No one cares about your new found approach of 'median' results.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4
- Thread starter Wosh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.
No doubt it's something Carlton folk would prefer to ignore, but merely correcting your fellow Carlton supporter when he suggested that Collingwood finishing outside the finals was 'reverting to type'.
Rather ironic coming from a Carlton supporter don't you think, given Carlton have very recently endured a 10 year finals drought?
- Oct 25, 2001
- 14,566
- 11,961
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- IOM Gyms, Preston Nth End
So clubs do have a "type"?
It's fair to say Pies do have a culture, with loyalty, covering up stuff (when we can) and high expectations.
Eddie McGuire is very typical if out clubs leadership style and he still has influence, Kelly is a mate IIRC.
The fire sale of Treliar,Grundy Philips etx was the result of that style. Worst of all was the Beams mess.
So is the way we have shown loyalty to a bunch of other blokes, our partnerships with clubs like Footscray and Sydney and Essendon, and our strong financial position.
The way Malthouse left was quite "Collingwood", lots of passion, mistakes, a favourite son, and some losing Grand Finals.
The way Malthouse left Carlton was also very "Carlton". Sacked mid year, a mercenaries, dissension, and an attempt to buy success by getting in Bolton.
Carlton has a style too. Like Collingwoods it goes back decades.
It's quite fair to look back, Pies are playing true to type. We have tried to hold our premiership heroes together for another fling, and been loyal (too loyal?) to favourite sons like Pendles and Sidey and Howe.
Carlton are true to type as well, they rely on a fistful of stars and a truly brilliant captain. Very Carlton. Since the 1960s Carlton have been savage and unforgiving with their coaches and since the 1990s they have been ruined by Elliotesque egotism and factions.
It's fair to ask if they have similar attitudes about pay scales and list balance to what they had 10 years ago, and if it divides the playing group.
Last edited:
You really think you were on your own regarding this area?
JustaBattler
Everyone Looks Better In Blue
- May 31, 2012
- 28,303
- 66,661
- AFL Club
- Carlton
As did Kennedy as did Owies...
but what about Treloar - he has gone on the record as saying he was pushed out along with Grundy ....
selective memory much?
classic dirty birder argument - no matter what Carlton does or doesn't do accrodng to the median this and contender that brigade it is going to be bad- ...LOL
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,883
- 13,584
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
... as evidenced by your elite shitness over the last 25 years
- Mar 21, 2018
- 4,599
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Newcastle United FC
False. Kennedy and Owies were shopped around and forced out.
You have major basic comprehension issues. I said Adams wasn't forced out as you incorrectly stated he was. I didn't mention Treloar and Grundy.
Frig me.... as evidenced by your elite shitness over the last 25 years
Do they expect pats on the back for the decisions they've made that has led to a median ladder position of 13th since the turn of the century, and zero times contending for the premiership in that same timeframe?
I'm just going to concentrate on the thread title.
Does it really matter now ?
Carlton have made 9 list changes currently . Some forced, others pushed, it's what happens in the world of AFL as teams strive to be better. If they don't make changes, then it's virtually impossible to improve. You can agree with that or not, only time will tell. Good luck in 2025
- Mar 21, 2018
- 4,599
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Newcastle United FC
None of it matters mate.
All I was sayings is 1. Adams was not forced out and 2. Just because Collingwood forced out some players in the past and still had success doesn't mean it'll work for Carlton.
... as evidenced by your elite shitness over the last 25 years
As evidenced by your elite shitless over the last 66 year
And round we go again
Contender, median
= clutching defection
Currently, one team is still taco munching, the other isn't
Salty
= clutching defection
Currently, one team is still taco munching, the other isn't
Salty
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
Didn't you tell me this thread is about 2025?
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
The most recent season which has just gone has Carlton in the eight and Pies outside the eight, so it really doesn't matter if you won a flag in 2023 and we hadn't played finals for 10 years does it.
We are all laughing at each other's club, yet both sit top of the tree . Could be worse things in life such as following cronulla, or sides that haven't won more than a handful of flags in 100 years
Anyone have the stats of previous and likely probability of reoccurring posts of the following
Carlton - Shite over the last 3 decades v Pies
Pies - Shite over the last 7 decades v Carlton
I'd say both high, regarding post v rebuttal
2025 content analysis = Extremely low
Carlton - Shite over the last 3 decades v Pies
Pies - Shite over the last 7 decades v Carlton
I'd say both high, regarding post v rebuttal
2025 content analysis = Extremely low
Except, you're lying when you say that.As evidenced by your elite shitless over the last 66 year
And round we go again
Collingwood's record in the last 66 years:
Premierships: 3
Grand Finals: 15
Finals Series: 39
Finals Games Won: 42
Bottom 4 finishes: 10
Wooden Spoons: 2
Compare that to Carlton's last 25 years:
Premierships: 0
Grand Finals: 0
Finals Series: 8
Finals Games Won: 6
Bottom 4 finishes: 9
Wooden Spoons: 5
Now you are comparing 2 different timelines? You really are struggling Fadge
Make it easy first you.
66 years, 8 to 3 flags
Back to those tacos
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
Two different timelines lol, the gift that keeps on giving.
Of course there are two different timeliness.
We point to Carlton being shit over the last quarter of a century, and we are accurate.
5 more wooden spoons than Grand Final appearances.
3 more bottom 4 finishes than finals wins.
Carlton supporters then rebut with Collingwood's last 66 years, and it's a lie.
Robertio
Spotswood Guinness Bar manager
Eight to 3 premierships over the last 60 years isn't a lie mate.
You really di struggle Fadge, and it's declining as a rapid rate
No, it's not.
But to rebut people saying Carlton have been pathetic for the last quarter of a century with 'but Collingwood have been pathetic over the last 66 years, because Carlton have won more flags', is a pathetic and infactual argument.
Because Collingwood haven't been pathetic, as evidenced by their 15 Grand Final appearances and 39 finals series contested in that timeframe.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
- Poll
