Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Robertio]

No I was being churlish. You almost definitely rorted the cap then too but it was 30 years ago now. If you have to go back to 1987 for your last premiership we’re getting beyond living memory and that’s too cruel even for Blues supporters.

Why would I be bitter? I wasn’t born when most of the Blues success happened and even then Im nearly middle aged. Carlton’s total lack of success for the majority of my life has been heart warming and life affirming

We rorted the cap in 95 because you say we did, i believe you mate.

 

[Robertio]

Two different competitions

They were all the main leagues from the start.

 

[carlton_99]

I think all neutrals just hate the Blose because thry get an easier ride in '25 than most bottom 8 teams. I'm surprised they didn't slip in some EDFL sides in there for an even greater leg up.

Ah yes and those same "neutrals" only seem to pipe up when Carlton benefit from the fixture. Nothing said all those years Carlton were handed rubbish every year despite being at the bottom.

 

[rye]

Embarrassing stuff from Rye. I can still hear his moans that Neale should have been AA captain over Bont or Cripps permeating through the AA threads

the argument was actually zorko should have been aa captain. keep up walshy.

 

[rye]

Ah yes and those same "neutrals" only seem to pipe up when Carlton benefit from the fixture. Nothing said all those years Carlton were handed rubbish every year despite being at the bottom.

im pretty sure everyone complained when carlton got nearly all the friday night games and proceeded to stink up primetime television?

 

[rye]

No just a known Carlton troll. He just doesn't make it his sole mission in life like Fudgey.

He's not too bad.

 

[carlton_99]

im pretty sure everyone complained when carlton got nearly all the friday night games and proceeded to stink up primetime television?

You can keep trolling all you want. Hope you get the likes you clearly so desperately need.

 

[rye]

You can keep trolling all you want. Hope you get the likes you clearly so desperately need.

the truth does not fear inquisition.

 

[carlton_99]

the truth does not fear inquisition.

The truth is you clearly failed to comprehend my post which was about fixture difficulty. Either that or as I said you are trolling for some likes.

 

[Chronz]

Most Blues fans wouldn't disagree with the easy fixture being a bit laughable.

But what's more laughable is Fadgey and Corn etc saying we're going to finish 15th with one of the easiest fixtures going around

15th??? That's preposterous. I can't believe that Fadge and Cobs would ever think that could possibly happen. I have you finishing 13th.

 

[Robertio]

15th??? That's preposterous. I can't believe that Fadge and Cobs would ever think that could possibly happen. I have you finishing 13th.

Above the Pies again, i like it.

 

[King Tut]

We rorted the cap in 95 because you say we did, i believe you mate.

As you should.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

As you should.

Only one flag out of all that paper bag cheating in the 90s, same as us without cheating

Choked in 93 v ESSENDON then pathetically out in straight sets in 94, pretty useless even paying double cap

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Pistol Night]

the argument was actually zorko should have been aa captain. keep up walshy.

Guess he'll have to settle for a hollow premiership medallion

 

[King Tut]

Your three miserable flags since 1958 is life affirming as well. As for the rest of that piece of dribble you constructed, all hearsay and conjecture mate.

Only one flag out of all that paper bag cheating in the 90s, same as us without cheating

Choked in 93 v ESSENDON then pathetically out in straight sets in 94, pretty useless even paying double cap

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

I chuckle at the faux innocence of the Blues supporters. “Yes we cheated in 2000-1 but no way known would our same president, board and administration have done likewise in 1995!!”

 

[doppleganger]

Same sport though. Ourselves and Essendon are the actual big two of footy.

LoL, Port Adelaide board.

Tis only Port fans who care about premierships won in other competitions.

 

[JustaBattler]

LoL, Port Adelaide board.

Tis only Port fans who care about premierships won in other competitions.

You can care or not about anything you liek or not- same as everyone else- one fact is that putting all the competitions together as they existed when they existed and Carlton is clearly the best Club on that measure - and the omnly measure Crlton cares about is being the best. "Participation awards" are for losers - Collingwood are without a doubt the games most winningest at losing - hence the well earned name of wobblers.

Want any sauce with that?

 

[Robertio]

Only one flag out of all that paper bag cheating in the 90s, same as us without cheating

Choked in 93 v ESSENDON then pathetically out in straight sets in 94, pretty useless even paying double cap

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Double the cap you say lol, it's getting better all the time.

 

[JustaBattler]

Double the cap you say lol, it's getting better all the time.

wait a few posts in it will be triple the cap with a cherry on top.

 

[Robertio]

I chuckle at the faux innocence of the Blues supporters. “Yes we cheated in 2000-1 but no way known would our same president, board and administration have done likewise in 1995!!”

Pies cheated the cap in 90, my cousins cousin says they did so it must be true.

 

[Arr0w]

How good is it that we cheating in gaining every single flag, yet the AFL let us keep each one

Smart business I'd say, that's why you should always your brown paper bags

 

[South of the Yarra]

Even more hilarious - no wins against Essendon

How sad have Carlton become that they have to rely on Essendon to get their glory. You have just proven how pathetic Carlton are.

 

[doppleganger]

You can care or not about anything you liek or not- same as everyone else- one fact is that putting all the competitions together as they existed when they existed and Carlton is clearly the best Club on that measure - and the omnly measure Crlton cares about is being the best.

Not sure what any of that rambling is actually saying?

More Ricky Bobby style crap - if you aint first your last, and Carlton only cares about being first?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

How sad have Carlton become that they have to rely on Essendon to get their glory. You have just proven how pathetic Carlton are.

Bit like the sad and pathetic Pies who were actively cheering on a team that made ur life misery in the early 2000s to beat the Blues while ur mob were sipping on margaritas in Mexico.

 

[Pistol Night]

Bit like the sad and pathetic Pies who were actively cheering on a team that made ur life misery in the early 2000s to beat the Blues while ur mob were sipping on margaritas in Mexico.

I’d barrack for a team full of telemarketers over Carlton. We can’t cheer for teams that made your life misery in the 2000s because that’s every campaigner