Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Corn Cobbers]

Craig Kelly says hi

Thought we were talking about presidents, just any administrator now is it?

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Thought we were talking about presidents, just any administrator now is it?

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Bit hard to critique Eddie's fat red scone, he bailed on the Pies after getting caught up in similar controversy.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Bit hard to critique Eddie's fat red scone, he bailed on the Pies after getting caught up in similar controversy.

Eddie is a fine target

But our current president, whoever he is, is a cleanskin, apparently

In 2025 Collingwood's president is better than Carlton's president

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Eddie is a fine target

But our current president, whoever he is, is a cleanskin, apparently

In 2025 Collingwood's president is better than Carlton's president

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Give him a few years at the Pies and I'm sure some dirt will come to light

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Give him a few years at the Pies and I'm sure some dirt will come to light

Would have to be pretty bad to top LuSlay

Not to mention the likes of Harris, Elliott and Pratt

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

Quiet in here, Pie supporters redirected their attention to defending Pendlebury?

 

[JustaBattler]

Quiet in here, Pie supporters redirected their attention to defending Pendlebury?

? do tell!

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

? do tell!

They've somehow cooked up in their microwaved brains that Pendlebury is the 4th best player of this century

 

[Cyclops]

Quiet in here, Pie supporters redirected their attention to defending Pendlebury?

Plenty of Blues, no one defending Sayers.

I applaud our Blue friends, they adhere to a higher moral standard than their club administration.

They've somehow cooked up in their microwaved brains that Pendlebury is the 4th best player of this century

One of several Pies better than every Carlton player this century.

Judd's best was at the Eagles and....who else is there?

Buckley another definite, and you could make the case for Sidey as well, pretty soon Daicos will have a sufficient body of games too (I mean he's better now but for proprieties sake let's leave it till he hits 100 games).

Honestly it won't be long before we can feild a "Better than every Carlton player this century" XVIII, maybe even a XXIII.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Plenty of Blues, no one defending Sayers.

I applaud our Blue friends, they adhere to a higher moral standard than their club administration.


One of several Pies better than every Carlton player this century.

Judd's best was at the Eagles and....who else is there?

Buckley another definite, and you could make the case for Sidey as well, pretty soon Daicos will have a sufficient body of games too (I mean he's better now but for proprieties sake let's leave it till he hits 100 games).

Honestly it won't be long before we can feild a "Better than every Carlton player this century" XVIII, maybe even a XXIII.

Totally...

Record smashed! Cripps storms to second Brownlow win

Patrick Cripps takes home his second Brownlow Medal in dominant win

www.afl.com.au

 

[YeoShuey]

Why should we care about the opinion of Collingwood supporters who claim that Mason Cox is a better player than Sam Walsh? Mind boggling.

 

[Robertio]

Plenty of Blues, no one defending Sayers.

I applaud our Blue friends, they adhere to a higher moral standard than their club administration.


One of several Pies better than every Carlton player this century.

Judd's best was at the Eagles and....who else is there?

Buckley another definite, and you could make the case for Sidey as well, pretty soon Daicos will have a sufficient body of games too (I mean he's better now but for proprieties sake let's leave it till he hits 100 games).

Honestly it won't be long before we can feild a "Better than every Carlton player this century" XVIII, maybe even a XXIII.

Don't forget Big Cox a legend in his own glasses.

 

[Worm4]

Plenty of Blues, no one defending Sayers.

I applaud our Blue friends, they adhere to a higher moral standard than their club administration.


One of several Pies better than every Carlton player this century.

Judd's best was at the Eagles and....who else is there?

Buckley another definite, and you could make the case for Sidey as well, pretty soon Daicos will have a sufficient body of games too (I mean he's better now but for proprieties sake let's leave it till he hits 100 games).

Honestly it won't be long before we can feild a "Better than every Carlton player this century" XVIII, maybe even a XXIII.

Lol. Make a case for sidebottom being a greater player than Judd .
This will be hilarious

 

[Worm4]

Why should we care about the opinion of Collingwood supporters who claim that Mason Cox is a better player than Sam Walsh? Mind boggling.

This is what it's down to now-
Cox better than Walsh
Sidebottom better than Judd
Daicos better than any Carlton player by end of this year
Ned Long is best 22 if wearing navy blue
Oh lord give me strength

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

This is what it's down to now-
Cox better than Walsh
Sidebottom better than Judd
Daicos better than any Carlton player by end of this year
Ned Long is best 22 if wearing navy blue
Oh lord give me strength

Don't forget

Harry Demattia
Wil Parker
Ed Allan
Fin Macrae
Tew Jiath
Iliro Smit
Oscar Steene
Jakob Ryan
Reef McInnes
Lachie Sullivan
Harvey Harrison
Oleg Markov
Ash Johnson
Charlie Dean
Ned Long
Mason Cox


All better than Owies and Kennedy apparently

 

[Robertio]

Lol. Make a case for sidebottom being a greater player than Judd .
This will be hilarious

I didn't say anything, can see a good fisherman a mile away.

 

[Red_man2008]

Terrifying prospect, having to rely on Freo in a GF

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

This would be an incredibly entertaining GF. Carlton and Freo have become somewhat rivals recently and always close games. The neutral supporter would love it. Carlton to break a 30 year drought or Fremantle first ever. What’s not to like.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

This would be an incredibly entertaining GF. Carlton and Freo have become somewhat rivals recently and always close games. The neutral supporter would love it. Carlton to break a 30 year drought or Fremantle first ever. What’s not to like.

Two of the best midfields in the league going head to head would be fantastic to watch. Jackson/Darcy vs TDK

 

[Corn Cobbers]

This would be an incredibly entertaining GF. Carlton and Freo have become somewhat rivals recently and always close games. The neutral supporter would love it. Carlton to break a 30 year drought or Fremantle first ever. What’s not to like.

It would be terrific, until they bounced the ball

I would load up on Carlton and go to the beach

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Thrawn]

In 2025 Collingwood's president is better than Carlton's president

Might change in a few weeks.

Perhaps Fudge might give it a go?

 

[Worm4]

Might change in a few weeks.

Perhaps Fudge might give it a go?

Well he proclaims to know more about the Carlton FC, than the Carlton FC....

 

[Noidnadroj]

One of his career best games, in which he was duly awarded a Brownlow vote.

Midfielder with 18 Brownlow votes from 179 career games.

I know he has a strong defensive element to his game, but he's a C Grader, no matter how you spin it.

How do you rate Lipinski? Above or below Hewett?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Fadge]

How do you rate Lipinski? Above or below Hewett?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Hewett slightly ahead of Lipinski. Both C Graders.

Hewett gets more midfield time and therefore gets slightly more of the ball, whilst Lipinski spends more time forward of centre and hits the scoreboard more.

Both good, honest role players.

 

[Cyclops]

Might change in a few weeks.

Perhaps Fudge might give it a go?

Nah he's shy about sending dickpics, unqualified for the job.

Jokes aside its a weird one. If it was "romance" then its a private matter, we all lol and he carries on. If it's nasty he obviously has to go.

I have no idea, my guess would be romance but how would I know? Poor woman would be embarrassed and that makes it hard for everyone to tell the truth.

Sayers mucked up by lying about the hack. It's not irrecoverable but he's made it harder to.

"Never apologise, never explain" is a tough policy and it works. Unfortunately he explained. If he apologises he's gone.

 

[JustaBattler]

Sorry to hear that Naicos has succombed to stress relateded injury - I hate it when serious talent gets compromised by the reality of inevitable wear and tear. Took Walsh 2 season and two surgeries to understand that his back injury was as much his own fault as the game's. The elite kids these days have put their bodies through a lot of wear and tear- before they are even drafted. Hopefully DeGoey can manage his own OP issues - these two players are pretty important for Collingwood.

I'm still waiting to see how many players at Carlton get the usual pre-season season ending injury - before the season even starts - maybe it will be delayed this year because the rehab group so far only includes C Curnow/McGovern/Acres/Saad/Sivagni/Durdin/Cottrell and they havent really had a great opportunity to do themselves in as yet.

Carlton signed a big bodied defender into VFL this year - if he comes good ( apparently not good enough to make it at Hawthorn) he might feature in teh second half of the year- as an SSP signing. Meanwhile a hyphenated name from Hawthron ios battling against a bloke whoahs played 20 games in ten years ( and currrently delisted) in Durdin for a 2nd KPP place - a position that Carlton has crying out for since Jones decided to leave being allergic to syringes.

Cant comment on Sayers - I'm still laughing.