Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5

[Dtennent94]

The big question will be, who will whinge more about not getting free kicks - Nick or Charlie? I'm sure both will continually put arms in the air sooking about not getting free kicks

De Goey was the only real whinger I saw last night. Wasn’t a fan of his game.

Nick gets taken to ground without the ball every second play. Can’t call him a sook for getting 1/10 of the free kicks he deserves.

 

[beema limapep]

Carlton fans gifted a game against Freo in 2024 going off about umpires.

Never change Blue Baggers.

Also more gifted by the umpires in recent times than Collingwood. See the 2024 free kick differential ladder below.

 

[Worm4]

Weird insecure shit.

its up there with lurking around a thread not directly involving your footy side

 

[Worm4]

De Goey was the only real whinger I saw last night. Wasn’t a fan of his game.

Nick gets taken to ground without the ball every second play. Can’t call him a sook for getting 1/10 of the free kicks he deserves.

It took Nick 5 seconds to throw his arms in the air at the opening centre bounce against Port.

 

[Robertio]

?

Also more gifted by the umpires in recent times than Collingwood. See the 2024 free kick differential ladder below.

View attachment 2257215

5 free kicks difference over the whole season wow that's big mate, which Pie posters alt are you?

 

[Dtennent94]

It took Nick 5 seconds to throw his arms in the air at the opening centre bounce against Port.

If he can put his arms up to get the umpire to look his way when Drew is holding his jumper while not detracting from his own ability to keep playing the contest, then why not?

 

[Worm4]

Also more gifted by the umpires in recent times than Collingwood. See the 2024 free kick differential ladder below.

View attachment 2257215

If you're gunna post these old stats, at least post the current one as well relevant to 2025 for comparison

 

[Fadge]

Goals 2025

Houston 1
McKay 1
Curnow 0

Can you do that for Sidebottom?

 

[carlton_99]

Also more gifted by the umpires in recent times than Collingwood. See the 2024 free kick differential ladder below.

View attachment 2257215

I dont know what worse. Using free kick numbers to evaluate umpiring. Or just posting that you don't like people whinging about umpiring and then posting a ladder of free kick differential from a previous season to whine about umpiring

 

[Worm4]

I dont know what worse. Using free kick numbers to evaluate umpiring. Or just posting that you don't like people whinging about umpiring and then posting a ladder of free kick differential from a previous season

Why would poster put up stats relevant to 2025 ? Maybe because pies are +18 , and Carlton are in the negative..mmmm

 

[peetoo]

The umpires are clearly picking out marking contest interference to the point it’s sometimes absurd

 

[doppleganger]

I dont know what worse. Using free kick numbers to evaluate umpiring. Or just posting that you don't like people whinging about umpiring and then posting a ladder of free kick differential from a previous season to whine about umpiring

Are you still blabbering on about umpiring

 

[South of the Yarra]

Why would poster put up stats relevant to 2025 ? Maybe because pies are +18 , and Carlton are in the negative..mmmm

Why do you just keep making statistics up. Collingwood are not close to plus 18 for free kicks this year.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Haha Owen 2.

 

[South of the Yarra]

I expect a weekly update if you are going to run with this sort of rubbish

Things are getting tense in Panama. Will the Blues ever get back to Mexico?

 

[Robertio]

Pies scraped home against an injury riddled middling team Blues will be 2-2 in a couple of weeks.

 

[carlton_99]

Are you still blabbering on about umpiring

Hard to see how you get that from my comment

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Pies scraped home against an injury riddled middling team Blues will be 2-2 in a couple of weeks.

Again, Carlton focussing on Collingwood.

Focus on the rest of the league - there are several sides better than the Pies this year (currently).

If you want to win it you’ll need to go through them.

 

[Robertio]

Again, Carlton focussing on Collingwood.

Focus on the rest of the league - there are several sides better than the Pies this year (currently).

If you want to win it you’ll need to go through them.

Last time i looked this is a Carlton Collingwood thread old mate, check if you like.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Pies scraped home against an injury riddled middling team Blues will be 2-2 in a couple of weeks.

And Carlton lost to a team of 18 years in the first year of a rebuild

Carlton would have lost to the Dogs last night - softest team in the league.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

And Carlton lost to a team of 18 years in the first year of a rebuild

Carlton would have lost to the Dogs last night - softest team in the league.

Weren't u lot 50 points down vs North last year and also lost to GWS 2nds by over 50 in Rd 0?

 

[Robertio]

And Carlton lost to a team of 18 years in the first year of a rebuild

Carlton would have lost to the Dogs last night - softest team in the league.

We'll beat the Doggies next week and Pies the week after.

 

[smasha]

All I could hear last night was the "free kick Collingwood" by the umpires.
Sounded like sulphur crested cockatoos.

If you actually sat a sulphur crested cockatoo next to the TV last night,the first three words the bird would learn is Free kick Collingwood.

There ya go Pies fans,your own trolling pet.

 

[nahnah]

Pies scraped home against an injury riddled middling team Blues will be 2-2 in a couple of weeks.

Bulldogs have a lot of talent, they are middling but really shouldnt be

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Again, Carlton focussing on Collingwood.

Focus on the rest of the league - there are several sides better than the Pies this year (currently).

If you want to win it you’ll need to go through them.

Well then this is a disaster for Collingwood.

You’ve traded away your future with the oldest list in the league, for what? To be the 4th best team in it?

If Collingwood don’t win the flag then it’s a huge failure.