Mega Thread #14 David Mackay - 14 possessions again

[Golumless]

Ahhh the ol deflection technique ......some posters simply can't handle being exposed for their ignorance, can they .....brings out the dark side of people

This is a real "give a man an inch and they'll take a mile" moment for you.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Wayne melt again, take your meds son, the excitement if the night has got to you. Posters are free to correctly assess Mackay's game as being very good after a season of mostly poir to average. I'm sure the B&F voters will agree. Now take those tablets little fella.

Ahh the ol fence sitter ...who argues against both sides .....but is one of Mackays biggest critics because it's cool to do

 

[WaynesWorld19]

This is a real "give a man an inch and they'll take a mile" moment for you.

No not at all ......given all the threads started by the Mackay bashers who will slink away after tonight .....or more hypocritically, moderate their views on Mackay, after previiously viciously attacking him .......think it's appropriate to balance the ledger, don't you?

 

[DD#23]

Haven't been on the board a while heh? ........i've teed off all year on the ignorant Mackay bashers .....can't tackle (Goldstein) ....can't mark .....handballs too much ......the ignorance on player assessment is frankly laughable

oh give be a break, tonight was three standard deviations above the mean for Mr Mackay's season, and similarly over the odds against the rest of his illustrious 162 game career.

good work tipping his big break out though, keep holding it

 

[Godallblighty]

Ahhh the ol deflection technique ......some posters simply can't handle being exposed for their ignorance, can they .....brings out the dark side of people

Your dark side has been on permanent display this year. You used to temper your excesses with some reasoned discussion but now it's all point-scoring and self-pleasuring.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

oh give be a break, tonight was three standard deviations above the mean for Mr Mackay's season, and similarly over the odds against the rest of his illustrious 162 game career.

good work tipping his big break out though, keep holding it

Ahhh a statistician or accountant .....who thinks all football analysis is by numbers

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Your dark side has been on permanent display this year. You used to temper your excesses with some reasoned discussion but now it's all point-scoring and self-pleasuring.

Yep .....on this subject ....and only this subject, becuase the public assassination of Mackay on this board, a Crows player, has been disgraceful, ignorant, and absolutely social bullying

 

[WaynesWorld19]

So the Mods decide to close the thread:

What Mackay effort are you most looking forward to?

Tell me Drugs Are Bad Mackay? ....i assume you did this only because Mackay didn't live up to your expectations ......it most definitely would still be open if the game and Mackays efforts had gone as you expected / hoped......prey tell why you closed it off

 

[DD#23]

Ahhh a statistician or accountant .....who thinks all football analysis is by numbers

quite the opposite in fact, can't stand bean counters like Vader.

so give me your expert judgement, what next for Dave Mackay?

 

[Scrotes2000]

He has to back it up next week. I so badly want him to succeed - hoping he takes some confidence out of what he brought tonight.


There's always going to be a whiping boy Wayne. Mackay is ours, sometimes unfairly. I guess time will tell.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[WaynesWorld19]

quite the opposite in fact, can't stand bean counters like Vader.

so give me your expert judgement, what next for Dave Mackay?

I've posted that several times in regard to next season ......do the research on my posts (not this thread though ......so my thoughts are concrete and don't change qtr by qtr

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

So the Mods decide to close the thread:


Tell me Drugs Are Bad Mackay? ....i assume you did this only because Mackay didn't live up to your expectations ......it most definitely would still be open if the game and Mackays efforts had gone as you expected / hoped......prey tell why you closed it off

A couple of threads abusive to our players have been closed. The Mackay one and there was one bagging Walker a couple of weeks ago

 

[rezagun]

Reality is mackay has played shit most of the year and shouldve been dropped more than once. Through injuries and our selection decisions he has remained in the 22. He is lucky to be in the team atm. His performance tonight was what a player with his experience should provide on a weekly basis. Congrats to him on his great game, i hope its not a flash in the pan.

 

[Godallblighty]

Yep .....on this subject ....and only this subject, becuase the public assassination of Mackay on this board, a Crows player, has been disgraceful, ignorant, and absolutely social bullying

So, instead of offering up praise for one of our players, this thread is instead to be dedicated to your obnoxious crusaderism? Come on, mate.

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Very good game tonight…earnt back some credit after being heavily in debt! Next week the true test.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

A couple of threads abusive to our players have been closed. The Mackay one and there was one bagging Walker a couple of weeks ago

Thought normal form would be to delete the offending posts, rather than close the thread ?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

So, instead of offering up praise for one of our players, this thread is instead to be dedicated to your obnoxious crusaderism? Come on, mate.

Doesn't that work both ways .....if what Drugs Are Bad Mackay? says about closing the Mackay thread was in fact due to abuse being hurled at Mackay ......that's ok is it ? & IIRC you're one of the culprits .....but now you're offended

 

[Roo Lives Again]

Reality is mackay has played shit most of the year and shouldve been dropped more than once. Through injuries and our selection decisions he has remained in the 22. He is lucky to be in the team atm. His performance tonight was what a player with his experience should provide on a weekly basis. Congrats to him on his great game, i hope its not a flash in the pan.

Spot on

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Thought normal form would be to delete the offending posts, rather than close the thread ?

There wasn't really anywhere else for the thread to go after the OP!

 

[Jars458]

Really good game. Now to play four in a row and win us a flag

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Happy to see that he saved his best for when it mattered most. Hopefully, he can back it up because we can't afford any passengers next week.

 

[WetCrow1991]

Very pleased with his game. kicked within his limits and most of all contested well!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Reality is mackay has played shit most of the year and shouldve been dropped more than once. Through injuries and our selection decisions he has remained in the 22. He is lucky to be in the team atm. His performance tonight was what a player with his experience should provide on a weekly basis. Congrats to him on his great game, i hope its not a flash in the pan.

Lets talk reality shall we? ......Mackay played every available game bar 1 .......week off, all list players fit and available ......so the comment "he's lucky to be in the team" is just a plain rubbish statement

Fact is ..he wasn't dropped & if his form had been as you have posted weekly, he would have been dropped ....so clearly your opinion was influenced by other posters or you just can't accurately judge player performances

 

[Golumless]

A couple of threads abusive to our players have been closed. The Mackay one and there was one bagging Walker a couple of weeks ago

Keep the Mackay one open and sticky it after that performance. That got posted and we got one of the best games of his career.

Then delete it after his next average game.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Very good game tonight…earnt back some credit after being heavily in debt! Next week the true test.

Flip Flop