Werewolf Town of Salem Werewolf IV (Coven Wins)

[Nunez]

I’m trying to believe you Nunez, but man this game is confusing as heck haha. There could be 0, 1 or 2 bodyguards right? Depending on how many town protects we have. Porps is right we could have another one, but it’s probably more likely it’s a trapper.

Bovo’s outcry is also interesting. Surely Bovo and Nunez sit on the opposite sides of the fence, whichever way that is at this point, who knows.

It's bizarre man. Usually if you try and counterclaim someone, you do it after they've claimed and not days later after the doctor protects them. If he's evil, it makes more sense as why not draw a doc protect to me while they kill off someone else?

Equally, I've been visited by mafia and coven, so in this case could only be neutral.

If I were neutral, would I have gone ham at the doctor of all people?

I think logic needs to prevail, even if this game is illogical hahah.

 

[BEaston]

Outside of my collosal *up, what have I said that is rubbish?

Let's see...

• you loosely claimed you had some investigative "results", which you did not have as you're the supposed bodyguard.
• you claimed MCBG said he was mafia (he didn't)
• you claimed potential forged or framed, neither of which were relevant to the situation (smoke screen)
• you claimed hypno'd N1, but ethdog does not see any mafia visit to you
• you said serial chooses the targets of the roles (ie executioner targeting the doctor). I think you know full well it's RNG (more smoke screening)
• you're now claiming transported N1

 

[BEaston]

Maybe you're the bodyguard and it's all legit... but it's a lot of fishyness

 

[serial_thrilla]

Deadline.

 

[Nunez]

Let's see...

• you loosely claimed you had some investigative "results", which you did not have as you're the supposed bodyguard.
• you claimed MCBG said he was mafia (he didn't)
• you claimed potential forged or framed, neither of which were relevant to the situation (smoke screen)
• you claimed hypno'd N1, but ethdog does not see any mafia visit to you
• you said serial chooses the targets of the roles (ie executioner targeting the doctor). I think you know full well it's RNG (more smoke screening)
• you're now claiming transported N1

1. I explained why I was sus on MCMG and given what I was sent via PM and his reaction to the vote, I back my initial vote on him in as I had no reason not to believe he was the plague dude.
2. I said Coven, NOT mafia. That was a logical call too as when I voted him, he replied calling me mafia. I pointed out how it felt like a Freudian slip and my money was on him being coven.
3. Fair enough the roles in this game have ****ed with my brain.
4. So a mind**** as I don't get why I'd have got that PM any other way. Similar to getting poisoned last night, we'll see if it was a Hypno again .
5. Have you ever run a game, used RNG only for it to completely **** a mechanic? I have and then rerolled to ensure balance of the game mechanics. It is a very reasonable and responsible thing to do as a mod.
6. I did not claim I was, I theorised and did not state it as fact, more so throwing out there ways it could have happened without mafia targeting me.

Regarding the last point - I'd love to see what you'd be doing in my shoes. Imagine getting that PM then running a lynch on a wagon. It is confusing a.f and frankly anyone in this situation would be theorising as to why.

 

[serial_thrilla]

NIGHT 3 NOTIFICATIONS

Chipmunk (Coven Leader) killed by the Trapper.
LAST WILL
TBC

Senor M (Tracker) killed by the Mafia.
LAST WILL
N1– I tracked Tarks, who visited Nil.
N2–I tracked Nunez, who visited Sante.
N2 I tracked Chipmunk who visited ???

por_please_ya (Psychic) assaulted by the Juggernaut.
LAST WILL
Psychic night one: at least one of hotchilli, Senor M or rye is EVIL. Bake them away, toys.
I note hotchilli was quick to jump on the MCBG wagon. Not sure if that means he's evil but, was an observation.
Psychic night two: at least one of Pickitt or dogs105 is good.

It is now Day 3.
Voting deadline is at 4pm AEDT.
There are 22 players remaining, so 12 votes required for a lynch.

Night 4 actions may be placed in advance.

 

[DenieD]

Porps last will is a big help.

I say we go after hotchilli serial_thrilla

 

[BEaston]

NIGHT 3 NOTIFICATIONS


Senor M (Tracker) killed by the Mafia.
LAST WILL
N1– I tracked Tarks, who visited Nil.
N2–I tracked Nunez, who visited Sante.
N2 I tracked Chipmunk who visited ???

Nunez I thought you protected eth N2?

I think the game is up for you mate.

Nunez

serial_thrilla

 

[eth-dog]

Agreed. Let's lynch hotchilli now and if he isn't evil then we know rye is and he can be jailed and executed overnight

 

[Nunez]

eth-dog don't hate me for not protecting you night two. I felt very uncertain about your N1 result given it didn't add up with my PM but given Your N2 result matched me getting hypnotized again I believe you now.

Sante have me town vibes so figured he was as good a target as any.

 

[Nunez]

Nunez I thought you protected eth N2?

I think the game is up for you mate.

Nunez

serial_thrilla

Lol way to reply at the same time as me.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Nope, you’re definitely not bodyguard! That role has been taken! This means you are definitely evil.

Are you claiming the Bodyguard?

 

[hotchilli]

I'd prefer not to role claim but why me?

 

[eth-dog]

eth-dog don't hate me for not protecting you night two. I felt very uncertain about your N1 result given it didn't add up with my PM but given Your N2 result matched me getting hypnotized again I believe you now.

Sante have me town vibes so figured he was as good a target as any.

It's suss dude. I can understand that if you are the bodyguard why you'd put a red herring in but it still doesn't look good

 

[eth-dog]

I was roleblocked last night so I think I might have been in jail for protection.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

It's suss dude. I can understand that if you are the bodyguard why you'd put a red herring in but it still doesn't look good

I might have something to help but want to hear from Bovo first.

 

[dogs105]

maybe they are just incompetent? there's a bit of that going around this game

 

[Nunez]

It's suss dude. I can understand that if you are the bodyguard why you'd put a red herring in but it still doesn't look good

Honestly I get that. It does look sus but ultimately I found your claim to be sus when it didn't connect with the PM I'd gotten. Plus Spy would be my go to if I were to make a safe claim as it's a bit OP and I don't think I'd include it. Alas, you proved to be legit and I do trust you now.

Really sorry for the crappy game I've played.

 

[Nunez]

I was roleblocked last night so I think I might have been in jail for protection.

You weren't.

 

[dogs105]

Haha. Suck it Chipmunk!! Revenge for all those times I was 4th in the list!!!

 

[eth-dog]

Okay, then a consort is in play. I'd expect to be roleblocked until they're dead from here.

 

[Nunez]

Agreed. Let's lynch hotchilli now and if he isn't evil then we know rye is and he can be jailed and executed overnight

My read has been as accurate as the weatherman, but IMO Rye is the one I see as the more likely evil of the two. I played with him on his first game back on here a few games ago and he is playing the exact way he said he'd play when evil.

I don't mind going either way though.

 

[thewizardmelon]

Honestly for such a good player, rye has remained quiet, that’s where I want to look. Chilli quiet too though. Thanks for the assist after death porps!

serial_thrilla

 

[Nunez]

Okay, then a consort is in play. I'd expect to be roleblocked until they're dead from here.

I think you've got us some valuable info at the very least. Hopefully we can Lynch the consort today. Positive vibes

 

[eth-dog]

I might have something to help but want to hear from Bovo first.

That's fair enough.