Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Fadge · Sunday at 10:42 AM

carlton_99 said:
I understand people look straight to the goal tally but if you watch Carlton enough you will see that we were going no where with Owies as a small forward playing most weeks. Provides no defensive pressure, has no pace, doesn't crumb off the talls (i.e., no positional awareness) and gets a lot of his goals against bottom-tier sides.

He kicked 33 goals in 2024:
Vs Top 14 sides ==> 20 goals in 17 games
(1.18 goals/game)
Vs Bottom 4 sides ==> 13 goals in 6 games
(2.17 goals/game)

Can you now do that for Charlie and Harry, and also for every other forward in the game?

carlton_99 · Sunday at 10:48 AM

Fadge said:
Can you now do that for Charlie and Harry, and also for every other forward in the game?

Did you read the whole post? My point was very clearly if all he is going to give us is 30 goals a year with nothing else and the numbers show that a lot of them are against bad teams then he is very easily replaceable.

Fadge · Sunday at 10:51 AM

carlton_99 said:
Did you read the whole post? My point was very clearly if all he is going to give us is 30 goals a year with nothing else and the numbers show that a lot of them are against bad teams then he is very easily replaceable.

Yeah, I'm sure you truly want to believe that.

Because you've got Motlop. And Durdin.

As I said.... give me the goal ratios of Charlie and Harry against top 14 and bottom 4 sides over the last couple of seasons?

Should we take Charlie's 19 goals against West Coast in 2023 off him, because they were against the bottom team?

carlton_99 · Sunday at 10:53 AM

Fadge said:
Yeah, I'm sure you truly want to believe that.

Because you've got Motlop. And Durdin.

You literally haven't argued with any of the points I'm making. Just keep pushing that agenda

Fadge · Sunday at 10:56 AM

carlton_99 said:
You literally haven't argued with any of the points I'm making. Just keep pushing that agenda

You made a point?

carlton_99 · Sunday at 11:00 AM

Fadge said:
You made a point?

The arrogance to tell someone they're wrong when you haven't bothered to listen to them is impressive.

Bale Dup · Sunday at 11:19 AM

carlton_99 said:
The arrogance to tell someone they're wrong when they haven't bothered to listen to them is impressive.

His arrogance, ignorance, stubbornness and delusion are anything but impressive.

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

WalshistheGOAT · Sunday at 11:21 AM

Fadge would be a great shout for The Scarecrow in a Wizard of Oz remake.

Scritchyscroony · Sunday at 11:29 AM

Robertio said:
Before the trade period you blokes were only saying they were depth players anyway, you can't have it both ways.

Lol. Nobody was saying two of your regular best 22 were just "depth players" . They clearly weren't. They were best 22 players for your club.
It's only since you guys forced them out of the club that you are suddenly saying they were "fringe" and "depth" players. Funny that.

Fadge · Sunday at 11:30 AM

WalshistheGOAT said:
Fadge would be a great shout for The Scarecrow in a Wizard of Oz remake.

Carlton supporters - quick!

Someone's playing the man!

Scritchyscroony · Sunday at 11:32 AM

Fadge said:
Did I?

You're not imagining again, are you?

He is imagining again Fadge. Honestly it's all these poor Bloosers have left... Imagining being a contender...imagine winning a flag.
I distinctly recall you saying you thought Haynes was a good pick up....

Corn Cobbers · Sunday at 11:32 AM

Robertio said:
We are still 8th last time i looked, best you put the word might in there.

Who will be better in 2025? Collingwood or Carlton?

Any 2024 ladders or racist Mexico shit is now off topic

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

WalshistheGOAT · Sunday at 11:35 AM

Fadge said:
Carlton supporters - quick!

Someone's playing the troll!

EFA

Robertio · Sunday at 11:35 AM

Corn Cobbers said:
Who will be better in 2025? Collingwood or Carlton?

Any 2024 ladders or racist Mexico shit is now off topic

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

I presume you're joking here.

Robertio · Sunday at 11:37 AM

Scritchyscroony said:
Lol. Nobody was saying two of your regular best 22 were just "depth players" . They clearly weren't. They were best 22 players for your club.
It's only since you guys forced them out of the club that you are suddenly saying they were "fringe" and "depth" players. Funny that.

We didn't want them and Houston as well, good or bad decision we don't know yet, neither do you.

Bale Dup · Sunday at 11:39 AM

WalshistheGOAT said:
EFA

Umpires call after a bit of on ball jostling between 2 players and 1 appeals for a hold.
"Nah, you're both "in it", play on".

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Scritchyscroony · Sunday at 11:40 AM

Corn Cobbers said:
Who will be better in 2025? Collingwood or Carlton?

Any 2024 ladders or racist Mexico shit is now off topic

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

The racist bullying of Mexicans by Carlton supporters needs to stop.

WalshistheGOAT · Sunday at 11:42 AM

Scritchyscroony said:
The racist bullying of Mexicans by Carlton supporters needs to stop.

Where in God's name has this come from lmao???

carlton_99 · Sunday at 11:42 AM

Scritchyscroony said:
Lol. Nobody was saying two of your regular best 22 were just "depth players" . They clearly weren't. They were best 22 players for your club.
It's only since you guys forced them out of the club that you are suddenly saying they were "fringe" and "depth" players. Funny that.

No mate Kennedy and Owies have always been in that ~18-26 (i.e., fringe best 22) part of the list. Kennedy was sub multiple times and Owies benefited from injuries to our other small forwards.

Robertio · Sunday at 11:44 AM

Scritchyscroony said:
The racist bullying of Mexicans by Carlton supporters needs to stop.

Pies supporters throwing their toys out of the cot lol.

Robertio · Sunday at 11:45 AM

carlton_99 said:
No mate Kennedy and Owies have always been in that ~18-26 (i.e., fringe best 22) part of the list. Kennedy was sub multiple times and Owies benefited from injuries to our other small forwards.

Something tells me that won't sink in.

Scritchyscroony · Sunday at 11:45 AM

WalshistheGOAT said:
Where in God's name has this come from lmao???

You also need to stop with the fat shaming.
Schultz is just big boned.

Fadge · Sunday at 11:50 AM

Robertio said:
Something tells me that won't sink in.

Owies played 23 of 24 games only because their star small forwards Motlop and Durdin were injured.

LMAO.

Fadge · Sunday at 11:51 AM

Robertio said:
We didn't want them and Houston as well, good or bad decision we don't know yet, neither do you.

Carlton didn't want Houston, because they already have Saad and Newman.

LMAO.

Robertio · Sunday at 11:52 AM

Fadge said:
Owies played 23 of 24 games only because their star small forwards Motlop and Durdin were injured.

LMAO.

Our star small forwards are only kids too, takes 2 or 3 seasons just like your small forwards Hill and Elliott.

WBBL Season 10 - Oct '24 to Dec '25

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Who will be better in 2025

Collingwood

Carlton

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Senior List

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Spotswood Guinness Bar manager

Spotswood Guinness Bar manager

Senior List

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Spotswood Guinness Bar manager

Spotswood Guinness Bar manager

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Spotswood Guinness Bar manager

Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account