Personally i think we have given Nash enough changes and quite frankly i don't think he is AFL standard. Hopefully he proves me wrong.
2 Ruckman has not worked and Ceglar hardly provides any impact, so glad we have omitted him .
Still think Cousins is stiff ... but surely will get his...
I'm not a big fan of 2 rucks . Cegs is too slow and not really providing any impact . Although TOB can be frustrating i think he is better proposition.
Greaves foot skills is better then Howe, so i would persevere with him rather then Howe ..
This seems like a fitting game to manage Burgers...
This is terrible
- Stratton / Frawley are cooked
- Why is Bigboy not in Ruck
- Michington / Glass are not AFL standard
Hopefully we see more youngsters next week ..
Out: Smith (inj) O'Brien (omitted) Ceglar (omitted)
In : Jones, Patton , Burgoyne
Scully very lucky that Smith got injured, else was definitely on the chopping block .
Wingard, Jones,Burgoyne to rotate through the midfield .
Patton to provide backup for McEvoy .
- Not enough depth in the midfield . Great performances from Worpel and Wingard
- We need more run from the backline ( Impey is a big loss ) .
- Nash enough experimenting .. he is not up to it
- Poppy - cooked
Would like to see the likes of Cousins, Miles , Walker...
Will be disappointed if Duryea comes in . Still unsure why Miles has been overlooked .
I suspect Mirra for Stratton .. and Schoe for either
Ceglar / Nash .
I suspect if weather forecast is correct , there will be a late change .
Howe in for Schoe..
Surely to top heavy if there is rain tommorow afternoon/night.
in: Sicily, Frawley
Out; Mirra, Brand
Ceglar close, maybe conditions will depend if picked. Only concern is forward line will be not mobile enough with Ceglar at FF .
Although tempted, Birchall to play full game BH if available, and come in to the team the following game .
In: Rough, Ceglar, Henderson
Out: Shoenmakers, Pittonet, Glass
Although we have not lost with Schoe in the team ( 7-0) , i just feel he does not contribute enough .
Would also like to see how Nash works with Roughie in the forward line .
Hopefully Frawley can get up . Either way , team...
I think WX will be serviceable ...not too fussed about the selection.
O'Brien .. well i still don;t understand how is getting promoted to the AFL , when his form
in VFL is poor . Expect him to touch it around only 6 times , and have no influence on the game !!
FFS .. why OBrien ? .
He was given a good run in the start of season and went missing . his VFL form does not warrant his inclusion .
Possibly to play in defence ..because he wont mark or compete at
AFL level as a forward.
In: Brand, O'Rourke, Schoenemakers
Out: Frawley, Langford, O'Brien
Frawley - Cooked .. need to play Brand
Langford - Poor disposal and bad decision making .. not up to AFL standard.
O'Brien - Cannot mark, and goes missing in games ..enough chances provided .. needs time in VFL. Schoe ...
My thoughts :
- TOB really lucky to hold his position . Offers very little . Think Schoe is a better option structurally .
- Surprised with Langers inclusion . Considering O'Rourke's game for BH i would have thought he would have got the nod.
- Great to see Burgers back . Considering how...
Both Cousins and Willsmore have been in the bests for weeks in BH, so it is good to see
how they handle themselves going one step up. Happy for Brand coming in as well .
Would have preferred Heatherly to stay as he is our future,but Clarko has proven he is not going to drop Gibbo ,
even...
Not surprised with the ins ..
Brand -> Frawley
Duryea -> Stratton
Vickery -> Fitzy
Whitecross -> Cyril
Team structure seems unbalanced with WhiteX for Cyril . I guess we may play Burton forward and
Whitex in defence, hence why i would have preferred Stewart in instead of Doc.
Very disappointed with the omission of Brand. This year Brand has performed better then both Frawley and Gibson. I just don;t understand Clarko's logic. Surely if we cop another belting, then the likes of Stewart, Brand. Heatherly, Wilsmore must be given a 6-8 game run to see if they cut it...
Disappointed that Stewart was overlooked, hopefully he is a late in .
Personally i think TOB does not cut it at this level, and not sure how many more opportunities he will have .
Surely Willsmore will be given his opportunity soon if we continue to struggle .
Out: Hartung, Pittonet, Sicily
In: Langford, McEvoy, Stratton
Being wet, i thing Langers is better suited then Hartung , who has not yet shown enough
when the heat is really on.
Sicily slightly stiff as well,but once the ball hits the ground seems to struggle.
Need to omit either Frawley / Lake as playing one forward does not work .
Need more speed around the ground as well, Though knowing Clarko he
will only make 1 -2 changes .
Suckling - weak player under pressure and is a liability in defence
Hale - give him a week break , so we can have a look...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.