Murray also could've polled 1-3 votes in all of the 19 games he played and yet still wouldn't have been close to making in the top 10
You're right, it would be nice to be able to see a breakdown of the voting for each game
2023 AFC Club Champion - Congratulations Jordan Dawson
- Thread starter Crow-eater
- Start date
- Tagged users None
You're right, it would be nice to be able to see a breakdown of the voting for each game
- Sep 3, 2018
- 5,337
- 7,042
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Max was well down from about the Essendon game onwards - not surprising he dropped out after a very good start
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Well he should have been top 10 easily on his season. That's not great from the coaching group there.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 19,209
- 37,957
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
That would have been piss poor voting given that’s what Sloane averaged from round 15 and he sucked
Murphy and Sloane as mentioned by everyone. Puzzling.
I don't think Murphy's as bad as he gets portrayed on this board but how does he make top ten?
Has anyone seen the criteria for the voting?
I don't think Murphy's as bad as he gets portrayed on this board but how does he make top ten?
Has anyone seen the criteria for the voting?
Effort not impact
Yeah, the real criteria, not BF's take.
I actually think that is REAL
I think he plays a different role to the players everyone compares him to. He obviously gets given his votes for the role he’s been given for the game not how well he didn’t do Soligo’s, Pedlar’s or Rachele’s role.
But would still need to play that role well
They must have thought he did
Yeh marginally less than Tex far better than Murray etc, we are in trouble
Multiballz
All Australian
- Feb 21, 2023
- 762
- 1,017
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Didnt show enough experience.
FR0GGY
From a cartel villa in Tuscany
Reckon it just goes to show how poor the voting format is.
For Murray to not be top 10 is baffling despite playing majority of games.
For Murray to not be top 10 is baffling despite playing majority of games.
It would influence their selection from week to week
- Sep 3, 2018
- 5,337
- 7,042
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Sloane voted pretty much as expected I would have thought. Pretty solid up until around mid year and then fell away as the year wore on
Murphy had a solid consistent year but very surprised he finished in he top ten
Is obviously not a top ten talent in the side.
Pedlar Rach Soligo will fly past next year with more consistency within games
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
It must be enormous disappointment for the Bigfooty “Experts” that three whipping boys (Smith, Keays and Murphy) finished in the top ten
.Clearly the coaches are clueless since the Bigfooty “Experts” (particularly those that only (occasionally) watch the team on the tellie) are the font of all wisdom. Wasn’t one fxxxen poster keen to trade Lairdy?
Dawson deserved to win and the top three were as expected imho.
Last edited:
It must be enormous disappointment for the Bigfooty “Experts” that three whipping boys (Smith, Keays and Murphy) finished in the top ten
Clearly the coaches are clueless since the Bigfooty “Experts” (particularly those that only (occasionally) watch the team on the tellie) Are the font of all wisdom. Wasn’t one fxxxen poster keen to trade Lairdy?
Dawson deserved to win and the top three were as expected imho.
This doesn’t make the point you think it does.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 19,209
- 37,957
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
So the voting gave you confidence in the coaches opinions? Or is your contribution just to have a crack at posters?It must be enormous disappointment for the Bigfooty “Experts” that three whipping boys (Smith, Keays and Murphy) finished in the top ten
Clearly the coaches are clueless since the Bigfooty “Experts” (particularly those that only (occasionally) watch the team on the tellie) are the font of all wisdom. Wasn’t one fxxxen poster keen to trade Lairdy?
Dawson deserved to win and the top three were as expected imho.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 19,209
- 37,957
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
He got 2 cheerleaders likes though
It’s disappointing all right, but if you seriously think we’re surprised or that our opinions should swayed by it, puh-leeease.It must be enormous disappointment for the Bigfooty “Experts” that three whipping boys finished in the top ten
Some of these high placings and the omission of certain others completely aligns with this club’s baffling “experience over everything” philosophy and just reinforces our opinion that…
Samcro24
Free Soda
- Oct 28, 2014
- 11,148
- 28,713
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Me waking up this morning seeing that Laird beat Tex.
Or what the coaches value highly in a player, doesn't win you games of footy
Similar threads
