Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Corn Cobbers]

Only one of them made the eight but you go dream about the 21st Century and 2023 and Tim Membrey lol.

Carlton making the 8 on 2024 is a ridiculous accident of history, can think of at least 60 reasons why to nil against

 

[Robertio]

Carlton making the 8 on 2024 is a ridiculous accident of history, can think of at least 60 reasons why to nil against

At least you had the guts to say we made the eight and it will be in the history books forever, along with our 16 premiership cups.

 

[Fadge]

At least you had the guts to say we made the eight and it will be in the history books forever...

Woohoo!

Carlton making history by making the 8 in 2024!

A year for the ages!

 

[carlton_99]

Saints better than both teams in 2024.

This is certainly something. Carlton finished 8th Saints finished 12th but because Saints won by 2pts in their only matchup all season in Round 24 they had a better season. You lot make me laugh.

 

[Robertio]

Woohoo!

Carlton making history by making the 8 in 2024!

A year for the ages!

Why is it history? We've been in the eight before.

 

[Fadge]

Why is it history? We've been in the eight before.

It is a very rare event.

And you're the one who mentioned the History Books...

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Yes but the century began in 2001

Ah ok even better. I'll amend

 

[Scritchyscroony]

This is certainly something. Carlton finished 8th Saints finished 12th but because Saints won by 2pts in their only matchup all season in Round 24 they had a better season. You lot make me laugh.

Yeah but what a win that was. Loved how the Saints let you hit the lead with less than a minute to go then stole it back with 12 seconds to go.
It was such a stirring comeback by the Bloos who'd been down all game. Bloos fans were absolutely creaming themselves ...but then Carlton Carltoned and couldn't even defend a lead for 40 seconds.

That was your last home and away game. Then you Owen 60'd in the final. Awesome end to the season. Not as good as the grim reaper game but still highly memorable and amusing.

 

[carlton_99]

Yeah but what a win that was. Loved how the Saints let you hit the lead with less than a minute to go then stole it back with 12 seconds to go.
It was such a stirring comeback by the Bloos who'd been down all game. Bloos fans were absolutely creaming themselves ...but then Carlton Carltoned and couldn't even defend a lead for 40 seconds.

That was your last home and away game. Then you Owen 60'd in the final. Awesome end to the season. Not as good as the grim reaper game but still highly memorable and amusing.

I guess anything is amusing when you are in Cancun

 

[Corn Cobbers]

I guess anything is amusing when you are in Cancun

Watched the Carlton final in Cancun!! When it got to 0-60 one of the Mexicans asked me "when is it Carlton's turn to bat?"

 

[carlton_99]

Watched the Carlton final in Cancun!! When it got to 0-60 one of the Mexicans asked me "when is it Carlton's turn to bat?"

One of your better ones ngl

 

[adammania9]

60 odd years, Saints 1, Pies 3, Us 8

Very selfish view to have. There are 30 year old Carlton supporters who can’t remember any variation of on field success in their lifetime.

 

[adammania9]

Oh no.

Carlton's record against St. Kilda since the turn of the century:
11 wins
25 losses

This includes a 12 game losing streak.

Finals Played:
Carlton - 11
St Kilda - 20

So basically St. Kilda - the team that Carlton supporters have been trying to punch down on in this thread - have been twice as good as them this century.

Oh boy.

Luke Ball won his first 14 games against Carlton. Retired with a 17-1 record against them

His only defeat he did his knee in the 2nd quarter

His ratio of premierships and losing to Carlton is 1:1

 

[Arr0w]

Very selfish view to have. There are 30 year old Carlton supporters who can’t remember any variation of on field success in their lifetime.

8 to 3, plenty of supporters on both sides of the fence my age

Glorious really

 

[Fadge]

Very selfish view to have. There are 30 year old Carlton supporters who can’t remember any variation of on field success in their lifetime.

15 million Australians haven't seen Carlton win a premiership, but many of them have fond memories of their 5 wooden spoons.

 

[Robertio]

15 million Australians haven't seen Carlton win a premiership, but many of them have fond memories of their 5 wooden spoons.

25 million saw Collingwood fall to Mexico in 2024.

 

[Fadge]

25 million saw Collingwood fall to Mexico in 2024.

Sick burn.

 

[Robertio]

Sick burn.

Better than the same old shit you keep spitting out.

 

[JustaBattler]

25 million saw Collingwood fall to Mexico in 2024.

I think it may be more than 25 million - add that to the 300,000 that have never seen Collingwood play a final - or the same number of have only have ever seen Carlton be better than Collingwood....

wowee

oh dear who'd wanna be a dirdyberder huh?

 

[Fadge]

Better than the same old shit you keep spitting out.

Yeah, nah.

 

[Fadge]

I think it may be more than 25 million - add that to the 300,000 that have never seen Collingwood play a final - or the same number of have only have ever seen Carlton be better than Collingwood....

wowee

oh dear who'd wanna be a dirdyberder huh?

Tell us again about the 29 generations that haven't seen Carlton win a premiership?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Luke Ball won his first 14 games against Carlton. Retired with a 17-1 record against them

His only defeat he did his knee in the 2nd quarter

His ratio of premierships and losing to Carlton is 1:1

.
Those are some awesome stats! Good job.
He played for two teams that have really had the wood on the Bloos this century.

 

[leon123]

Watched the Carlton final in Cancun!! When it got to 0-60 one of the Mexicans asked me "when is it Carlton's turn to bat?"

Under rated... that was good

 

[JustaBattler]

Tell us again about the 29 generations that haven't seen Carlton win a premiership?

tell me more about the 27 times your mob lost a gf - but gloried in "con" - tending

 

[Fadge]

tell me more about the 27 times your mob lost a gf - but gloried in "con" - tending

We won a lot of big games to get to those Grand Finals - what a great ride my club regularly gives me.

15 million Australians haven't seen Carlton make it that far in their lifetimes.

Oh well. Maybe one day.