Yeah you're right champ, doesn't get big supercoach tons, must be no good.
Have you ever heard of Jordan Murdoch? He and Gary are the same player.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Yeah you're right champ, doesn't get big supercoach tons, must be no good.
Rebounding defender? Go and have a nap....Sure you're not mixing up Talia with his brother, or even Jordan Roughead? Michael Talia is reasonably poor one-on-one, but ok as a rebounding type.
I sincerely hope you've confused him with someone, because your posting is absolutely embarrassing otherwise.
Ok great, And your point?Have you ever heard of Jordan Murdoch? He and Gary are the same player.
Ok great, And your point?
ok.Jordan Murdoch is not very good.
Rebounding defender? Go and have a nap....
Surely you guys would be better off going for a genuine KPD, rather than Talia who would ideally play as a third tall defender? How is Allir Allir tracking? KPD stocks seem incredibly thin at the Swans.
Well I'm just glad he's finally made an impact as a mature age player taken in the first round.
Gary Rohan surely can't continue to be thought of as an AFL standard player? Injured all the time, and pretty ordinary when he's not.
Are you one of those Swans fans who sits around in their little red hat and scarf, clapping the famous numbers 23 and 37 for reasons that are beyond you?
Please talk me through why Gary Rohan, pick 6 in the 2009 draft, should not be under the pump? "Oh but he had a bad injury 4 years ago". Was shit before it, is shit now.
I dont want to get into the keyboard warriors stink but the daniel menzel comparison is apt. he doesnt need to find the ball more than 12 times - weve got hanners, and mitchell and jpk and parker etc for that. he simply needs to kick a goal have two score involvements 6 pressure acts and 4 tackles if he plays forward of the ball. and if he plays behind the ball have 15-18 possessions, 2 bounces, and kick at 75% efficiency. he may never be a superstar but his pace, tackling pressure and closing speed as well as his height are all very valuable assets.
Seen plenty thanks Champ, I wasnt aware you play rebounding defenders on the likes of Franklin, Josh Kennedy, Riewoldt, Roughead, Walker... You do realise he played on all these players this year?Might want to maybe tune into a few more Dogs games, "champion". Bloke is a ball magnet.
Oh yeah he alslo played on Patrick Ryder, and Joe Daniher, obviously jobs for a 3rd tall..... You are utterly clueless champ.You mean to say he's shorter than noted 3rd defender Lachie Hansen?
He plays CHB/FB at the Dogs for lack of other options.
"Champion".
Do you not think you're being a bit hysterical? They have been backed by most to challenge the past few years, and rightly so.
Goodes and Shaw have retired. Richards, McVeigh and Grundy are looking tired. Buddy has a huge cloud over him at the moment, Reid always does. Jetta is leaving and Rohan hasn't reached potential hurting their run. Pike is cooked.
Hanneberry, Parker, Heeney, JPK, Smith, Tippett, Jack (x2) and Mitchell are all top shelf but there are serious questions about the depth of the list for the first time in years.
Oh yeah he alslo played on Patrick Ryder, and Joe Daniher, obviously jobs for a 3rd tall..... You are utterly clueless champ.
Sorry mate when u make this comparison u cant point out others lack of insight.Murdoch ever played as a lead up tall forward? or ever apply constant tackle pressure.Pace is the only similar attribute of these twoHave you ever heard of Jordan Murdoch? He and Gary are the same player.
Sorry mate when u make this comparison u cant point out others lack of insight.Murdoch ever played as a lead up tall forward? or ever apply constant tackle pressure.Pace is the only similar attribute of these two
Actually I just base my opinion on more than disposal numbers. Average disposals is a very poor method to judge at any time, but particularly for a player who has suffered in-game injuries, been stuck in the sub vest, etc.You've either got very low standards, or you're deluded. The bloke averaged 11 possessions a game this year, in what may have been his best season since he was drafted. There's no denying his positive attributes, he is quick, he does have good hands, he is not a bad kick, but the fact remains that he is unable to find the footy. Not sure how long you can carry that kind of player in your team. Hasn't improved in 6 years on the list, after being pick 6. Trade bait, I'd have thought.
So you are going ignore the fact Talia gets all the big jobs abd maintain he's a third tall? Maybe take on some of your own advice and watch some Dogs footy. Utterly cluelessFeel free to list the Dogs other "key" defenders, mate. They're in just about as poor a state as the Swans, of course he was going to be asked to play CHB/FB, as I've already said in this thread.
But go wild with your ridiculous attempts at belittling me, throwing around your champs and your champions, instead of actually offering insight.
Of course you would.Yeah he's done both of those things, as well as play on the wing, and across half back.
I'd probably have him ahead of Rohan at this point.
So you are going ignore the fact Talia gets all the big jobs abd maintain he's a third tall? Maybe take on some of your own advice and watch some Dogs footy. Utterly clueless
Yeah great, Murdoch gets more ball, I dont care....
I've said it before on another thread.
I'll repeat it here.
Post Kelly, Lockett, Roos etc. Swans are stuffed! We build a list that goes on to win the 2005 p'ship & just lose the 2006 p'ship by 1 point.
Post Leo Barry, MOL, Craig Bolton, Brett Kirk, Barry Hall, Jolly. Swans are really stuffed! We build a list that goes on to win the 2012 p'ship, play in the 2013 prelim, 2014 GF etc.
Post Adam Goodes, Jude Bolton, R O'Keefe, Rhyce Shaw, Malceski etc. Swans are stuffed this time FOR SURE! We build a list that (enter p'ship year here)!
A well run club with great list management over a span of 15 to 20 years has been planned. Yes we may have a slow year or two while putting game time into some youngsters, but as a supporter I know that that doesn't rule us out of perhaps challenging the good teams in finals. We have a great system.
The Hawks have....................ummm..........................Hodge, Mitchell & Burgoyne for only a short time longer & you know only too well that when Hodge & Mitchell don't have great games (enter what happens here)!