Who will win the Club Champion Award?

[cmndstab]

So why don't the four coaches votes match up then if there is a set criteria they are using?

For precisely the reason I explained in the very post you quoted - not everyone sees eye to eye.

People are not going to agree with each other over who has met the set of criteria most adequately, but there's a massive difference between that and choosing to rate someone more or less harshly based on your own political agendas.