Who do you want to win the premiership the most and least?

[Rotayjay]

To use a tiered approach:

Would be happy:
Carlton
Brisbane
Hawthorn

Wouldn't mind:
Western Bulldogs
Sydney
GWS
Geelong

No thanks:
Port Adelaide

 

[Osho]

After five pages, surprised to see the Swans firmly embedded in the middle of most people’s lists.

Thought there’d be more love and more hate, frankly.

Well, I've played my part.

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

Hated how every man and his dog jumped on the bandwagon in 2016 and acting like they were some type of Leicester City fairy tale story in a salary capped competition. They also get kissed on the by the umps 90% of the time including their whole 2016 finals run.

Wasn't it fantastic? By that reasoning we are a shoe-in this year too I guess the 10% when we didn't get KOTD explains why we only finished 6th

So.... 1. Bulldogs







2+ DGAT

 

[Lsta062]

My ranking from most to least is as follows:

GWS
Hawthorn
Bulldogs
Sydney
Geelong
Brisbane
Port Adelaide
Carlton

Port Adelaide rank so low purely because they let Carlton into the top 8. You had one job!

 

[Aristotle Pickett]

No one wants to Geelong win it and they will go out in staright sets anyway.
No one cares about or wants GWS to win it. Brisbane don't deserve it. Carlton have zero chance.
Longmire is an arrogant coach and Sydney are boring to watch so not them.
Hawthorn haven't got the finals experience and have enough recent flags.
Port would be worthy winners and the Bulldogs would be a great outcome.

 

[myblueroan]

No one wants to Geelong win it and they will go out in staright sets anyway.
No one cares about or wants GWS to win it. Brisbane don't deserve it. Carlton have zero chance.
Longmire is an arrogant coach and Sydney are boring to watch so not them.
Hawthorn haven't got the finals experience and have enough recent flags.
Port would be worthy winners and the Bulldogs would be a great outcome.

 

[Osho]

No one wants to Geelong win it and they will go out in staright sets anyway.
No one cares about or wants GWS to win it. Brisbane don't deserve it. Carlton have zero chance.
Longmire is an arrogant coach and Sydney are boring to watch so not them.
Hawthorn haven't got the finals experience and have enough recent flags.
Port would be worthy winners and the Bulldogs would be a great outcome.

I object!

 

[RUNVS]

 

[SBD Gonzalez]

No one wants to Geelong win it and they will go out in staright sets anyway.
No one cares about or wants GWS to win it. Brisbane don't deserve it. Carlton have zero chance.
Longmire is an arrogant coach and Sydney are boring to watch so not them.
Hawthorn haven't got the finals experience and have enough recent flags.
Port would be worthy winners and the Bulldogs would be a great outcome.

Sydney “boring to watch” LOL.

 

[Sirlemsip]

1. Hawks first obviously.

2. Lions are my 2nd team, and after last year it would be a good story for them to salute.

3. Other than that I think it is GWS' time. I dunno if they can do it, but I'd love to see it.

4. Always respect the Swans and the way they go about it. Don't want them to win necessarily, but would prefer them over some of the other options.

5. The Dogs play an entertaining brand and would love to see Bont get another one (hopefully to go along with a Brownlow)

6. Ken has copped a lot of crap this year, so it would be great to see Port win one, mainly because it will massively confuse the supporters that wanted him gone.

Beyond them it would be:

7. Disappointing to see Carlton win one this year because as a club they don't deserve it, though Cripps as a player certainly does.

8. The Cats I also respect as a club. I just really don't want them to win another one.

 

[Rotayjay]

I think GWS have been in the league long enough to have paid their dues and any success they now enjoy can no longer be attributed to the initial heavily compromised drafts. Therefore I wouldn't mind if they won.

 

[myblueroan]

1. Hawks first obviously.

2. Lions are my 2nd team, and after last year it would be a good story for them to salute.

3. Other than that I think it is GWS' time. I dunno if they can do it, but I'd love to see it.

4. Always respect the Swans and the way they go about it. Don't want them to win necessarily, but would prefer them over some of the other options.

5. The Dogs play an entertaining brand and would love to see Bont get another one (hopefully to go along with a Brownlow)

6. Ken has copped a lot of crap this year, so it would be great to see Port win one, mainly because it will massively confuse the supporters that wanted him gone.

Beyond them it would be:

7. Disappointing to see Carlton win one this year because as a club they don't deserve it, though Cripps as a player certainly does.

8. The Cats I also respect as a club. I just really don't want them to win another one.

We don't deserve it? 100,000 members who have stuck fat. 30 years waiting?
A great team with half - literally half out injured...including when we played you lot.

Don't like Doggies much but looking forward to watching baby Hawks get done Friday night.

 

[Sirlemsip]

We don't deserve it? 100,000 members who have stuck fat. 30 years waiting?
A great team with half - literally half out injured...including when we played you lot.

Don't like Doggies much but looking forward to watching baby Hawks get done Friday night.

I meant you don't deserve it this year. Barely scraped into the finals.

 

[Foxx]

Carlton the most because they've been shit for as long as us.
Brisbane the least, because Danihers a selfish fl*g.

 

[goondog]

1. Dogs
2. Sydney
3. Port
4. Hawthorn
5. Geelong
6. Brisbane
7. GWS
8. Carlton

 

[myblueroan]

I meant you don't deserve it this year. Barely scraped into the finals.

Let me help you reframe.

Yes, we Bradburyed our way into the 8.

We lost to Saints by a point without
Curnow
McKay
Cerra
Martin
Williams
Guv
TDK
ANd those are just our major outs and don't include SOS or Docherty out all year.
So I think most non-biased footy people knew that and thought we were pretty gallant last 2 games to win with 3 rookies playing.
And that is why many commentators are saying ANYONE can win from here. We will have some of our 'must have' players back for Lions game and do I think we 'deserve' to be there?

HELL YES!

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Hawks premiership would ve good for football. It would see the rise of fast and attacking football, as teams always copy the premiers if they can defend against it - and the hawks game plan if very hard to defend against

 

[Outtatym]

GWS.
Brisbane
Geelong for the Richmond-bigfooty melt downs

 

[Rabish Binney]

Any club but Port

 

[Mayes2Gray]

My ranking from most to least is as follows:

GWS
Hawthorn
Bulldogs
Sydney
Geelong
Brisbane
Port Adelaide
Carlton

Port Adelaide rank so low purely because they let Carlton into the top 8. You had one job!

Our job isn’t to lose. Blame freo.

 

[Lsta062]

Our job isn’t to lose. Blame freo.

Well for your sake I hope Port Adelaide players remember that this finals series

 

[Mayes2Gray]

Well for your sake I hope Port Adelaide players remember that this finals series

Never said they were good at their jobs.

 

[Lsta062]

Never said they were good at their jobs.

Well why couldn’t they be bad at their job to win last weekend?

Here I am being a hater now. I just wanted a peaceful finals series

 

[Cleavy]

want: Hawks
don't want: Cats and Dogs

 

[Stax on the mill]

1. Dogs
2. Cats
3. GWS
4. Hawks
5. Port
6. Brisbane







7. Sydney
8. Carlton

If Melbourne were in the finals I’d rank them equal 8th.