Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[HeathySure]

Did you watch Melbourne against Collingwood round 24 . Couldn't get an easier time to play those plodders.
Freo - well , it's freo . You reckon our form was bad in August. Those clowns couldn't win a game.

you must have forgotten we beat Brisbane to knock them out of the top 4

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Did you watch Melbourne against Collingwood round 24 . Couldn't get an easier time to play those plodders.
Freo - well , it's freo . You reckon our form was bad in August. Those clowns couldn't win a game.

C'mon Worm be serious
Freo will give top 4 a shake. Did you see the quality they added to their list in trade period? Thats how it's done Carlton!
Melbourne is still a much tougher gig than North or West Coast.

 

[Fadge]

Did you watch Melbourne against Collingwood round 24 . Couldn't get an easier time to play those plodders.
Freo - well , it's freo . You reckon our form was bad in August. Those clowns couldn't win a game.

So Melbourne's form from round 24 2024 will continue into 2025, but for Carlton 'next year will be different'?

 

[Fadge]

C'mon Worm be serious
Freo will give top 4 a shake. Did you see the quality they added to their list in trade period? Thats how it's done Carlton!

Yep.

When a team falls short of premiership contention, the idea is to improve their list to close the gap.

Carlton meanwhile rely on 'better luck with injuries' and a couple of 18 year old draftees, whilst trading out durable and reliable best 22 players.

 

[Robertio]

So Melbourne's form from round 24 2024 will continue into 2025, but for Carlton 'next year will be different'?

Is that what he said?

 

[Robertio]

Yep.

When a team falls short of premiership contention, the idea is to improve their list to close the gap.

Carlton meanwhile rely on 'better luck with injuries' and a couple of 18 year old draftees, whilst trading out durable and reliable best 22 players.

We were 2nd when De Koning went down and he'll be back and he's not 18.

 

[BloodRet]

both will be shit. carlton tho. carlton 10th collingwood 13th

 

[Fadge]

We were 2nd when De Koning went down and he'll be back and he's not 18.

Lose one player and you drop from 2nd (courtesy of your soft draw) to the 16th best team in the competition (once you started to play some better teams regularly).

Fickle.

 

[Robertio]

Lose one player and you drop from 2nd (courtesy of your soft draw) to the 16th best te in the competition (once you started to play some better teams regularly).

Fickle.

We finished in the 8, your post is factually wrong.

 

[Worm4]

So Melbourne's form from round 24 2024 will continue into 2025, but for Carlton 'next year will be different'?

No, playing melbourne when their season is shot is a guaranteed 4 points in the bank

 

[Worm4]

Is that what he said?

He is having massive comprehension problems today. Meds.....

 

[carlton_99]

No, playing melbourne when their season is shot is a guaranteed 4 points in the bank

It's almost like when you play a team is pretty significant. Who would have thought

 

[Fadge]

No, playing melbourne when their season is shot is a guaranteed 4 points in the bank

It's almost like when you play a team is pretty significant. Who would have thought

Nah.

Collingwood playing Melbourne is very similar to Collingwood playing Carlton- a guaranteed 4 points regardless of when we play them.

 

[carlton_99]

Nah.

Collingwood playing Melbourne is very similar to Collingwood playing Carlton- a guaranteed 4 points regardless of when we play them.

View attachment 2166982

"Nah"

So you disagree with my post that when you play a team matters?

 

[Fadge]

"Nah"

So you disagree with my post that when you play a team matters?

It doesn't matter when Collingwood play Carlton or Melbourne.

Guaranteed 4 points for Collingwood (unless the game is a dead rubber).