2009 Trade Discussion - Part 5

[larson]

dt site is stuffed, can't even get near the nrl dt...

f***!

 

[senrulzisback]

dt site is stuffed, can't even get near the nrl dt...

No, I need to trade out J.Riewoldt!

 

[bones25]

f***!

so its not just me then?

 

[Maestro15]

Crap I really need to trade. I've still got 2 hours though so it should be fine.

 

[Adamh707]

Don't trade Tuck, next two games are against Freo and Melbourne.

Thanks,

Think i will just take my two forward donuts and enjoy that sweet sweet feeling next week when they come back... If zeibell doesn't then hello yarran, i would expect hoops and higgins to play.

 

[Athomas]

I traded Houlihan to Fisher. Was contemplaying holding on, as he has a low BE and I have Suban EMG, but I figure Fisher is pretty durable, gettable BE, need more saints etc.

Backline is now: Goddard, Cornes, Fisher, Burgoyne, Lockyer, Mundy, Hill (Suban, Petrenko)

Yumm.

 

[The Cotch]

OUT: M.Brown, Walker
IN: S.Johnson, Sidebottom

Liking my team now.

BACKS: Goddard, Lockyer, C.Cornes, Enright, Adcock, Broughton, Petrenko, Hodge, Houlihan.

CENTRES: Bartel, Swan, K.Cornes, Vince, Coughlan, Rich, Otten, Anthony.

RUCKS: Cox, Mumford, Jacobs, Spencer

FORWARDS: Riewoldt, Deledio, S.Johnson, Franklin, Higgins, Krakouer, Sidebottom, Ziebell, Nahas

Only a few more upgrades to make with massive cash cows in Ziebell, Nahas and Otten. And once Hodge and Houlihan come back, my side will be neeeaaat.

 

[kangaroo19]

Just did 1 trade.

Picken > Cockie

Got $186k in the bank and don't know what to do with it just yet...

Could do Rich to Corey or Ziebell to Roo, but is it too early to get rid of them?

 

[Dimitri_Mishkin]

omfg I need to get into DT site!! Argh!

*brain explodes*

 

[magpies03]

traded rich to cockie
then otten to montagna

was tempted to go murphy but rekon they will both end up on similar points come season end. All in all pretty happy with both of them thought murphy will be more likley to bepicked up by other coaches....montagna may be a bit more unique

 

[senrulzisback]

Just did one trade, Jack Riewoldt out for ROK.

Please work out.

 

[magpies03]

Just did one trade, Jack Riewoldt out for ROK.

Please work out.

risky trade imo mate...
good luck with it tho

 

[C-Dog]

Was going to do nothing, but now considering Krakouer to ROK.

Argh Tough decision, have 18 trades left.

 

[ajay]

Just the one trade this week: Cloke > Franklin.
Gonna cop two doughnuts in the forwards, but none of my cows are quite there yet. Pity though, missing out on some bargains in the mid-field too. I'll be happy with my decision in Round 18 when I still have trades though.

 

[MightyIrons]

Just the one trade, which alot may disagree with, but have done my calculations and thought it through.

Ziebell->S.Johnson.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Just did Cloke to frontbum!

Trying to decide whether i should do otten to murphy

I know if i do he'll pull a hamstring and if i don't he'll rip it up

 

[magpies03]

Just did Cloke to frontbum!

Trying to decide whether i should do otten to murphy

I know if i do he'll pull a hamstring and if i don't he'll rip it up

dont touch montagna then

 

[magpies03]

Just the one trade, which alot may disagree with, but have done my calculations and thought it through.

Ziebell->S.Johnson.

Eyy Mate
dont be worryed about what other ppl think. If you have done your own calculations then back yourself in. Who knows ziebel maybe out for multiple weeks and come back and score very average.

Everyones team is different and we all need to pull the trigger on different players at diferent times. Personally i wouldnt of traded ziebel yet but i didnt need a forward its one less trade you have to make later. Good luck wif it

 

[kangaroo19]

Is Roo worth the price tag of $459k, or worth saving the $$ and going with JB? $90k difference.

Can do M Brown --> J Brown, or Ziebell to either J Brown or Roo.

Thoughts?

 

[Buddyman]

Who do u reckon out of Pav be99 SJ be54 the difference in price is 19k. Leaning towards Pav. thoughts would be appreciated!

 

[gizmo01]

Bullants have a bye this weekend.
Houlihan out for 2 more weeks then?

 

[Buddyman]

Im gonna go with pav after i looked at sj's scores before 149 after round 2 he didnt score 100 for 4 weeks. go pav tonight!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

 

[carlton__09]

My forward line is:
Chapman, Deledio, N.Brown
Higgins, Ziebell, Walker, Thomas

My options I believe are:

1. Thomas > ROK or J.Brown or Johnson
Ziebell > Sidebottom

2. Thomas > ROK
Wait on Ziebell means i have definitely 2 possibly 4 0's

3. Don't trade cop lots of 0's

Thoughts/ opinions???

 

[magpies03]

Is Roo worth the price tag of $459k, or worth saving the $$ and going with JB? $90k difference.

Can do M Brown --> J Brown, or Ziebell to either J Brown or Roo.

Thoughts?

Kangas i probably wouldnt trade tbh... definately wouldnttrade out ziebel yet imo has alot more price to go up and could even be a keeper.

Id be more favouring trying to scrape out another 30k and upgrading m brown to stevie j. Im not set on jono brown...im pritty hesitant on those big marking forwards havehaving to many in the team coz they tend to be very inconsistant and up and down. Thats just my 2 cents tho...if you think j brown has some goodscores in him go forit definately wouldntdo the ziebel trade tho.

 

[Pee Tear Griffin]

Ok. There are three different options I am assessing at the moment. I have 90k in the bank at the moment and facing 1 zero with Higgins out.

Option 1:

Do not trade this week, next week Petrenko-----> Grimes.

Option 2:

Petrenko ----> Grimes this week and Hentschel -----> Sidebottom (meaning I would have cover for Higgins)

Option 3:

Houlihan -----> Lockyer/Waite (meaning that I essentially use up all my spare cash and cannot trade Petrenko -----> Grimes next week, however it would provide me with a high scoring keeper to boost my score.)

Any help is greatly appreciated.