Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Fadge]

Cox playing 1 good finals game all the way in 2018 is nothing notworthy.

Except he's played more than '1 good final', and they've been better than 'good'.

I think 'scintillating' was the term that was used, and that wasn't even his best final.

And when assessing 'career output', why does it matter that it was 'all the way back in 2018'?

 

[Worm4]

Worm4 1 more, hopefully the big boland

Only a matter of time

 

[Arr0w]

Cox was a liability in the 2023 grand final

Good set of 2 tone goggles though

 

[Arr0w]

Only a matter of time

Lyonnñnnnnn

 

[Pistol Night]

Cox was a liability in the 2023 grand final

Good set of 2 tone goggles though

On a sunny day that’s brilliant eye care

 

[leon123]

some Carlton bloke answering the question on, so how big is Cox?

 

[YeoShuey]

some Carlton bloke answering the question on, so how big is Cox?

View attachment 2195431

Preparing for that Cripps avatar yet?

 

[leon123]

Preparing for that Cripps avatar yet?

Fair dinkum Yeoee, it will be an absolute pleasure to introduce you to the Pies board and you singing praise of the well oiled machine that the Pies are, trust me, we will be kind to you, because, well, thats the way we are

 

[Pistol Night]

Fair dinkum Yeoee, I will be an absolute pleasure to introduce you to the Pies board and you singing praise of the well oiled machine that the Pies are, trust me, we will be kind to you, because, well, thats the way we are

We welcome opposition on our board. It’s a safe place to leave a reaction..

 

[Arr0w]

Fair dinkum Yeoee, it will be an absolute pleasure to introduce you to the Pies board and you singing praise of the well oiled machine that the Pies are, trust me, we will be kind to you, because, well, thats the way we are

Missed it, what's the bet?

 

[YeoShuey]

Missed it, what's the bet?

I've bookmarked it. I'll post it in a minute.

 

[Arr0w]

We welcome opposition on our board. It’s a safe place to leave a reaction..

Last time I was there, it was akin to a scene in blazing saddles

 

[leon123]

We welcome opposition on our board. It’s a safe place to leave a reaction..

We even have a ready made nearly dedicated thread for Yeoee

The New Carlton Thread​

 

[YeoShuey]

YeoS... your up there in the high cluckering stakes, clucker, clucker clucker. If you are really that confident that the Blues are so much better that the Pies, you would take on a fun bet - illustrates, you know, your not cooking much in 2025, maybe a microwaved taco... who knows. My last offer of a fair and fun bet or are we just going to hear clucker until the end of the 2025 season... then it will be revealed that our ageing geriatrics are still superior to your mob

The Bet

• based on H/A season, simply which club is highest on ladder (even if just by %)

The Prize:

• Change of Avatar for Leon to (P Cripps_) for YeoS (Nick Daicos)
  • In respective footy colours, current or recent image
  • Can change avatar back 01 January 2026
• Loser to post to a Blues or Pies nominated thread stating "Pies or Blues are a really great club, I should never have doubted their superiority"; and
• Must post at least five times a week within their respective BF Team site until 01 January 2026
• an apology note within the who will be better in 2025 thread, stating: "I was wrong Pies/Blues are a better club, I should have never doubted the quality of the well oiled machine that the Pies/Blue are - they will dominate for generations to come"
  • this note to permanently stay and can not be removed/deleted/modified

Arr0w

 

[Pistol Night]

Last time I was there, it was akin to a scene in blazing saddles

Must of been a quiet day then

 

[Arr0w]

Must of been a quiet day then

Only the horse was missing

 

[Worm4]

Or Fremantle v. Carlton, for the past two seasons...

Tell me Fadge, how did the umpires fudge up this match you are referring to ?

 

[Pistol Night]

View attachment 2195438View attachment 2195439

Tell me Fadge, how did the umpires fudge up this match you are referring to ?

Joel Wilson was umpiring

 

[Arr0w]

We even have a ready made nearly dedicated thread for Yeoee

The New Carlton Thread​

Do I need sanitation

 

[YeoShuey]

We even have a ready made nearly dedicated thread for Yeoee

The New Carlton Thread​

Something tells me I won't be posting in there.

And if I did, it would be to debate and win I'd take on all challengers

 

[Pistol Night]

Do I need sanitation

It’s all shit about Carlton so I’d be wary

 

[Pistol Night]

Something tells me I won't be posting in there.

And if I did, it would be to debate and win I'd take on all challengers

Even tattoo flog guy with Premiers 2022,2023 and so on up his arm?

 

[Arr0w]

It’s all shit about Carlton so I’d be wary

If it's a banter thread, I'll pop in for both games, before and after the result

 

[YeoShuey]

It’s all shit about Carlton so I’d be wary

Oh so I could enter in there, argue with them like I do Fadge, and destroy all their dumb arguments? Sounds fun.

 

[YeoShuey]

Even tattoo flog guy with Premiers 2022,2023 and so on up his arm?

Someone really did that?