Roar Metre
Senior List
Who gives a shit if someone reckons the side is a few years away compared to someone else
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rumour Trade rumour/innuendo/fact/fiction
- Thread starter tugga
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Aug 8, 2009
- 10,074
- 12,010
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I would prefer to pay too much for Mundy aka 700k the Bombers are offering him than pay excess for Sherman.
Would really piss me off if we give up pick 28 for Sherman...
Would prefer to spend the coin on securing the All Aus squad member Mundy and then using pick 28 to pay a talented young kid like Ben Jacobs of Priesta 100k a year....
Would really piss me off if we give up pick 28 for Sherman...
Would prefer to spend the coin on securing the All Aus squad member Mundy and then using pick 28 to pay a talented young kid like Ben Jacobs of Priesta 100k a year....
- May 3, 2007
- 1,153
- 519
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- WEST HAM : THE POSH : FORT WILLIAM
If we take Sherman I will kill Craig Cameron telepathically.
Sherman is quick but has no poise - he's a panic merchant.
I always ask myself the same question at trade time... "Was I concerned when he had the footy?" The answer is a clear and resounding NO.
NO, NO and f****n NO again!!
Sherman is quick but has no poise - he's a panic merchant.
I always ask myself the same question at trade time... "Was I concerned when he had the footy?" The answer is a clear and resounding NO.
NO, NO and f****n NO again!!
They're morons.
Ox on SEN last night declared his love affair for Houli, and was on the verge of suggesting Essendon would be losing on that deal
The Yellow Line
Draftee
No Houli, No Sherman, and Mundy only if it does not cost a fortune.
In the press here today, which is News Ltd run, it states that we want Houli and are pursuing trading Polo for him which Essendon are favourable to. Seperately there is interest from a number of Clubs around Tambling which we may or may not consider. That sounds more feasible to me as I would personally rate Tambling much higher than Houli.
Polo's only good game has clearly left an impression. I'd do that deal, seems like both clubs will be getting a player with unfulfilled potential and severe consistency issues.
Polo for Houli is fair
The more Houli doesn't play, the better he gets....Ox on SEN last night declared his love affair for Houli, and was on the verge of suggesting Essendon would be losing on that deal
If Houli straight swap with Bling occurs it will be more humiliating than losing by 157 points to Geelong. **** OFF MEDIA! Houli is a piece of shit slow, poor user under pressure, one-sided limited player!
Also I don't mind the idea of Sherman he is outside and in a side where he gets the pill given to him he will be an asset. Pick 28 and change his contract to 250k-275k per season and I am sold.
SA TIGER
Club Legend
Hopefully we can utilise Tambling to tee up a deal for Mundy. Would a Tambling and Rance trade for Mundy be too much? This way we keep our draft picks.
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #242
That would be an absolute win for us.
And would be good for Polo as he is a good footballer and deserves a shot in another environment.
- Aug 8, 2009
- 10,074
- 12,010
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Are you kidding? I don;t think it would be enough.
Tambling a failed top 4 pick with talent but never shows it, plus Rance a top 20 pick who has never really shown a whole lot and cannot play KPD due to poor aerial ability for a guy who carved it up this season and made the AA squad. Where do we sign.
Rance + Tambling + Pick 28...
Ideally these are the trades I want us to make:
McGuane and 28 for pick 15
Rance and Pick 15 for David Mundy
Dean Polo for Houli
Patrick Vezpremi for our 3rd round pick
Draft Atley with pick 6
Meaning we line up like so:
Moore, Gourdis, Newman
Deledio, Astbury, Connors
Morton Cotchin Mundy
Edwards Griffiths Collins
Vezpremi Riewoldt Taylor
Graham Foley Martin
Jackson, Graham, Tambling, Atley (pick 6)
Then depth players that may replace someone: King, Dea, Tuck, Farmer, Dea ect....
That way our A grade mid rotation would be: Foley, Cotchin, Martin, Morton, Mundy
B Grade: Edwards, Atley, Tambling, Jackson
Tambling a failed top 4 pick with talent but never shows it, plus Rance a top 20 pick who has never really shown a whole lot and cannot play KPD due to poor aerial ability for a guy who carved it up this season and made the AA squad. Where do we sign.
Rance + Tambling + Pick 28...
Ideally these are the trades I want us to make:
McGuane and 28 for pick 15
Rance and Pick 15 for David Mundy
Dean Polo for Houli
Patrick Vezpremi for our 3rd round pick
Draft Atley with pick 6
Meaning we line up like so:
Moore, Gourdis, Newman
Deledio, Astbury, Connors
Morton Cotchin Mundy
Edwards Griffiths Collins
Vezpremi Riewoldt Taylor
Graham Foley Martin
Jackson, Graham, Tambling, Atley (pick 6)
Then depth players that may replace someone: King, Dea, Tuck, Farmer, Dea ect....
That way our A grade mid rotation would be: Foley, Cotchin, Martin, Morton, Mundy
B Grade: Edwards, Atley, Tambling, Jackson
lesrythmes
Senior List
lol
This place is always good for a laugh. "too much"..haha..try not even anywhere near enough.
Mundy is uncontracted. He can walk for nothing so not sure why you're laughing when you would be willing to overpay considering the circumstances.
lesrythmes
Senior List
Ahh...Gold Coast have the first pre-season draft pick, how the hell would he fall to us? It's not like we can price them out of him. We're not going to get him this way to he may as well be contracted.
- May 8, 2007
- 48,686
- 71,373
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #247
According to the hun today we will not be delisting any player until after trade week Oct 4-11
And has also said we have plenty of room in the salary cap to make a play for Mundy.
And the younger players will be back to train in late October and the full squad will start on November 1.
And has also said we have plenty of room in the salary cap to make a play for Mundy.
And the younger players will be back to train in late October and the full squad will start on November 1.
Toadvine
17?19?
- Feb 29, 2008
- 8,331
- 14,801
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens
No they don't. They have no picks in the PSD. All the concessions and the ability to sign uncontracted players out side of trade week/ National draft make picks in the PSD not necessary
Wacky Tiger
Parmy
Brilliant. Might as well see if we can get SOMETHING if anything for our scraps. Somone might just be dumb enough to offer something
Jackson is our main tagger and you have us trading for Houli but he's no where to be seen in your team. LOL if Essendon trade for Polo, he's played 1 good game in his career and that was his first one, which i think was against the Bombs.
- Status
