Top 3 Most Hated Collingwood Players

[Frank Gallagher]

I'll have a crack at my Carlton top 3 guys if you don't mind, can't be bothered looking up our thread.

Kernahan
The Dominator
Judd.

 

[true blue19]

Buckley
Buckley
Buckley

 

[thylacine60]

I'll have a crack at my Carlton top 3 guys if you don't mind, can't be bothered looking up our thread.

Kernahan
The Dominator
Judd.

If you wanted the unconditional love thread you just had to ask.

 

[Captain crippa]

I'll have a crack at my Carlton top 3 guys if you don't mind, can't be bothered looking up our thread.

Kernahan
The Dominator
Judd.

Hated is too strong a word for me
I’ll pick one
Tony Shaw

Hated or strongly disliked is a good thing as opposition clubs are would rate player highly

 

[bleednavyblue]

1 Shaw
2 Francis
3 Banks

(could name so many)

 

[Monkey King]

I don’t hate any Collingwood players. That mob helped us to so many flags I feel nothing but gratitude.

 

[BlueTongue]

Don't really hate any Pies players, but a few in recent times that I definitely didn't like...

Nathan Buckley (Arrogant as a player - don't mind him as a coach)
Nick Maxwell (Dumb & Mouthy - Annoying)
Adam Treloar (This guy is doing well on the Piss-me-off scale. Arrogant and mouthy)

 

[Jabba73]

Hated is too strong a word for me
I’ll pick one
Tony Shaw

Hated or strongly disliked is a good thing as opposition clubs are would rate player highly

Used to think Tony Shaw was the worst Premiership Captain in history. Has clearly been superseded by Nick Maxwell.

 

[Garth Vader]

Can't say I "hate" any Collingwood players. It's a word I generally reserve for StKilda players (esp. Tip Rat, Goddard and Koschinski).

Oh, I do remember that David Cloke's kicking action used to irritate the **** out of me. I guess that's a form of hatred, yeah?

 

[LanceRomance]

Keep your eye on elliot

Got in early

 

[The Blueseum]

Collingwood have always played the game fair and square.

Maybe part of the reason they have lost so many grand finals.

Very few collingwood players I would consider 'dirty' or who did not play in the spirit of the game.

Essendon or Richmond (or Hawthorn) players? Where does the list end? Mongrels everywhere.

Despite hating Collingwood, one thing you can (almost) never pin against them is playing against the rules or spirit of the game.

 

[gab213]

Considered a perfect hip and shoulder back in the day, how many weeks would Magro get today?

 

[calman]

Mick malthouse , that Collingwood coach did more damage to us than any of their players did

 

[blue healer]

Buckley
Buckley
Buckley

I have a bit of difficulty with this choice.

Couldn't get out of Brisbane too quickly and missed being a triple premiership player, never won a premiership at his beloved Pies and since taking over as coach has presided over a consistent downward spiral which turned a potential dynasty into a joke.

What's to hate about that?

Long may he reign.

 

[passmark]

Magro
Magro
Magro.

Not sure it was a hip and shoulder either.

 

[ScottoP]

Mick McGuane × 3

Even more when he played for us

 

[bluebrew]

Nothing but pity , but then everyone needs a Collingwood Around just for the LOLS

 

[1981]

Does Ed count?

 

[TGR]

Dislike: Ray Shaw who completely phoned in a junior clinic when I was a wee lad.
Like: Tony Shaw who absolutely gave it to him for doing so.

 

[Gingerbread man]

Didak
Buckley
Maxwell

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Does Ed count?

Yes.

 

[thylacine60]

Considered a perfect hip and shoulder back in the day, how many weeks would Magro get today?

life in front of a firing squad

 

[bluespur]

Collingwood have always played the game fair and square.

Maybe part of the reason they have lost so many grand finals.

Very few collingwood players I would consider 'dirty' or who did not play in the spirit of the game.

Essendon or Richmond (or Hawthorn) players? Where does the list end? Mongrels everywhere.

Despite hating Collingwood, one thing you can (almost) never pin against them is playing against the rules or spirit of the game.

You forgot the dirtiest of them all The mob from Moorabbin, Ditterich,Muir,to name a couple

 

[Stig O'Hara]

You forgot the dirtiest of them all The mob from Moorabbin, Ditterich,Muir,to name a couple

That ‘78 Saints squad was a pack of animals.

Carl, Sidey, Sarau, O’Dea, Muir, Booth (he was the one that kicked the stray dog at VFL Park).

Was at the game at Moorabin where they went after the Essendon kids, Neagle & Terry Cahill from memory, both knocked cold inside the first 5 minutes.

Honestly thought the crowd was going over the fence that day.

 

[CFC_JP]

Francis
the Shaw brothers
Kink
Magro
Tuddenham
Banks