In the comments of a FB post specifically comparing the Hawks & Lions 3-peat teams, some dickhead pipes up with "Geelong were better". He then goes on about them having the best win-loss % of 2007-11. They can finish top every year as far as I'm concerned, as long as they continue to choke in finals.
It's an odd way of looking at things isn't it? Who wins the championship points in F1 motor racing, the driver with pole position or the one who crosses the finish line first? There is only one way to measure greatness, and that is in terms of premierships, not by beating crappy teams in the minor round.