Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Pistol Night]

Lewis Young is not a bad player. He's just not great.

I don't think there are any bad players on our list.

Between you and Walshy that’s pretty evident

 

[YeoShuey]

So he’s no Mason Cox?

Probably "borderline" with Cox. Just meh.

Between you and Walshy that’s pretty evident

Do you think there are any bad players on the Collingwood list? If so, who?

 

[Worm4]

So he’s no Mason Cox?

Very similar . Cox rated 18-25th by one of your own. Young rated around 25 -30 . That's of course if both lists are healthy.
I would prefer Cox but none of the sideshow clown gear that he wears. I hear he is petitioning to wear a cape next season

 

[Pistol Night]

Probably "borderline" with Cox. Just meh.



Do you think there are any bad players on the Collingwood list? If so, who?

Fin McRae, Jakob Ryan, Oleg Markov is a shell of last year. Charlie Dean we had high hopes of a KPF to free up Moore but hasn’t delivered yet. Oh and Nick Daicos for stat padding and general squibbary

 

[Pistol Night]

Very similar . Cox rated 18-25th by one of your own. Young rated around 25 -30 . That's of course if both lists are healthy.
I would prefer Cox but none of the sideshow clown gear that he wears. I hear he is petitioning to wear a cape next season

Didnt you read about the eagle and blow up owl. Throw in a cape and the poor campaigner will need 7 hours to get ready for a game

 

[YeoShuey]

Fin McRae, Jakob Ryan, Oleg Markov is a shell of last year. Charlie Dean we had high hopes of a KPF to free up Moore but hasn’t delivered yet. Oh and Nick Daicos for stat padding and general squibbary

Macrae is decent, Markov is ok and cant comment on Ryan. Don't see any bad there

I really like Reef McInness. Shame they don't play him that much.

 

[Pistol Night]

Macrae is decent, Markov is ok and cant comment on Ryan. Don't see any bad there

I really like Reef McInness. Shame they don't play him that much.

Reef has trained down back all off season as a Murphy type replacement. That’s where he’ll be lining up next year and hopefully left there to consolidate his position. Been thrown all over the place and in and out of the side but the kid has talent

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Still waiting for an explanation how any player who has earned an All Australian jacket can be considered behind Cox in terms of career output...

One of the biggest s***trucks to ever play.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Sorry, got you confused with your fellow minnows, North Melbourne.

I tend to group all the minnows together - Carlton, North Melbourne, Richmond, etc.

Richmond gone from 'dynasty team' to 'minnows' in the space of 2 pages... I guess Cox's one good game for his career isn't all it's wrapped up to be after all...

 

[Pistol Night]

Still waiting for an explanation how any player who has earned an All Australian jacket can be considered behind Cox in terms of career output...

One of the biggest s***trucks to ever play.

If you don't get an answer by tonight just wait a bit longer

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

If you don't get an answer by tonight just wait a bit longer

I've got Indian cricket Twitter to keep me entertained in the meantime. The melts are glorious!

 

[Pistol Night]

I've got Indian cricket Twitter to keep me entertained in the meantime. The melts are glorious!

Well go shit on them and leave our poor 7 foot American alone.

 

[Worm4]

Still waiting for an explanation how any player who has earned an All Australian jacket can be considered behind Cox in terms of career output...

One of the biggest s***trucks to ever play.

He must be in Fudges team of the decade along with McStay and Frampton. I'm sure he's got some team formed somewhere along with his top 100 ranked players for 2025 that he will reference ( you know, the one that McKay couldn't make this season) as well.

 

[YeoShuey]

He must be in Fudges team of the decade along with McStay and Frampton. I'm sure he's got some team formed somewhere along with his top 100 ranked players for 2025 that he will reference ( you know, the one that McKay couldn't make this season) as well.

Pretty sure that's just Fadge's failed attempt at bantering.

 

[Fadge]

Are these blokes really still crying about Carlton's 7th or 8th best player over 2022/23 not being rated in the top 100 players across the entire league heading into 2024?

 

[JustaBattler]

Are these blokes really still crying about Carlton's 7th or 8th best player over 2022/23 not being rated in the top 100 players across the entire league heading into 2024?

That is such a stoopid argument ...

where does Mckay rate as a tall forward is more sensible

I reckon easilly a top10 tall forward- eg better than anyone on Collingwood's list ..

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

That is such a stoopid argument ...

where does Mckay rate as a tall forward is more sensible

I reckon easilly a top10 tall forward- eg better than anyone on Collingwood's list ..

Was Bucks pick for AA CHF... Must be a bum...

 

[Worm4]

Are these blokes really still crying about Carlton's 7th or 8th best player over 2022/23 not being rated in the top 100 players across the entire league heading into 2024?

Are you going to cry when the top 50 gets released and your golden boy isn't on top again ?

 

[YeoShuey]

Would Cox get a spot on a Top 400 list for best current players in the AFL? If you're asking me, no chance.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Would Cox get a spot on a Top 400 list for best current players in the AFL? If you're asking me, no chance.

Will be a top 100 VFL player next year if he's lucky.

Will be his last year on an AFL list. Almost certain of it.

 

[YeoShuey]

Will be a top 100 VFL player next year if he's lucky.

Will be his last year on an AFL list. Almost certain of it.

Agreed. He's too old and they don't need him in the ruck anymore.

If I were Collingwood, I'd try one of their newer ones in there: Smit or Steene rotating with Cameron, and give the useless Cox the boot.

 

[Matrix10]

Ummm you really are struggling here, but no surprise given your Carlton posting. Bizarre though as a Tigers supporter you'd be a Pies mouth piece

Cripps 31
30

Williams 31
31 September

Saad 31
31 July

Dochery 32
31 for the season

Acres 30
29 see Doc

McKay 28
27 see Doc

Fantasia 30 (lol)
30 September

Newman 32
First 1 right

Weitering 28
27 see Doc

Pittonet 29
29 June

Hewitt 30
29 see Doc

Curnow 29
28

Haynes 33
33 May

Fantasia keep him on the list , the spud has been recycled by 2 farms. hopefully he lasts at his third farm a couple more years.

 

[Fadge]

Are you going to cry when the top 50 gets released and your golden boy isn't on top again ?

I'm not the poster (or posters) who cry over someone else's opinion...

But it's the second time you've mentioned this now, what is your prediction for the top 5 in the Hun top 50?

 

[Fadge]

Fantasia keep him on the list , the spud has been recycled by 2 farms. hopefully he lasts at his third farm a couple more years.

Be careful, this is the player whose career output is (apparently) borderline with that of Mason Cox....

Given that, he's probably overdue to tear an opposition team to shreds in a big final this year...

 

[Worm4]

I'm not the poster (or posters) who cry over someone else's opinion...

But it's the second time you've mentioned this now, what is your prediction for the top 5 in the Hun top 50?

You have just spent the last 2 days crying over people's opinion on the big giraffe.
Top 50 will be Cripps number 1 as it should be. Then it's a raffle amongst Bont, Neale, Heeney, Daicos , then next level Serong, Butters, Warner , Gulden and chuck in Curnow for winning the Fadgelow forwards award for 2024