McPharlin hadnt played for 1 year and in his first come back had no problems containing Fraser.God help fraser if he came up against mcpharlin later on in the season as he would have been totally embarrassed.

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Nobody mentioned Campbell Brown in their Top 10's .... hmmmm ... interesting.

Also, LozNger ... 3 of the 4 Tiger players you've put in that list of forty are 20 years old - Pettifer, Coughlan and Zantuck. Are we to therefore assume that 75% of your entire list don't qualify for this post ...??!!

 

[superstar]

1. Riewoldt
2. Judd
3. Hodge
4. J.Brown
5. Kerr
6. Pavlich
7. Haselby
8. Kelly
9. Ball
10. Koschitzke
11. Cloke

OK, that's 11, but who counting?

 

[Zombie]

Originally posted by GhostofJimJess
Nobody mentioned Campbell Brown in their Top 10's .... hmmmm ... interesting.

Also, LozNger ... 3 of the 4 Tiger players you've put in that list of forty are 20 years old - Pettifer, Coughlan and Zantuck. Are we to therefore assume that 75% of your entire list don't qualify for this post ...??!!

Brown wasn't even rated in the top 10 of first year players, let alone top 10 under 20.

 

[Macca19]

Originally posted by Zombie


I hope that isn't in order Macca

it sure is

 

[Macca19]

Originally posted by GhostofJimJess
Nobody mentioned Campbell Brown in their Top 10's .... hmmmm ... interesting.

i rated him 16th in my list of players 20 and under

 

[MarkT]

Originally posted by sabre_ac
Thirdly McPharlin hadnt played for 1 year and in his first come back had no problems containing Fraser.God help fraser if he came up against mcpharlin later on in the season as he would have been totally embarrassed.

The difference between them is that Fraser PLAYED with his debilitating injury. That is heart. God help McPharlin when he has to play an a fit Fraser.

 

[Zombie]

Originally posted by Macca19


it sure is

Burgoyne and Cornes are better players than Guerra, Burgoyne is better than everyone in your top 10 other than Riewoldt, Kerr, Judd, Kosi and Hodge.

 

[Portmanteau]

Originally posted by Zombie


Burgoyne and Cornes are better players than Guerra, Burgoyne is better than everyone in your top 10 other than Riewoldt, Kerr, Judd, Kosi and Hodge.

I don't know so much about that. Burgoyne and Cornes perhaps have more potential, but Guerra pretty much was the match-winner against Essendon in 2001, and is a far better tackler than either two. I hope they all become stars, and they should do.

 

[Zombie]

Originally posted by Guey_34


I don't know so much about that. Burgoyne and Cornes perhaps have more potential, but Guerra pretty much was the match-winner against Essendon in 2001, and is a far better tackler than either two. I hope they all become stars, and they should do.

If it comes down to the last man in the 22 Cornes and Burgoyne get the nod before Gu does. Guerra has played more games than the other 2 simply because his body is more mature than theirs, skills wise Burgoyne and Cornes are superior.

 

[Royal Blue And White]

Apart from a couple of standouts such as Riewoldt its hard to analyse a top 10 let alone a top 40.....Thats just insane.....There are a lot of players who havent broken through to seniors yet from the past couple of drafts that are going to be superstars.
Being a North supporter and watching Pagan never play the youngsters has meant that our youth are never rated. I was pleased to see a couple of people on this thread mention Daniel Motlop though...This kid is a freak!!! Also David Hale in the reserves is something extra special....Watch out for him!!! Petrie is going to be 'special' but the other two I mentioned look the goods......

 

[ajmart]

You are all ignoring Graham John(ock in the same way as you ignored Andy McLeod in his early years.

 

[Zombie]

Originally posted by ajmart
You are all ignoring Graham John(ock in the same way as you ignored Andy McLeod in his early years.

Johnco(k has been average at best in his first season, no doubt he will improve and just to play a whole season in your debut year is good, he wasn't anything special.

Johnco(k plays off half back, McLeod played in a forward pocket (early in his career), Johnco(k is a straight at it player whilst McLeod is an elusive player, the only reason you are comparing them is because they are both Aboriginal.

Johnco(k is more like Ben Hart than Andrew McLeod.