List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets

[eastfreo75]

Warner would make almost as much difference as another quality tall would. Gun.

You can't play 22 midfielders.

 

[Joao]

You can't play 22 midfielders.

Well last time I checked we weren't at 21, so adding Warner should be ok.

 

[Superkoops]

So we had 7,8,49&58 what were we planning on using for matching Henry bid even if it fell as expected in the late teens? That’s pretty poor planning, no wonder we got bent over in the live trade we did.

We did a trade with Port Adelaide. We traded F2 for something like 50 and 52.

We then had something along lines of 49,50,52,58 to match bid and go around 200pt deficit the year after which was I think (after bids and taking off the mid first round compo pick GC received) dropping from 12 to 14 where we selected Chapman.

Freo should have bid on Green at either 7 or 8 and would have pushed Henry back one spot to 10 and given ourselves more time to negotiate trade of F2. I did the calculations at the time and it wouldn’t have made too much difference from memory. We benefited from that mid first round pick not causing our pick deficit to drop as much.

That same mid first round pick ended up with Geelong after GC traded it in one of the most stupid trades ever for pick 27 to select our recently acquired Jeremy Sharp.

The recruiters at GCS knew they were trading a pick valued around 12 for basically 27.

 

[Taylor]

There were murmurs pre draft that Carlton liked Henry, people were thinking it was probably too early but we showed our hand that we were definitely matching so Carlton used that to make time to trade

That was why we traded up ahead of them so they didn't bid and make us burn pick #10 matching it

 

[freo_leo29]

That was why we traded up ahead of them so they didn't bid and make us burn pick #10 matching it

Yeah it made up part of the reason for sure


Edit: article on it AFL draft 2019, pick swaps, AFL trades, Fremantle, Melbourne, Adelaide, Liam Henry

 

[Taylor]

We did a trade with Port Adelaide. We traded F2 for something like 50 and 52.

We then had something along lines of 49,50,52,58 to match bid and go around 200pt deficit the year after which was I think (after bids and taking off the mid first round compo pick GC received) dropping from 12 to 14 where we selected Chapman.

Freo should have bid on Green at either 7 or 8 and would have pushed Henry back one spot to 10 and given ourselves more time to negotiate trade of F2. I did the calculations at the time and it wouldn’t have made too much difference from memory. We benefited from that mid first round pick not causing our pick deficit to drop as much.

That same mid first round pick ended up with Geelong after GC traded it in one of the most stupid trades ever for pick 27 to select our recently acquired Jeremy Sharp.

The recruiters at GCS knew they were trading a pick valued around 12 for basically 27.

That GC pick was a locked to pick #11 selection given to them as a priority pick

 

[Superkoops]

That GC pick was a locked to pick #11 selection given to them as a priority pick

Thanks - I can’t remember how but that locked pick at 11 worked in our favour. I think the points deficit saw us only move to a certain pick rather that be pushed back further by 11. There were some bids in the top 10 but 11 was locked and we didn’t drop as far. Also from memory our pre draft position was helped by rounding of the points deficit. Anyway we had a small win of sorts and we ended up at 14 instead of say 15.

Also as to say a draft night locked pick 11 swap for 27 looks even worse.

 

[Rockmelon]

Initially I thought so but the combination of us passing on JVR and McDonald being dropped for the GF has swung things over the past year.

Now JVR is the Dees great white hope

True, if we were to go as hard at JVR as we are at McDonald I think we could tempt him

Don’t know if he’s worth it just yet and the Dees would be anxiously trying to tie him down long term as to not repeat what happened with Jackson

 

[JammoMonty]

Sorry I got you confused with JammoMonty. My point still stands about your accuracy though!

Would be surprised if he re-signed with the swans. The swans have what around 12 or 13 OOC players and are targetting JUH…

 

[JammoMonty]

Mate I’m way better. Where’s the confusion?

LooooooooL BF flex. Nothing more intimidating.

 

[JammoMonty]

Initially I thought so but the combination of us passing on JVR and McDonald being dropped for the GF has swung things over the past year.

Now JVR is the Dees great white hope

Freo had a strong conversation with McDonald after he was dropped for the GF. I’d be surprised if he stayed with Sydney with the offer Freo are putting up.

 

[Purple Jesus]

Freo had a strong conversation with McDonald after he was dropped for the GF. I’d be surprised if he stayed with Sydney with the offer Freo are putting up.

He wouldn’t have made a lick of difference to that shitshow.

 

[wakojako]

Freo had a strong conversation with McDonald after he was dropped for the GF. I’d be surprised if he stayed with Sydney with the offer Freo are putting up.

Who's going to be right? Stay tuned!

 

[Taylor]

Both can be right, we have four first round picks to play with, that should be far and above the price for three players when one of them is out of contract and another is not established.

 

[pK75]

Is the younger Worner any good?

 

[The Feeder Club]

Is the younger Worner any good?

There's a 15 year old Warner on the way that is supposed to be better than his two older brothers at the same age. Yikes

 

[JammoMonty]

Who's going to be right? Stay tuned!

View attachment 1865347
View attachment 1865349

Does anyone think this news will be big enough to push Harley Reid of the back page of the West?

 

[JammoMonty]

He wouldn’t have made a lick of difference to that shitshow.

You’re right, but that wasn’t what the post was alluding to. I attended that GF. Cats were on roids that day. Don’t even think the premiership pies would have got them last year.

 

[jimboslice]

Different sport I know but something to think about while we’re building and targeting other teams players. If you watch nba you know Paul George is a shell of himself now and Shai is an MVP candidate + all those picks.

Never sell the farm for one player

 

[wakojako]

Both can be right, we have four first round picks to play with, that should be far and above the price for three players when one of them is out of contract and another is not established.

There's like zero chance they take that deal unless we finish bottom 3 next year AND hold their families hostage at the trade table.

 

[Pussinbootz]

Different sport I know but something to think about while we’re building and targeting other teams players. If you watch nba you know Paul George is a shell of himself now and Shai is an MVP candidate + all those picks.

Never sell the farm for one player

View attachment 1865419

Had no choice but to overpay as OKC weren’t shopping PG at the time and Clips needed a co star to land Kawhi.

Realistically they got Kawhi & PG for that trade package.

 

[Superkoops]

Both can be right, we have four first round picks to play with, that should be far and above the price for three players when one of them is out of contract and another is not established.

Where did we get the fourth from?

Freo, Port, Collingwood,???

 

[Shadow Man]

Future 1st.

 

[Spirit Level]

Different sport I know but something to think about while we’re building and targeting other teams players. If you watch nba you know Paul George is a shell of himself now and Shai is an MVP candidate + all those picks.

Never sell the farm for one player

View attachment 1865419

Similar to the bounty the Cowboys got for Herschel Walker in the 80's, got us 3 superbowls.

 

[Purple Jesus]

You’re right, but that wasn’t what the post was alluding to. I attended that GF. Cats were on roids that day. Don’t even think the premiership pies would have got them last year.

My point was that if he is pissed that he was dropped because of the glory rather than thinking his inclusion would have benefited the team (it wouldn’t have) and enough so that he wants out as a result, that’s a red flag to me.