Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5

[beerbandit]

At what point do we bring up the vision of golden boy squibbing a contest.

Not sure but that moment was a podium effort for the golden squib award

 

[Worm4]

Not sure but that moment was a podium effort for the golden squib award

Not sure if he will ever take it off Nick. He is the current title holder

 

[Drought Break]

this is the part that will hurt them the most, even more painful the team that beat them tongiht got it.

that is painful, giving an early first rounder to a genuine contender.

 

[Fadge]

Kingy this morning on SEN - 'If ever a club needed Dan Houston in the off season, it was Carlton...'

 

[nahnah]

Not sure if he will ever take it off Nick. He is the current title holder

piss poor banter, Nick has proven he can win contested footy in the biggest game you can play
Blues really down bad at the moment

 

[Fadge]

At what point do we bring up the vision of golden boy squibbing a contest.

'Hey, look over there!'

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

At what point do we bring up the vision of golden boy squibbing a contest.

When Cripps stops playing rugby.

Glad the umpires are having the gonads to pay the throws now.

 

[nahnah]

When Cripps stops playing rugby.

Glad the umpires are having the gonads to pay the throws now.

Still giving him an eternity to get rid of the ball though

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Kingy this morning on SEN - 'If ever a club needed Dan Houston in the off season, it was Carlton...'

It was clear we couldn’t afford him, I’m not sure what everyone wanted us to do? Cheat the cap?

 

[carlton_99]

Still giving him an eternity to get rid of the ball though

Only a Collingwood supporter could watch that game and have this as their conclusion regarding umpiring yesterday. Genuinely bizarre

 

[doppleganger]

It was clear we couldn’t afford him, I’m not sure what everyone wanted us to do? Cheat the cap?

That wasn't the narrative Bagger fans originally went with.

They didn't need a skilled outside runner to launch attacks off HB was the claim.

 

[Arr0w]

Kingy also said this morning that he believes coaches votes are skewed, highlighting the rabbit getting 5 votes last week

Not like we don't know what's going on

 

[CarmenSandiego]

That wasn't the narrative Bagger fans originally went with.

They didn't need a skilled outside runner to launch attacks off HB was the claim.

it's a bit from both columns imo.

salary cap is clearly super tight. could we have worked out a way to afford him? yeah maybe, if we made some bold trades (which i wasnt against).

however, a hbf isn't/wasn't our priority - a small fwd and 2nd kpd is, any footy fan with half a brain who watches us regularly knows this.

if a player of houstons calibre was on the market - but played as a small fwd/kpd, i think we would've made the necessary moves to land them.

maybe it was a mistake, and if we traded someone like mckay or cerra and steak knives we could've got him, but i guess the club backed itself to be better, or have similar output without having to do that.

we wouldn't be much better with him anyway, the game plan, or the players strategy to execute it is just terrible.

 

[Worm4]

'Hey, look over there!

Hey looky, a contest in a pack, I better not get involved, i might get injured.....

 

[Ctracks]

Kingy also said this morning that he believes coaches votes are skewed, highlighting the rabbit getting 5 votes last week

Not like we don't know what's going on

It will be ok. P Cripps 3 votes.

 

[Arr0w]

It will be ok. P Cripps 3 votes.

3 out of 5 isn't bad, 5 for rabbit last week was a rort

 

[Fadge]

Hey looky, a contest in a pack, I better not get involved, i might get injured.....

You are obsessed with him.

Lucky for you, you've only got another dozen years of watching him dominate the competition, in a team that contends for the premiership as often as they don't.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

You are obsessed with him.

Lucky for you, you've only got another dozen years of watching him dominate the competition, in a team that contends for the premiership as often as they don't.

 

[Arr0w]

A matter of when not if

 

[doppleganger]

it's a bit from both columns imo.

salary cap is clearly super tight. could we have worked out a way to afford him? yeah maybe, if we made some bold trades (which i wasnt against).

How the **** is the cap tight?

Horrible list management if that is the case.

however, a hbf isn't/wasn't our priority - a small fwd and 2nd kpd is, any footy fan with half a brain who watches us regularly knows this.

It should be, Doc, Saad, Hollands is a poor group of rebounding half back flankers.

if a player of houstons calibre was on the market - but played as a small fwd/kpd, i think we would've made the necessary moves to land them.

maybe it was a mistake, and if we traded someone like mckay or cerra and steak knives we could've got him, but i guess the club backed itself to be better, or have similar output without having to do that.

A dual all Australian in their prime supposedly wants to come to your club, but you decide you don't need him...

we wouldn't be much better with him anyway, the game plan, or the players strategy to execute it is just terrible.

Players gave good effort last night, but you need someone who can break and line and has good disposal...

 

[Worm4]

You are obsessed with him.

Lucky for you, you've only got another dozen years of watching him dominate the competition, in a team that contends for the premiership as often as they don't.

Owies / Kennedy

 

[Fadge]

Yep.

You guys have the joy of watching Daicos for another dozen years dominate the competition in a team that regularly contends for the premiership, whilst I have the joy of watching Carlton bumble along, making mistake after mistake and flipping between the bottom four and finals contention, without ever genuinely contending for a premiership.

Glorious.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Yep.

You guys have the joy of watching Daicos for another dozen years dominate the competition in a team that regularly contends for the premiership, whilst I have the joy of watching Carlton bumble along, making mistake after mistake and flipping between the bottom four and finals contention, without ever genuinely contending for a premiership.

Glorious.

i like daicos, but my team sucks.

you get to enjoy all that, but you still have to wake up every day being you lol.

i'd rather my situation tbh.

 

[Worm4]

Yep.

You guys have the joy of watching Daicos for another dozen years dominate the competition in a team that regularly contends for the premiership, whilst I have the joy of watching Carlton bumble along, making mistake after mistake and flipping between the bottom four and finals contention, without ever genuinely contending for a premiership.

Glorious.

You think pies are a genuine contender this year?

 

[Fadge]

i like daicos, but my team sucks.

you get to enjoy all that, but you still have to wake up every day being you lol.

i'd rather my situation tbh.

Dur Hur Hur

Lololol...