List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
sport fm this arvo .

trade darling to Carlton for pick 5
trade 5 and Emac to GWS for Lobb

This will fix our ruck problem apparently .
Imagine i lobb played for west coast. A late first rounder would be labelled as a stretch for him. has potential but is playing in a gun side and is being shilded by two better players. At us he takes the second best defender
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Imagine i lobb played for west coast. A late first rounder would be labelled as a stretch for him. has potential but is playing in a gun side and is being shilded by two better players. At us he takes the second best defender
At GWS he arguably gets the third best as Cameron and Patton take the best two

That trade is ****ing ridiculous just quietly btw - Darling and Emac for Lobb. Get stuffed
 
At GWS he arguably gets the third best as Cameron and Patton take the best two

That trade is ******* ridiculous just quietly btw - Darling and Emac for Lobb. Get stuffed
we are getting getting bent over there.
I love how badly people rate our players. darling may have few squib moments but he is a consistent performer and is more than reliable. A lot KPF at 22-24 aren't that consistent or great (aka lobb).
 
sport fm this arvo .

trade darling to Carlton for pick 5
trade 5 and Emac to GWS for Lobb

This will fix our ruck problem apparently .

image.jpg


Just quietly I wouldn't even do Darling as a straight swap for Lobb, but maybe that's just me.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

We should not trade Darling for another forward. If we were to trade Darling, I hope it is for a gun midfielder or a very very high pick which we could in turn use to draft a potential gun mid.
I'd love to get Lobb as a Kennedy replacement down the track but losing Darling and gaining Lobb is no improvement on our current setup. As good as he was, Lobb still kicked only 26 goals for the year which included two bags of 4 - Darling offers more if one is willing to ignore the occasional brain fades. Forwards who can average 40 goals even in a mediocre year do not grow on trees.
 
We should not trade Darling for another forward. If we were to trade Darling, I hope it is for a gun midfielder or a very very high pick which we could in turn use to draft a potential gun mid.
I'd love to get Lobb as a Kennedy replacement down the track but losing Darling and gaining Lobb is no improvement on our current setup. As good as he was, Lobb still kicked only 26 goals for the year which included two bags of 4 - Darling offers more if one is willing to ignore the occasional brain fades. Forwards who can average 40 goals even in a mediocre year do not grow on trees.


Liam ryans one to look at for sure

On GT-I9505 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Liam Ryan has shot up the order and is now rated in the top 25 draft picks has kicked 4 goals in the last 3 games .Possible to go higher if stars in G/F ..
 
Liam Ryan has shot up the order and is now rated in the top 25 draft picks has kicked 4 goals in the last 3 games .Possible to go higher if stars in G/F ..
Bugger,we need to tie his hands behind his back for the GF i think a good small forward for us is really important; josh jill isnt really doing the job imo

On GT-I9505 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
what about a straight swap Nelson to Geelong for Vardy? Hes from there, they will retire a couple of their smalls out and we seemingly have small defenders coming out our ears
 
what about a straight swap Nelson to Geelong for Vardy? Hes from there, they will retire a couple of their smalls out and we seemingly have small defenders coming out our ears
No.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top