Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[South of the Yarra]

I need some convincing on that View attachment 2040132

Oh, my goodness, read my post again. Carlton have won 33% of the AFL Grand Finals they have competed in. In the modern era they are the laughingstock of football.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

This happens roughly every 30 odd years or so since I was born, the filth win a Grand Final, then they think where they are sat becomes the top table. Stinkin' minnows, they never learn.

 

[Worm4]

Oh, my goodness, read my post again. Carlton have won 33% of the AFL Grand Finals they have competed in. In the modern era they are the laughingstock of football.

Geez, you are really clutching at straws there. You know we haven't won a flag for 29 years either , and Collingwood have participated on average 1 every 3 years for grand finals.
Next please

 

[Robertio]

Oh, I missed this thread. It is nice to wonder back in due to a break from the main board due to racist reasons. Great to see Blues supporters up and about. They deserve some bragging rights after years of pain and torment. It is amusing though to see a Tigers fan try to get in for some sledging. Probably symbolic of how pathetic they have become having to ride on the coat tails of one of their arch enemies.

As for the Blues their fans must be getting edgy getting closer to finals. With one of the worst AFL Grand Final win / loss records, winning only 33% of the Grand Finals they have competed in, they must be starting to get concerned. With all this wonderful sledging they have provided (and at the moment it is warranted). they would not want to crash and burn. Hell will be coming if they do, I would imagine.

Concerned lol

 

[Robertio]

I have a very strong feeling we will get plenty of comedy watching Carlton in September.

We're getting comedy right now though mate.

 

[Worm4]

Wondering what Pie supporters think of giving up a 1st round pick for the next draft. Good list management or just plain dumb ?

 

[Worm4]

I have a very strong feeling we will get plenty of comedy watching Carlton in September.

Do they have TV's in Bali ?

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Oh, my goodness, read my post again. Carlton have won 33% of the AFL Grand Finals they have competed in. In the modern era they are the laughingstock of football.

In that case, the big 4 are Blues, Bombers, Tigers & K Mart Tigers right?

The league went national 1987.

Since then, the big 3 in Grand Finals combined = 64% win rate.

K-Mart Tigers have won 29% of their Grand Finals in the same period. 4th rate big 4 club.

 

[Madblue]

Wondering what Pie supporters think of giving up a 1st round pick for the next draft. Good list management or just plain dumb ?

But but they got Schultz

 

[Madblue]

Oh, my goodness, read my post again. Carlton have won 33% of the AFL Grand Finals they have competed in. In the modern era they are the laughingstock of football.

Pies with guys that should have retired last year but clearly playing for records, no depth or quality of youth coming through are the real laughing stock

 

[South of the Yarra]

In that case, the big 4 are Blues, Bombers, Tigers & K Mart Tigers right?

The league went national 1987.

Since then, the big 3 in Grand Finals combined = 64% win rate.

K-Mart Tigers have won 29% of their Grand Finals in the same period. 4th rate big 4 club.

Such a sad club the Tigers have become. Try getting into the 16 club with the Big 3. Richmond are like the jealous little stepsister yapping at the heels of Collingwood, Carlton and Essendon wanting to feel important. Go have a conversation with Melbourne and Hawthorn, the clubs on your level. We are not interested in what you have to say in a big club thread.

 

[JustaBattler]

Boring, come on, lift your game, this is a Banter thread not a cure for insomnia thread where you bore me to sleep.

It is quite common for people in a 'depressed state of mind' to seek solace in sleep.

I'd be pretty discomfitted too contemplating the reality of what is Collingwood -currently playing at its peak and getting pantsed week in week out.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

More bluebagger cringe on display.
It was much better when they were shit and never seen. Now they are cocky and everywhere.

P.S. Collingwood are reigning champs.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Such a sad club the Tigers have become. Try getting into the 16 club with the Big 3. Richmond are like the jealous little stepsister yapping at the heels of Collingwood, Carlton and Essendon wanting to feel important. Go have a conversation with Melbourne and Hawthorn, the clubs on your level. We are not interested in what you have to say in a big club thread.

Are those the same Tigers who lead all comers in YOUR all important stat, % of Grand Finals won in the national era? Woops.

 

[JustaBattler]

More bluebagger cringe on display.
It was much better when they were shit and never seen. Now they are cocky and everywhere.

P.S. Collingwood are reigning champs. Stay in your lane.

Still getting over your brave effort against Carlton are you mate? Need a bucket for those tears or are you down to just boxes of Kleenex now?

 

[South of the Yarra]

It is quite common for people in a 'depressed state of mind' to seek solace in sleep.

I'd be pretty discomfitted too contemplating the reality of what is Collingwood -currently playing at its peak and getting pantsed week in week out.

Come on, give me something, anything. Can someone find some banter that is at least original.

 

[Worm4]

More bluebagger cringe on display.
It was much better when they were shit and never seen. Now they are cocky and everywhere.

P.S. Collingwood are reigning champs.

Collingwood are replicating Geelongs 2023 season. It's a fantastic fall from grace.
It's happenning

 

[South of the Yarra]

Are those the same Tigers who lead all comers in YOUR all important stat, % of Grand Finals won in the national era? Woops.

You're not relevant in a big club thread. This is for the powerhouse clubs Collingwood and Carlton. Go start a jealous little minnow thread so you can have something to talk about.

 

[Worm4]

Come on, give me something, anything. Can someone find some banter that is at least original.

You literally regurgitated a stat about Carlton and grand finals, and you need someone to come up with something original ?
Take your medicine. You are in the wrong thread. The pies are cooked

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Still getting over your brave effort against Carlton are you mate? Need a bucket for those tears or are you down to just boxes of Kleenex now?

Less than two years since our last flag. You still got your VHS and beta max machines to watch yours?

Collingwood are replicating Geelongs 2023 season. It's a fantastic fall from grace.
It's happenning

And what happened to both before that eventuation?

Some of us don't exist to accumulate No.1 picks.

 

[Robertio]

More bluebagger cringe on display.
It was much better when they were shit and never seen. Now they are cocky and everywhere.

P.S. Collingwood are reigning champs.

Have a squiz at the ladder.

 

[South of the Yarra]

You literally regurgitated a stat about Carlton and grand finals, and you need someone to come up with something original ?
Take your medicine. You are in the wrong thread. The pies are cooked

Yes please, something original, the Blues are in control, doing great, give us some decent banter. Don't be a Richmond rehash.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Wondering what Pie supporters think of giving up a 1st round pick for the next draft. Good list management or just plain dumb ?

Perfect draft to bottom out on imho

Pick 1 here we come babyyyyyyy

 

[Robertio]

Come on, give me something, anything. Can someone find some banter that is at least original.

Are you new to this thread?

 

[Worm4]

And what happened to both before that eventuation?

That was my point. Clearly went over your head. Both won flags with aging lists and shit the bed the following year.