Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2025

  • Collingwood

    Votes: 110 51.4%
  • Carlton

    Votes: 104 48.6%

  • Total voters
    214

Remove this Banner Ad

Nah, they paid Carlton players to play dead in the prelim, then word got out, and 2 players got 5 years bans prior to the GF.
so lets be fair then - Collingwood shoudl have a flag taken off their fake flag list

back to 15 you dirty birds! and take the three match fixed depression era flgs off them as well- back to 12 - which kinda feels abotu right for this bunch...
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Nah, they paid Carlton players to play dead in the prelim, then word got out, and 2 players got 5 years bans prior to the GF.
Your running with Collingwood bribed Carlton blokes to play dead in the 1909 GF and then again in multiple games throughout 1910...which was all part of a long plan to have them identified by the Carlton committee on the eve of the 1910 finals series so they wouldn't be able to play dead and gift the Pies a win!

Some of your best Worm fake news.
 
Your running with Collingwood bribed Carlton blokes to play dead in the 1909 GF and then again in multiple games throughout 1910...which was all part of a long plan to have them identified by the Carlton committee on the eve of the 1910 finals series so they wouldn't be able to play dead and gift the Pies a win!

Some of your best Worm fake news.
140+ years of SHAME for your mob !!
 
Your running with Collingwood bribed Carlton blokes to play dead in the 1909 GF and then again in multiple games throughout 1910...which was all part of a long plan to have them identified by the Carlton committee on the eve of the 1910 finals series so they wouldn't be able to play dead and gift the Pies a win!

Some of your best Worm fake news.
Has Collingwood ever breached salary cap ? Yes
Has Collingwood ever bribed players to play dead ? Yes
Has past presidents of Collingwood ever been seen to be racist ? Yes
Have Collingwood players ever been found guilty of placing bets on football ? Yes
Are Collingwood considered a shit club ? Yes
Squeaky clean my arse you bunch of rats toss bags.
Hypocrites the lot of ya's
 
Dirty rotten cheating cooked Pies had to bribe Carlton players to make sure there wouldn't be yet another Pies chokejob vs the Blues in finals. Says it all really...

What a stain on the competition that wretched, rotten, toothless merry band of flogs are.

15 flags in my books. Still got some catching up to do!
 
Yeah but the Collingwood 1958 to 1990 experience, constantly finding various ways to squander and lose grand finals that is it's own form of humiliation and torment i think.

You hate us and we hate you that's how it works, but some of your posts do show signs of psychological trauma that is still prevalent from that era in you.

Granted we have been poor for quite a considerable period of time, yet i would be of the mindset and mentality that when the stakes are at their highest that Carlton will always prevail over Collingwood.

It's just one of the facts of life! As for the modern-day Carlton well at least we aren't Essendon who last won a finals game twenty years ago.
Agree 58-90 was tough and left scars. Very different type of tough compared to your last 29 years. The only people I would wish that on are Carlton supporters. I couldnt stand becoming irrelevent to the comp.

You are really living in the past and denying reality. "When stakes are highest Carlton will prevail". Pretty big stakes your last game of 22, remember this




"At least you aren't Essendon". Youre last 29 years have been so much worse than theirs. What are you smoking?
 
Agree 58-90 was tough and left scars. Very different type of tough compared to your last 29 years. The only people I would wish that on are Carlton supporters. I couldnt stand becoming irrelevent to the comp.

You are really living in the past and denying reality. "When stakes are highest Carlton will prevail". Pretty big stakes your last game of 22, remember this




"At least you aren't Essendon". Youre last 29 years have been so much worse than theirs. What are you smoking?

Hold up... All we've heard from the toothless brains trust this off season is that scraping into finals is meaningless as seen with our game vs Brisbane this year?

Which is it?

Ultimately the last time the Pies beat the Blues when the stakes were truly at the highest they can be was before a single one of us were born. Embarassing.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Or just a final?
Only two since you last beat us in a final 84 and 88, 1 win each

Other fun facts.

Since 2010, the modern era Coll 21wins Carl 6 wins . Carlton Collingwoods bunny
Since your last flag Collingwood 23 finals victories, Carlton 8

Spoons hahahahahahahahaha
 
Hold up... All we've heard from the toothless brains trust this off season is that scraping into finals is meaningless as seen with our game vs Brisbane this year?

Which is it?

Ultimately the last time the Pies beat the Blues when the stakes were truly at the highest they can be was before a single one of us were born. Embarassing.
Yep dont like that, dont have any trouble saying that. For the grandpas and grandmas on the board they had a good Carlton time a long time ago. You Walshy not so much. Sucks to be a Blue in this day and age
 
Only two since you last beat us in a final 84 and 88, 1 win each

Other fun facts.

Since 2010, the modern era Coll 21wins Carl 6 wins . Carlton Collingwoods bunny
Since your last flag Collingwood 23 finals victories, Carlton 8

Spoons hahahahahahahahaha
bklah bloah blah "Modern era" - what a load of BOLLocKz you ferals spew

I say teh "modern era started in 2024 - howz zat!! and yoru monb are Mexicans in teh "modernz eraz"

LOl at yoru total rejection of football- and your pathetic attempt to rewrite history - no wonder though what a shameful awful CLub in prison stripes.
 
Hold up... All we've heard from the toothless brains trust this off season is that scraping into finals is meaningless as seen with our game vs Brisbane this year?
Which Collingwood poster said that?

Are you imagining?

Or merely lying like many of your Carlton supporting brethren?

We have said Carlton were finals frauds, and took the position off more deserving sides courtesy of their soft fixture.
 
Which Collingwood poster said that?

Are you imagining?

Or merely lying like many of your Carlton supporting brethren?

We have said Carlton were finals frauds, and took the position off more deserving sides courtesy of their soft fixture.

the only confoirmed liar in this thread is ou fudgey ( fact )
 
Which Collingwood poster said that?

Are you imagining?

Or merely lying like many of your Carlton supporting brethren?

We have said Carlton were finals frauds, and took the position off more deserving sides courtesy of their soft fixture.
From the man who says fixtures and injuries are what loseeeerrrs focus on... Good old Fudgelina, forever tying urself in knots.
 
Which Collingwood poster said that?

Are you imagining?

Or merely lying like many of your Carlton supporting brethren?

We have said Carlton were finals frauds, and took the position off more deserving sides courtesy of their soft fixture.

You calling people liars? Rich

Actually in your case, not rich at all
 
Hold up... All we've heard from the toothless brains trust this off season is that scraping into finals is meaningless as seen with our game vs Brisbane this year?
Hold up, it is actually Baggers who were claiming scraping into finals as being meaningless when slagging off Essendon or running with the moronic Ricky Bobby if you aint first your last crap.

Making finals aint meaningless, if earnt.

However, Carlton was gifted a finals position due to having 30% of your 2024 wins against two horrific teams.

The 0-60 scoreline was expected when a team only qualified due to a soft fixture.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Back
Top